{"componentChunkName":"component---src-templates-blog-post-tsx","path":"/technical-debt-examples/","result":{"data":{"allContentfulCategory":{"edges":[{"node":{"contentful_id":"2gOurgpDj1BasZvVToN13z","slug":"tiny-sparks","title":"The Tiny Way"}},{"node":{"contentful_id":"2a3w396SgR2Fl1ep4eYu0w","slug":"product-management","title":"Product-Led Growth"}},{"node":{"contentful_id":"T7VZcLaLRpt6XlNLJPLmL","slug":"wysiwyg-world","title":"World of WYSIWYG"}},{"node":{"contentful_id":"6HNYGjOUjHzUS2gXBnMVXn","slug":"design-and-ux","title":"Content Marketing & Design"}},{"node":{"contentful_id":"6XFMYLCe4AEYIDazkjGFvb","slug":"engineering","title":"Developer Insights"}},{"node":{"contentful_id":"24ufWIsR0ImSvxvvIrutB5","slug":"open-source","title":"Open Source"}},{"node":{"contentful_id":"2fLgNI8yOMeZHNl1nSQ11","slug":"how-tos-and-tutorials","title":"How-to Use TinyMCE"}}]},"contentfulBlogPost":{"title":"Dangerous examples of technical debt in rich text editors","lastUpdated":"December 19th, 2022","publishDate":"2022-12-19T00:00+10:00","category":{"slug":"engineering","title":"Developer Insights","blog_post":[{"title":"Comparing Customization: TinyMCE vs. Froala","slug":"tinymce-vs-froala-customization","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Mar 24th, 2026","description":{"description":"<p>How TinyMCE and Froala compare on plugin depth, API extensibility, and collaboration features? Developer guide to customization ceilings and trade-offs.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"How TinyMCE and Froala compare on plugin depth, API extensibility, and collaboration features? Developer guide to customization ceilings and trade-offs."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Comparing Customization TinyMCE vs Froala","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hSfpSImgxOsHs4iIKlvbB/6919ae5955c4e2db9092985361be7d4a/-TinyMCE--Blog_Header-_Comparing_Customization__TinyMCE_vs_Froala.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Coco Poley","slug":"coco-poley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"TinyMCE vs Froala Customization: Plugins, APIs & Collaboration | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"How TinyMCE and Froala compare on plugin depth, API extensibility, and collaboration features? Developer guide to customization ceilings and trade-offs."}},{"title":"How to Discern Level of Effort to Integrate Collaboration in a Rich Text Editor","slug":"rich-text-editor-integration-level-of-effort-collaboration","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Feb 2nd, 2026","description":{"description":"<p>Learn how to estimate the level of effort required to integrate a rich text editor with collaboration features like comments, mentions, and version history.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Learn how to estimate the level of effort required to integrate a rich text editor with collaboration features like comments, mentions, and version history."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"How to Discern Level of Effort to Integrate a Rich Text Editor","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4a6Y89AUrMs3F9FBApjSa2/a999da5fe3da0f46fb01e6d7ea3b7426/Collaboration_Series_-5__How_to_Determine_Level_of_Effort_to_Integrate_a_Rich_Text_Editor_blog.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Coco Poley","slug":"coco-poley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"How to Determine Level of Effort to Integrate Collaboration in a Rich Text Editor | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Learn how to estimate the level of effort required to integrate a rich text editor with collaboration features like comments, mentions, and version history."}},{"title":"What to Expect During a Free Trial with TinyMCE","slug":"tinymce-14-day-free-trial-guide","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Feb 3rd, 2026","description":{"description":"<p>Learn what the TinyMCE 14-day free trial really offers: full premium features, framework integrations, support access, and what happens after day 15.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Learn what the TinyMCE 14-day free trial really offers: full premium features, framework integrations, support access, and what happens after day 15."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"What to Expect During a Free Trial with TinyMCE","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3o9qGwM2PgitaqxcfCBROx/6ef77a45182243650ea85c81549e41b6/What_to_Expect_During_a_Free_Trial_with_TinyMCE__1_.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Coco Poley","slug":"coco-poley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"What to Expect From the TinyMCE 14-Day Free Trial | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Learn what the TinyMCE 14-day free trial really offers: full premium features, framework integrations, support access, and what happens after day 15."}},{"title":"Why collaborative rich text editing is essential for modern products","slug":"collaborative-text-editing","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Mar 11th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>Looking for a text editor for your product? Find out why real-time, collaborative rich text editing is an essential feature for modern apps.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Looking for a text editor for your product? Find out why real-time, collaborative rich text editing is an essential feature for modern apps."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Stylized graphic showing three people reaching into the center, pointing and holding colored shapes.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.3333333333333333,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1qCGDGSz0tHzTKqXh309Q2/b69ee36e76042abcffbc721fe32096ef/Collaborative_Editing_.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1qCGDGSz0tHzTKqXh309Q2/b69ee36e76042abcffbc721fe32096ef/Collaborative_Editing_.png?w=185&h=139&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1qCGDGSz0tHzTKqXh309Q2/b69ee36e76042abcffbc721fe32096ef/Collaborative_Editing_.png?w=370&h=278&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1qCGDGSz0tHzTKqXh309Q2/b69ee36e76042abcffbc721fe32096ef/Collaborative_Editing_.png?w=739&h=554&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1qCGDGSz0tHzTKqXh309Q2/b69ee36e76042abcffbc721fe32096ef/Collaborative_Editing_.png?w=800&h=600&q=50&fit=scale 800w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1qCGDGSz0tHzTKqXh309Q2/b69ee36e76042abcffbc721fe32096ef/Collaborative_Editing_.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1qCGDGSz0tHzTKqXh309Q2/b69ee36e76042abcffbc721fe32096ef/Collaborative_Editing_.png?w=185&h=139&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1qCGDGSz0tHzTKqXh309Q2/b69ee36e76042abcffbc721fe32096ef/Collaborative_Editing_.png?w=370&h=278&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1qCGDGSz0tHzTKqXh309Q2/b69ee36e76042abcffbc721fe32096ef/Collaborative_Editing_.png?w=739&h=554&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1qCGDGSz0tHzTKqXh309Q2/b69ee36e76042abcffbc721fe32096ef/Collaborative_Editing_.png?w=800&h=600&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 800w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Elise Bentley","slug":"elise-bentley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Why modern products need collaborative text editing"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Looking for a text editor for your product? Find out why real-time, collaborative rich text editing is an essential feature for modern apps."}},{"title":"5 tools for checking mobile accessibility","slug":"5-tools-for-checking-mobile-accessibility","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Apr 26th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>Here are five things you can get started with right away when it comes to testing for mobile accessibility.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Here are five things you can get started with right away when it comes to testing for mobile accessibility."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Mobile device displaying color filters options","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6K40X0CdENUmHHcC5aaYDH/a8de64c661956b2b78c03bcb82444a9c/Image_default_5tools-MobileAccessibility.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6K40X0CdENUmHHcC5aaYDH/a8de64c661956b2b78c03bcb82444a9c/Image_default_5tools-MobileAccessibility.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6K40X0CdENUmHHcC5aaYDH/a8de64c661956b2b78c03bcb82444a9c/Image_default_5tools-MobileAccessibility.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6K40X0CdENUmHHcC5aaYDH/a8de64c661956b2b78c03bcb82444a9c/Image_default_5tools-MobileAccessibility.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6K40X0CdENUmHHcC5aaYDH/a8de64c661956b2b78c03bcb82444a9c/Image_default_5tools-MobileAccessibility.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6K40X0CdENUmHHcC5aaYDH/a8de64c661956b2b78c03bcb82444a9c/Image_default_5tools-MobileAccessibility.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6K40X0CdENUmHHcC5aaYDH/a8de64c661956b2b78c03bcb82444a9c/Image_default_5tools-MobileAccessibility.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6K40X0CdENUmHHcC5aaYDH/a8de64c661956b2b78c03bcb82444a9c/Image_default_5tools-MobileAccessibility.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6K40X0CdENUmHHcC5aaYDH/a8de64c661956b2b78c03bcb82444a9c/Image_default_5tools-MobileAccessibility.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6K40X0CdENUmHHcC5aaYDH/a8de64c661956b2b78c03bcb82444a9c/Image_default_5tools-MobileAccessibility.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Matthew Thackwell","slug":"matthew-thackwell"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"Functional debt vs Technical debt: What’s the difference in a rich text editor?","slug":"technical-vs-functional-debt","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"May 16th, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>What is functional debt compared to technical debt? Read on to find out how knowing the difference influences your technical debts.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"What is functional debt compared to technical debt? Read on to find out how knowing the difference influences your technical debts."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"the symbols that represent debt and it's affects, including time and money loss.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.780758556891767,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=1925&h=1081&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7p6SJvrwphZ1vTDomoRs5J/bc466e697ac16d79060b6c1b31f178e0/Tech_Debt_-7__1_.png?w=1925&h=1081&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Millie Macdonald","slug":"millie-macdonald"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Functional vs Technical Debt: Cost, Causes, Examples | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"We focus on what is functional debt compared to technical debt in software development. One example is the rich text editor, and the key differences in handling and prioritising those are discussed.\n"}},{"title":"CSS preprocessors and frameworks: streamlining your CSS development","slug":"css-development","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Aug 23rd, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>How do you approach CSS development? Find out ways to streamline your projects, including vanilla CSS, preprocessors such as LESS, SASS and SCSS, as well as Bulma and Bootstrap, plus utility-first frameworks like Tailwind CSS.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"How do you approach CSS development? Find out ways to streamline your projects, including vanilla CSS, preprocessors such as LESS, SASS and SCSS, as well as Bulma and Bootstrap, plus utility-first frameworks like Tailwind CSS."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"CSS, the initialism, appearing in a box, surrounded by colour, showing the design power of CSS","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.780758556891767,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=1925&h=1081&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1lrHp6Ww3gXvSDua3WTjDE/c68cbcea100165fd35106a8d881c21ce/CSS_preprocessors_and_frameworks__streamlining_your_CSS_development.png?w=1925&h=1081&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Marty Friedel","slug":"marty-friedel"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"CSS preprocessors and frameworks explained | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Dive into CSS development optimization with our guide. Learn about vanilla CSS, preprocessors like LESS, SASS, SCSS, and frameworks like Bulma, Bootstrap, and Tailwind."}},{"title":"Developer insights collection: resources, trends, and news","slug":"developers-insights-collection","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Dec 8th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>Tiny values developers knowledge, and we're sharing more developer insights in this collection.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Tiny values developers knowledge, and we're sharing more developer insights in this collection."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"developer resources and useful information on software and web development insights, trends, news and hacks represented by prompts on devices.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.0979142526071843,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=185&h=169&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=370&h=337&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=739&h=673&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=1109&h=1010&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=1478&h=1346&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=1895&h=1726&q=50&fit=scale 1895w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=185&h=169&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=370&h=337&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=739&h=673&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=1109&h=1010&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=1478&h=1346&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T30PcQr5caJ36AncUnwHu/e3e45e1719bfb883bc0538de9057b833/Image_DeveloperInsights_Design_1.png?w=1895&h=1726&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1895w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Developers resources collection: insights, trends and news | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Constantly updated overview of developer resources to keep an eye for the most useful information on software and web development insights, trends, news and hacks."}},{"title":"Real-time collaboration is the new responsive design","slug":"real-time-collaboration-essential","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Feb 3rd, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>Real-time collaboration is the new responsive design. We share why it&rsquo;s becoming essential for tools and what developers can expect.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Real-time collaboration is the new responsive design. We share why it’s becoming essential for tools and what developers can expect."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Different colored text boxes","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tEPRk1cyAfxNcKMYmaH7Z/40fb3d40c19ab4298810104f9d97f041/BlogImage_Jan2021_default_RTC-new-responsive-design.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tEPRk1cyAfxNcKMYmaH7Z/40fb3d40c19ab4298810104f9d97f041/BlogImage_Jan2021_default_RTC-new-responsive-design.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tEPRk1cyAfxNcKMYmaH7Z/40fb3d40c19ab4298810104f9d97f041/BlogImage_Jan2021_default_RTC-new-responsive-design.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tEPRk1cyAfxNcKMYmaH7Z/40fb3d40c19ab4298810104f9d97f041/BlogImage_Jan2021_default_RTC-new-responsive-design.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tEPRk1cyAfxNcKMYmaH7Z/40fb3d40c19ab4298810104f9d97f041/BlogImage_Jan2021_default_RTC-new-responsive-design.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tEPRk1cyAfxNcKMYmaH7Z/40fb3d40c19ab4298810104f9d97f041/BlogImage_Jan2021_default_RTC-new-responsive-design.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tEPRk1cyAfxNcKMYmaH7Z/40fb3d40c19ab4298810104f9d97f041/BlogImage_Jan2021_default_RTC-new-responsive-design.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tEPRk1cyAfxNcKMYmaH7Z/40fb3d40c19ab4298810104f9d97f041/BlogImage_Jan2021_default_RTC-new-responsive-design.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tEPRk1cyAfxNcKMYmaH7Z/40fb3d40c19ab4298810104f9d97f041/BlogImage_Jan2021_default_RTC-new-responsive-design.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tEPRk1cyAfxNcKMYmaH7Z/40fb3d40c19ab4298810104f9d97f041/BlogImage_Jan2021_default_RTC-new-responsive-design.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Wilkinson","slug":"ben-wilkinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Real-time collaboration is no longer optional"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Real-time collaboration is the new responsive design. We share why it’s becoming essential for tools and what developers can expect."}},{"title":"To OT or CRDT, that is the question","slug":"real-time-collaboration-ot-vs-crdt","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Jan 13th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>If you&rsquo;re playing around in the real-time collaboration space, you&rsquo;re likely to come across these terms: operational transformation (OT) and conflict-free replicated data type (CRDT). But what do they really mean? And which one should you use?</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"If you’re playing around in the real-time collaboration space, you’re likely to come across these terms: operational transformation (OT) and conflict-free replicated data type (CRDT). But what do they really mean? And which one should you use?"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Abstract illustration of text editor, containing text 'Hello World', and two cursors present.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lq18Ma2NAAtWvmZbaj7E4/a6e3872f74d3d43613b0e2355af79b0a/Image_default_rtc.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lq18Ma2NAAtWvmZbaj7E4/a6e3872f74d3d43613b0e2355af79b0a/Image_default_rtc.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lq18Ma2NAAtWvmZbaj7E4/a6e3872f74d3d43613b0e2355af79b0a/Image_default_rtc.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lq18Ma2NAAtWvmZbaj7E4/a6e3872f74d3d43613b0e2355af79b0a/Image_default_rtc.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lq18Ma2NAAtWvmZbaj7E4/a6e3872f74d3d43613b0e2355af79b0a/Image_default_rtc.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lq18Ma2NAAtWvmZbaj7E4/a6e3872f74d3d43613b0e2355af79b0a/Image_default_rtc.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lq18Ma2NAAtWvmZbaj7E4/a6e3872f74d3d43613b0e2355af79b0a/Image_default_rtc.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lq18Ma2NAAtWvmZbaj7E4/a6e3872f74d3d43613b0e2355af79b0a/Image_default_rtc.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lq18Ma2NAAtWvmZbaj7E4/a6e3872f74d3d43613b0e2355af79b0a/Image_default_rtc.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lq18Ma2NAAtWvmZbaj7E4/a6e3872f74d3d43613b0e2355af79b0a/Image_default_rtc.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Andrew Herron","slug":"andrew-herron"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Building real-time collaboration applications: OT vs CRDT"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"What do OT (Operational Transformation) and CRDT (Conflict-free Replicated Data Type) really mean? And which one should you use in your real-time collaboration solution?"}},{"title":"Adaptability is key to your success as a software developer","slug":"software-developer-qualities-adaptability","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jun 7th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>One of the most important software developer qualities is adaptability. Find out why it&rsquo;s so critical and how developers can be more adaptable.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"One of the most important software developer qualities is adaptability. Find out why it’s so critical and how developers can be more adaptable."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"A group of eight young adults crowd around a laptop.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2qCuzkMe5Mw3yXvl43jV5Y/ad7f614887d682612681731aba2adeca/Image_default_Adaptability.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2qCuzkMe5Mw3yXvl43jV5Y/ad7f614887d682612681731aba2adeca/Image_default_Adaptability.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2qCuzkMe5Mw3yXvl43jV5Y/ad7f614887d682612681731aba2adeca/Image_default_Adaptability.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2qCuzkMe5Mw3yXvl43jV5Y/ad7f614887d682612681731aba2adeca/Image_default_Adaptability.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2qCuzkMe5Mw3yXvl43jV5Y/ad7f614887d682612681731aba2adeca/Image_default_Adaptability.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2qCuzkMe5Mw3yXvl43jV5Y/ad7f614887d682612681731aba2adeca/Image_default_Adaptability.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2qCuzkMe5Mw3yXvl43jV5Y/ad7f614887d682612681731aba2adeca/Image_default_Adaptability.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2qCuzkMe5Mw3yXvl43jV5Y/ad7f614887d682612681731aba2adeca/Image_default_Adaptability.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2qCuzkMe5Mw3yXvl43jV5Y/ad7f614887d682612681731aba2adeca/Image_default_Adaptability.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2qCuzkMe5Mw3yXvl43jV5Y/ad7f614887d682612681731aba2adeca/Image_default_Adaptability.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Adaptability is key to your success as a software developer"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"One of the most important software developer qualities is adaptability. Find out why it’s so critical and how developers can be more adaptable."}},{"title":"A Tiny road to Reason","slug":"tinymce-reasonml","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Sep 21st, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>We are incorporating ReasonML in TinyMCE to take advantage of its guaranteed type safety, superb type inference, more advanced type system features, and the ability to compile to extremely fast native binaries.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"We are incorporating ReasonML in TinyMCE to take advantage of its guaranteed type safety, superb type inference, more advanced type system features, and the ability to compile to extremely fast native binaries."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Time-lapse photo of highway road at dusk, a stream of white light on the left and red on the right.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/769iuq6HFbLRFFch3CrhSy/d7cf38e382559adbf73aa7ef4e09d26e/Image_default_Road-to-reason.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/769iuq6HFbLRFFch3CrhSy/d7cf38e382559adbf73aa7ef4e09d26e/Image_default_Road-to-reason.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/769iuq6HFbLRFFch3CrhSy/d7cf38e382559adbf73aa7ef4e09d26e/Image_default_Road-to-reason.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/769iuq6HFbLRFFch3CrhSy/d7cf38e382559adbf73aa7ef4e09d26e/Image_default_Road-to-reason.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/769iuq6HFbLRFFch3CrhSy/d7cf38e382559adbf73aa7ef4e09d26e/Image_default_Road-to-reason.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/769iuq6HFbLRFFch3CrhSy/d7cf38e382559adbf73aa7ef4e09d26e/Image_default_Road-to-reason.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/769iuq6HFbLRFFch3CrhSy/d7cf38e382559adbf73aa7ef4e09d26e/Image_default_Road-to-reason.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/769iuq6HFbLRFFch3CrhSy/d7cf38e382559adbf73aa7ef4e09d26e/Image_default_Road-to-reason.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/769iuq6HFbLRFFch3CrhSy/d7cf38e382559adbf73aa7ef4e09d26e/Image_default_Road-to-reason.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/769iuq6HFbLRFFch3CrhSy/d7cf38e382559adbf73aa7ef4e09d26e/Image_default_Road-to-reason.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Andrew Herron","slug":"andrew-herron"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"TinyMCE’s Road to ReasonML"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"We are incorporating ReasonML in TinyMCE to take advantage of its guaranteed type safety, superb type inference, more advanced type system features, and the ability to compile to extremely fast native binaries."}},{"title":"Agile, waterfall, or hybrid: what’s right for your development team?","slug":"waterfall-vs-agile-development-team","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"May 7th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>Agile is almost synonymous with software development, but that doesn&rsquo;t mean your dev team should automatically adopt it. We talk about alternative approaches and what to expect when you transition to agile.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Agile is almost synonymous with software development, but that doesn’t mean your dev team should automatically adopt it. We talk about alternative approaches and what to expect when you transition to agile."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Pineapple painted pale orange and green sits on a blue background.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tDsBx08Z8InkWXqt5XOuk/2cf53cd6878ad6e5acb2d4dc828ae63a/Image_default_AgileWaterfallHybrid.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tDsBx08Z8InkWXqt5XOuk/2cf53cd6878ad6e5acb2d4dc828ae63a/Image_default_AgileWaterfallHybrid.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tDsBx08Z8InkWXqt5XOuk/2cf53cd6878ad6e5acb2d4dc828ae63a/Image_default_AgileWaterfallHybrid.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tDsBx08Z8InkWXqt5XOuk/2cf53cd6878ad6e5acb2d4dc828ae63a/Image_default_AgileWaterfallHybrid.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tDsBx08Z8InkWXqt5XOuk/2cf53cd6878ad6e5acb2d4dc828ae63a/Image_default_AgileWaterfallHybrid.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tDsBx08Z8InkWXqt5XOuk/2cf53cd6878ad6e5acb2d4dc828ae63a/Image_default_AgileWaterfallHybrid.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tDsBx08Z8InkWXqt5XOuk/2cf53cd6878ad6e5acb2d4dc828ae63a/Image_default_AgileWaterfallHybrid.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tDsBx08Z8InkWXqt5XOuk/2cf53cd6878ad6e5acb2d4dc828ae63a/Image_default_AgileWaterfallHybrid.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tDsBx08Z8InkWXqt5XOuk/2cf53cd6878ad6e5acb2d4dc828ae63a/Image_default_AgileWaterfallHybrid.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tDsBx08Z8InkWXqt5XOuk/2cf53cd6878ad6e5acb2d4dc828ae63a/Image_default_AgileWaterfallHybrid.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Dallas Clark","slug":"dallas-clark"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Should every software development team adopt agile?"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Agile is almost synonymous with software development, but that doesn’t mean your dev team should automatically adopt it. We talk about alternative approaches and what to expect when you transition to agile."}},{"title":"Comparing Implementing Collaboration: TinyMCE & CKEditor","slug":"tinymce-vs-ckeditor-collaboration-implementation","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Nov 25th, 2025","description":{"description":"<p>Compare collaboration features in TinyMCE and CKEditor, including comments, revision history, and real-time editing. Implementation effort included.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Compare collaboration features in TinyMCE and CKEditor, including comments, revision history, and real-time editing. Implementation effort included."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Comparing Implementation in CKEditor and TinyMCE","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3W3sUzUnjIF1kp32gUGVQI/a2f3012e87e992acbedeab4852416eb9/Comparing_Implementation_in_CKEditor_and_TinyMCE.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Coco Poley","slug":"coco-poley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"TinyMCE vs CKEditor: Collaboration Implementation Comparison"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Compare collaboration features in TinyMCE and CKEditor, including comments, revision history, and real-time editing. Implementation effort included."}},{"title":"Comparing Implementing Collaboration: TinyMCE & Froala","slug":"comparing-implementing-collaboration-tinymce-and-froala","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Nov 6th, 2025","description":{"description":"<p>Compare how much effort it takes to implement collaboration tools - comments, mentions, version history, and more - in TinyMCE vs Froala.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Compare how much effort it takes to implement collaboration tools - comments, mentions, version history, and more - in TinyMCE vs Froala."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Comparing Implementation in Froala and TinyMCE","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1m3Oz5274jXLX3XftB6Xu5/d8fe08bb03076779f11400d30413d0c7/_TinyMCE__Blog_Header__Comparing_Implementation_in_Froala_and_TinyMCE.jpg?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Coco Poley","slug":"coco-poley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Comparing Implementing Collaboration: TinyMCE & Froala | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Compare how much effort it takes to implement collaboration tools - comments, mentions, version history, and more - in TinyMCE vs Froala."}},{"title":"Comparing Implementing Collaboration Features: TinyMCE and Tiptap","slug":"collaboration-features-implementation-tinymce-and-tiptap-compared","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Oct 14th, 2025","description":{"description":"<p>Compare the level of effort to integrate collaboration into Tiptap and TinyMCE, and how much coding and configuration is necessary.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Compare the level of effort to integrate collaboration into Tiptap and TinyMCE, and how much coding and configuration is necessary."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Comparing Implementing Collaboration TinyMCE and Tiptap","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.780758556891767,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=1925&h=1081&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7BBFYSN5SWgsjNdMkF00H9/af69b9548a29e6acbd9fff4d3124cf8c/Comparing_Implementing_Collaboration__TinyMCE_and_Tiptap.png?w=1925&h=1081&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Coco Poley","slug":"coco-poley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Collaboration Features’s Implementation: TinyMCE and Tiptap Compared | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Compare the level of effort to integrate collaboration into Tiptap and TinyMCE, and how much coding and configuration is necessary."}},{"title":"Why TinyMCE Is the Right Rich Text Editor for CMS Projects","slug":"why-tinymce-is-the-right-rich-text-editor-for-cms-projects","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Oct 2nd, 2025","description":{"description":"<p>Find out why TinyMCE is the perfect rich text editor for CMSs, from collaboration features to content conversion to media optimization and more.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Find out why TinyMCE is the perfect rich text editor for CMSs, from collaboration features to content conversion to media optimization and more."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Why TinyMCE is the right solution for a CMS","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1TAGispnUU2xwtPVjoopsx/927256ed2a0f6bbfa52ea341e2faacfa/-TinyMCE--Blog-_-_-Why_TinyMCE_is_the_right_solution_for_a_CMS-.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Coco Poley","slug":"coco-poley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Why TinyMCE Is the Right Rich Text Editor for CMS Projects | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Find out why TinyMCE is the perfect rich text editor for CMSs, from collaboration features to content conversion to media optimization and more."}},{"title":"Full Page HTML Returns: Complete HTML Document Editing in TinyMCE 8.1","slug":"full-page-html-returns-tinymce-8-1","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Sep 30th, 2025","description":{"description":"<p>TinyMCE 8.1 brings back Full Page HTML&mdash;secure, modern, and built for complete HTML document editing for emails, reports, and CMS templates.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"TinyMCE 8.1 brings back Full Page HTML—secure, modern, and built for complete HTML document editing for emails, reports, and CMS templates."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"A screen shows an abstract of an editor that includes HTML markup, including the ability to edit both the head elements and the body element in a single screen.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4ymgkoblToFt0GvJ32Hwku/3a21f8f4ebc8a5ae86a2e82b7e59fa52/New_Full_Page_release.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Coco Poley","slug":"coco-poley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Full Page HTML Returns in TinyMCE 8.1 | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"TinyMCE 8.1 brings back Full Page HTML—secure, modern, and built for complete HTML document editing for emails, reports, and CMS templates."}},{"title":"Simplifying User Identity Management Across TinyMCE with User Lookup API","slug":"user-identity-management-with-user-lookup-api","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Aug 20th, 2025","description":{"description":"<p><span style=\"font-size: 11pt; font-family: Arial, sans-serif; white-space-collapse: preserve;\">Discover how the TinyMCE User Lookup API unifies user identity management across Comments, Revision History, and Suggested Edits.</span></p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"span","properties":{"style":"font-size: 11pt; font-family: Arial, sans-serif; white-space-collapse: preserve;"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Discover how the TinyMCE User Lookup API unifies user identity management across Comments, Revision History, and Suggested Edits."}]}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Simplifying User Identity Management Across TinyMCE with User Lookup API","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6JIHk6uxQAQymmfo9HEK5P/dfc3abab083915ae004a729c16c9132b/Simplifying_User_Identity_Management_Across_TinyMCE_with_User_Lookup_API.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Benjamin Chau","slug":"benjamin-chau"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Simplifying User Identity Management Across TinyMCE with User Lookup API | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Discover how the TinyMCE User Lookup API unifies user identity management across Comments, Revision History, and Suggested Edits."}},{"title":"Improving the Developer Experience with TinyMCE Developer Center","slug":"improving-developer-experience-with-tinymce-developer-center","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Aug 13th, 2025","description":{"description":"<p>Explore how TinyMCE is leveling up its developer experience in 2025 with the launch of the new Developer Center, tailored for real-world use cases.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Explore how TinyMCE is leveling up its developer experience in 2025 with the launch of the new Developer Center, tailored for real-world use cases."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"TinyMCE Developer Center","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4J9rhe3agXZVgj760rgCiZ/42dcc015dbe61b22457e163f392689ad/TinyMCE_Developer__Center.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Frédéric Harper","slug":"frederic-harper"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Improving the Developer Experience with TinyMCE Developer Center | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Explore how TinyMCE is leveling up its developer experience in 2025 with the launch of the new Developer Center, tailored for real-world use cases."}},{"title":"Tell Us What You Think: The 2025 TinyMCE Developer Survey Is Now Open","slug":"tell-us-what-you-think-the-2025-tinymce-developer-survey-is-now-open","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Jul 23rd, 2025","description":{"description":"<p>The 2025 TinyMCE Developer Survey is open! Share how you build with rich text editors and help shape the future of editing experiences.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The 2025 TinyMCE Developer Survey is open! Share how you build with rich text editors and help shape the future of editing experiences."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"2025 Rich Text Editors Developer Survey now open until August 5th, 2025","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7833333333333334,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=370&h=207&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=739&h=414&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=1926&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1926w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=370&h=207&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=739&h=414&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5qdYVJWkent9FOyuyplJgg/20d4adcbbb491871ef5405de711f9484/_BLOG_HEADER__Survey_Launch_Blog_Post_-_Tiny.png?w=1926&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1926w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Coco Poley","slug":"coco-poley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"2025 TinyMCE Developer Survey - Share Your Feedback Today | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"The 2025 TinyMCE Developer Survey is open! Share how you build with rich text editors and help shape the future of editing experiences."}},{"title":"Text editor developers 2023: Survey says RTEs are core component of everything","slug":"text-editor-developers","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Oct 3rd, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>Insights about developers who work with rich text editors: their experience, preferred programming languages and comparison to the previous year</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Insights about developers who work with rich text editors: their experience, preferred programming languages and comparison to the previous year"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Survey results represented by charts and percentages with several media images involved.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7Gxv5uyBVNHWaO4HvR4Gj/f0671b79dd25b449a71931c094fee426/text-editor-developers-in-2023_-77-say-a-rich-text-editor-is-critical-to-their-app-2023091920381562.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Di Mace","slug":"di-mace"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Text editor developers in 2023 | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"The freshest insights about developers who work with rich text editors: their experience, preferred programming languages as well noticeable changes in comparison to previous year."}},{"title":"Looking for a rich text editor? Start with our Rich Text Editor 2023 Survey","slug":"rte-motivation-expectations","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Nov 8th, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>Discover glimpses of the future through the rich text editor survey results, with trends showing more on&nbsp; users migrating, new technologies being employed, and more on AI</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Discover glimpses of the future through the rich text editor survey results, with trends showing more on  users migrating, new technologies being employed, and more on AI"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"charts and documents under investigation representing the survey results analysis","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7816836262719704,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=1926&h=1081&q=50&fit=scale 1926w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/35JZiiZ73QCRDt3soUGowG/e2085e9c0acb478d16752f45569deca0/img-looking-for-a-rich-text-editor_-see-the-future-in-2023-rich-text-editor-developer-survey-report-2023110621420531.png?w=1926&h=1081&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1926w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Di Mace","slug":"di-mace"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Motivation behind choosing rich text editors | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"We cover main motivations and expectations that lay behind the choice of building a rich text editor or using a third-party tool."}},{"title":"Working with rich text editors in 2023: Industry overview and challenges","slug":"rich-text-editors-industry-and-challenges","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Nov 1st, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>Insights from developers who work with rich text editors on the industry, editing experiences, main challenges and the most important features.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Insights from developers who work with rich text editors on the industry, editing experiences, main challenges and the most important features."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"The words industry overview and challenges with different charts and icons around it, including a happy face and pen","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7816836262719704,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=1926&h=1081&q=50&fit=scale 1926w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6buweme8KyJwSadjqtaPCP/238e17f126a484d76a1287802f71f9f0/img-working-with-rich-text-editors-in-2023_-industry-overview-and-challenges-2023101718551676.png?w=1926&h=1081&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1926w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Di Mace","slug":"di-mace"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Working with rich text editors: industry overview and challenges |TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Insights from developers who work with rich text editors on the industry, editing experiences, main challenges and the most important features."}},{"title":"Rich Text Editors 2023 Developer Survey: Highlights and trends towards AI","slug":"text-editors-highlights-and-trends","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Sep 13th, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>Find out rich text editing insights and trends gathered from our annual survey, which investigates the varied aspects and facets of rich text editing</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Find out rich text editing insights and trends gathered from our annual survey, which investigates the varied aspects and facets of rich text editing"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"AI, represented by a robot, reaches out for survey results and data","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7816836262719704,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=1926&h=1081&q=50&fit=scale 1926w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ln1R1Coal342UkFeYUhw5/07e5096214ee68f276234174ea39a5cb/img-rich-text-editors-2023-developer-survey_-highlights-and-trends-towards-ai-2023090719485963.png?w=1926&h=1081&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1926w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Di Mace","slug":"di-mace"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Rich Text Editors 2023 Developer Survey: Highlights and trends | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"The freshest insights on rich text editing trends and highlights on what has changed in comparison to previous year survey results."}},{"title":"Technical debt and types: The benefits of TypeScript vs JavaScript","slug":"benefits-of-typescript","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Jul 26th, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>Heavy technical debt burdens can sink a project. But selecting the right language can help keep debt down. Find out what the results are after weighing up JavaScript vs Typescript, based on TinyMCE's development history</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Heavy technical debt burdens can sink a project. But selecting the right language can help keep debt down. Find out what the results are after weighing up JavaScript vs Typescript, based on TinyMCE's development history"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"The rich text editor represented as a document symbol with TypeScript and JavaScript logos above it","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7816836262719704,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=1926&h=1081&q=50&fit=scale 1926w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xiNigXJElGz4ouNTELxiO/d4d4fe5378e2be8bc1921dad842d168a/Technical_debt_and_types__The_benefits_of_TypeScript_vs_JavaScript.png?w=1926&h=1081&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1926w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Millie Macdonald","slug":"millie-macdonald"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Benefits of TypeScript over JavaScript: tech debt and types | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Giving a preference to TypeScript vs JavaScript can have long term benefits in terms of dealing with technical debt."}},{"title":"What does it mean to be SOC2 compliant for SaaS?","slug":"soc2-compliance-meaning","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"May 18th, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>Is your data security practice working to protect your customers? Read on to find out how SOC2 compliance contributes to your data security.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Is your data security practice working to protect your customers? Read on to find out how SOC2 compliance contributes to your data security."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"The text \"Compliance\" written alongside a representation of SaaS in a cloud symbol","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.780758556891767,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=1925&h=1081&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2QUVwzLBzYHfvlnfmr6lXW/492ae4fd65ffe6661c9c33abe80e8941/What_does_it_mean_to_be_SOC2_compliant_for_SaaS___1_.png?w=1925&h=1081&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"John Rau","slug":"john-rau"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"What does it mean to be SOC2 compliant for SaaS? | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"SOC 2 compliance means that your company has been audited by an independent third party to ensure that your data security practices meet industry standards."}},{"title":"Dangerous examples of technical debt in rich text editors","slug":"technical-debt-examples","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Dec 19th, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>Read the story of our team's technical debt experience: handling cases of technical debt accrual in rich text editors, and how we approach the issue</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Read the story of our team's technical debt experience: handling cases of technical debt accrual in rich text editors, and how we approach the issue"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"An exclamation mark as a warning, representing the dangers of technical debt","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Millie Macdonald","slug":"millie-macdonald"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Dangerous examples of technical debt in rich text editors | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"In this post we talk about the examples of technical debt that our team has the most expertise in: cases of technical debt accrual in rich text editors and share how we approach these issues"}},{"title":"Managing technical debt is difficult in rich text editors","slug":"manage-technical-debt","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Nov 29th, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>We&rsquo;ve collected the aspects that can make or break your strategy of tech debt management - read on to find how.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"We’ve collected the aspects that can make or break your strategy of tech debt management - read on to find how."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Pie chart depicted in contrasting colours","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6R0dgGR7Une66VCag5E6Bz/3f09fcd022ea9991bb49499d9bbcd9cc/management-2-2022111614140854.png?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Millie Macdonald","slug":"millie-macdonald"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"How to manage technical debt in rich text editors | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Dealing with the technical debt of rich text editors isn’t easy. We’ve collected the aspects that can make or break your strategy of tech debt management."}},{"title":"What makes a secure text editor?","slug":"secure-text-editor","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Mar 23rd, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>When selecting a secure text editor one of the most significant considerations is security, which is why it's worth reading on to find out what makes a text editor secure.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"When selecting a secure text editor one of the most significant considerations is security, which is why it's worth reading on to find out what makes a text editor secure."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Security icons together on a blue background","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7775489186405766,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=1478&h=831&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=1726&h=971&q=50&fit=scale 1726w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=1478&h=831&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6qrNMdgVG6Fe5606ZKnppo/78ad6f291c2a2dc7cdb02b40530add78/what-makes-a-secure-text-editor_-2023031610315788.png?w=1726&h=971&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1726w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Elise Bentley","slug":"elise-bentley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"What makes a secure text editor? | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Discover the key considerations and features you should look for in a secure text editor. Learn why TinyMCE is a reliable and secure option for your text editing needs."}},{"title":"How to track and prioritize technical debt","slug":"technical-debt-tracking","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Feb 21st, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>The worst technical debt is unidentified technical debt &ndash; find out how to identify, track and prioritize technical debt.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The worst technical debt is unidentified technical debt – find out how to identify, track and prioritize technical debt."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Overlapping rings representing the converging concerns and focus needed for tech debt management","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6hQk4SjPBGK9MIa1F3TTju/d4ccfd4c1f4fe8cbfb2dd3d8c4fe0c97/track-and-prioritize-2023020212375488.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Millie Macdonald","slug":"millie-macdonald"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Technical debt tracking and prioritization | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"The worst technical debt is unidentified technical debt. In this article, we discuss how to identify, track and prioritize technical debt."}},{"title":"Are developer velocity and technical debt impacted by a rich text editor?","slug":"developer-velocity-and-technical-debt","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jan 17th, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>Find out how developer velocity is impacted by a technical debt following our rich text editor stories, and what can you do to improve it.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Find out how developer velocity is impacted by a technical debt following our rich text editor stories, and what can you do to improve it."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Time represented in a clock currently set at 3 O' Clock. ","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/pSCoh3sRCzJCGPQ1rLfTi/9d0994f65e8d7732aafecf44302421cc/developer-velocity-2022122007162835.png?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Di Mace","slug":"di-mace"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Developer velocity and technical debt: rich text editor impact | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"We’ll explore how developer velocity is impacted by a technical debt on the example of rich text editor, as well as what can you do to improve it."}},{"title":"Is your code half-life shorter than your engineering career?","slug":"rte-code-half-life","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Nov 8th, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>Find out more about Code half-life - a metric that provides interesting perspective on developer&rsquo;s work efficiency and product longevity</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Find out more about Code half-life - a metric that provides interesting perspective on developer’s work efficiency and product longevity"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"A graph represented as a line on grid background","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6cg9iKrkdj6a8hWynmgnZg/56f3a41a4879ef769b82c0bada47ac57/tech-debt-2-2022110213124606-2.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Di Mace","slug":"di-mace"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Half-life of the rich text editor code | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":" Code half-life metric provides interesting perspective on developer’s work efficiency and product longevity as its contributes to the technical debt your app is accumulating"}},{"title":"Reduce technical debt with the right rich text editor","slug":"reduce-technical-debt","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Oct 25th, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>The choice of your software components can either increase or reduce technical debt acquisition.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The choice of your software components can either increase or reduce technical debt acquisition."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"a graph showing a drop in costs associated with technical debt","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2xMpI8uNuoFJAcwMcL4KEC/c2a0da85780e387924db38955a0492bf/img-tech-debt-1-2022092912314335.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Di Mace","slug":"di-mace"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"How to reduce technical debt with the right rich text editor | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"The choice of your software components can either increase or reduce technical debt acquisition. Learn how your decision about RTE components can affect your tech debt."}},{"title":"Rich Text Editor developers in 2021: survey says full-stack all the way","slug":"rich-text-editor-developers-in-2021-survey-says-full-stack-all-the-way","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Nov 2nd, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>Usually considered a&nbsp;front-end UI&nbsp;component and/or API, it&nbsp;appears that rich text editors (RTEs) aren&rsquo;t the shy retiring components we&nbsp;all thought. They&rsquo;re primarily being used by&nbsp;full-stack developers, for more complex major projects.</p>\n<p>&nbsp;</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Usually considered a front-end UI component and/or API, it appears that rich text editors (RTEs) aren’t the shy retiring components we all thought. They’re primarily being used by full-stack developers, for more complex major projects."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":" "}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Post 1 in our series exploring the results of the 2021 rich text editor survey.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":2.4767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=185&h=75&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=370&h=149&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=739&h=298&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=1109&h=448&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=1478&h=597&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=2130&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 2130w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=185&h=75&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=370&h=149&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=739&h=298&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=1109&h=448&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=1478&h=597&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/68vHF42PTMjZuY8LEa2Sf6/0fee9ed609ad60c413910c96ef23ca00/Image_Developer_Survey_post_1.png?w=2130&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 2130w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Di Mace","slug":"di-mace"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Tech stack used with rich text editors in 2021 | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Key findings from developers using rich text editors on programming language and front end frameworks – can you guess what’s used the most often?"}},{"title":"State of Rich Text Editor 2021 Survey uncovers hidden hero of content creation","slug":"state-of-rich-text-editor-2021-survey-results","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Oct 26th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>Rich text editors are the silent heroes of the content revolution. The State of Rich Text&nbsp;<br />Editor 2021 Survey encouraged industry-wide feedback from the developer community and product managers. 500 people share their stories, and &nbsp;you can read the full report now, as well as analysis of the results to stay up-to-date with trends in rich text editing.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Rich text editors are the silent heroes of the content revolution. The State of Rich Text "},{"type":"element","tagName":"br","properties":{},"children":[]},{"type":"text","value":"Editor 2021 Survey encouraged industry-wide feedback from the developer community and product managers. 500 people share their stories, and  you can read the full report now, as well as analysis of the results to stay up-to-date with trends in rich text editing."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"You can read our analysis, and download the results, of the rich text editor survey 2021.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":2.4767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=185&h=75&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=370&h=149&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=739&h=298&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=1109&h=448&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=1478&h=597&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=2130&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 2130w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=185&h=75&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=370&h=149&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=739&h=298&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=1109&h=448&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=1478&h=597&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/j1o8o0rad7oiiBKWiLbHj/5b0ae7aacc305c42cd86cb21accb3bc4/dev-page-summary-2.png?w=2130&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 2130w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Di Mace","slug":"di-mace"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"\n"}},{"title":"TinyMCE’s Highlights from AITX Meetup 2025 & What’s Next","slug":"aitx-meetup-2025","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Apr 15th, 2025","description":{"description":"<p>TinyMCE joined the AITX 2025 Meetup to connect with devs and founders innovating with AI and web tech. See the event highlights and upcoming meetups.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"TinyMCE joined the AITX 2025 Meetup to connect with devs and founders innovating with AI and web tech. See the event highlights and upcoming meetups."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"TinyMCE at AITX Austin Meetup","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KrBiRKOUdS4x4urYerK7M/135dc1bda04bf83a8984ec5c210cb72a/AITX_Autin_Meetup_Post_Event_Blog_updated.jpg?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Mrina Sugosh","slug":"mrina-sugosh"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"TinyMCE at AITX 2025: Event Highlights & What’s Next | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"TinyMCE joined the AITX 2025 Meetup to connect with devs and founders innovating with AI and web tech. See the event highlights and upcoming meetups."}},{"title":"Key Takeaways from Umbraco Spark 2025","slug":"key-takeaways-from-umbraco-spark-2025","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Apr 4th, 2025","description":{"description":"<p>Explore top takeaways from Umbraco Spark 2025, from caching and observability to TinyMCE innovations for Umbraco 14+. Plus, don&rsquo;t miss our May webinar!</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Explore top takeaways from Umbraco Spark 2025, from caching and observability to TinyMCE innovations for Umbraco 14+. Plus, don’t miss our May webinar!"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Umbraco Spark Event Recap 2025 by TinyMCE","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zPeaYFT8YEprNdFrf6XvA/8d06d556c7c2e1bee8546f39001d62e1/-BLOG_HEADER-_-BLOG-_Umbraco_Spark_Event_Recap_2025.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Mrina Sugosh","slug":"mrina-sugosh"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Key Takeaways from Umbraco Spark 2025 | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Explore top takeaways from Umbraco Spark 2025, from caching and observability to TinyMCE innovations for Umbraco 14+. Plus, don’t miss our May webinar!"}},{"title":"Learn with TinyMCE at MLH Global Hack Week AI/ML: Workshop Replays","slug":"learn-with-tinymce-mlh-global-hack-week-ai-workshop-replays","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Mar 13th, 2025","description":{"description":"<p>Missed the MLH Global Hack Week AI/ML? Watch TinyMCE's workshop replays to learn how to enhance your AI/ML projects with a powerful rich text editor!</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Missed the MLH Global Hack Week AI/ML? Watch TinyMCE's workshop replays to learn how to enhance your AI/ML projects with a powerful rich text editor!"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Global Hack Week AI/ML 2025 Event Recap","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6BGJYvIEUBleufd0Yjt8DN/f4d2b5d3587292001459561171be5f28/-TinyMCE--Blog-_Global_Hack_Week_Event_Recap.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Coco Poley","slug":"coco-poley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Learn with TinyMCE at MLH Global Hack Week AI/ML: Workshop Replays | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Missed the MLH Global Hack Week AI/ML? Watch TinyMCE's workshop replays to learn how to enhance your AI/ML projects with a powerful rich text editor!"}},{"title":"Join TinyMCE at MLH Global Hack Week AI/ML to Build an Email Editor with AI","slug":"join-tinymce-at-mlh-ai-ml-hackweek-build-with-ai","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Feb 5th, 2025","description":{"description":"<p>TinyMCE welcomes developers to join us for an Angular session and a Laravel session, each on creating an email editor with a different AI IDE.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"TinyMCE welcomes developers to join us for an Angular session and a Laravel session, each on creating an email editor with a different AI IDE."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Build an Email Editor with AI at MLH Global Hack Week AI/ML","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1jcdt2u9lnJtYrOlL1Khxy/57b88c2c3e5320dea6b0d28838d009ce/_BLOG_HEADER__Review_MLH_Pre-event_Blog_v1.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Coco Poley","slug":"coco-poley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Join TinyMCE at MLH Global Hack Week AI/ML to Build with AI | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"TinyMCE welcomes developers to join us for an Angular session and a Laravel session, each on creating an email editor with a different AI IDE."}},{"title":"Meet the Top Experts at Frontend Nation 2024 with TinyMCE","slug":"tinymce-frontend-nation-expert-interviews","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Nov 7th, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>Explore key takeaways from TinyMCE&rsquo;s interviews with tech experts at Frontend Nation.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Explore key takeaways from TinyMCE’s interviews with tech experts at Frontend Nation."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"An image of Mrina Sugosh and a speech bubble that says Key Insights from Industry Experts","artistName":"TinyMCE","image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/24VeBYN2sU2qt3AyyJ3B4z/aa66e0398cd42bbd2991fe243de8cc2c/Frontend_Nation_Post_Event_Blog_-_Interviews__1_.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Mrina Sugosh","slug":"mrina-sugosh"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Frontend Nation 2024: Key Insights from Industry Experts | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Explore key takeaways from TinyMCE’s interviews with tech experts at Frontend Nation."}},{"title":"TinyMCE Sponsors and Presents at Frontend Nation Online Event","slug":"tinymce-at-frontend-nation-online-event","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jun 3rd, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>TinyMCE will be attending Frontend Nation, a virtual event that brings together front-end developers, designers, and tech enthusiasts worldwide. As Diamond sponsors, Tiny is excited to present talks and workshops to help attendees understand the power a rich text editor can bring to their applications, and how to do it.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"TinyMCE will be attending Frontend Nation, a virtual event that brings together front-end developers, designers, and tech enthusiasts worldwide. As Diamond sponsors, Tiny is excited to present talks and workshops to help attendees understand the power a rich text editor can bring to their applications, and how to do it."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Blog banner promoting TinyMCE at the Frontend Nation event June 4th - 7th 2024 ","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3PAUJnDIil2svWxT6bOGLw/3e7b89a0917699adbc8c76d03c8998bb/Final_TinyMCE_Sponsors_and_Presents_at_Frontend_Nation_Online_Event1.jpg?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Team Tiny","slug":"team-tiny"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"5 steps to build and improve your QA process","slug":"5-steps-to-build-and-improve-your-qa-process","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Sep 17th, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>Discover the essential steps to build and improve your QA process. Learn best practices and tools to ensure software quality.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Discover the essential steps to build and improve your QA process. Learn best practices and tools to ensure software quality."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Shapes representing the vital steps in a QA process","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2FE0jPLhO8j8oGnZ3BkXfK/204461c97e571703683da746f1141366/5_steps_to_build_and_improve_your_QA_process.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Shiridi Gandham","slug":"shiridi-gandham"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"5 steps to build and improve your QA process | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Discover the essential steps to build and improve your QA process. Learn best practices and tools to ensure software quality."}},{"title":"Angular vs React vs Vue - Detailed Framework Comparison","slug":"vue-react-angular-js-framework-comparison","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Aug 30th, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>Discover which framework is best for your project. Our detailed comparison of Angular, React, and Vue covers performance, scalability, and community support.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Discover which framework is best for your project. Our detailed comparison of Angular, React, and Vue covers performance, scalability, and community support."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Angular vs React vs Vue trends for each of the two frameworks and a library represented as symbols","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2zovvGaRy7UQ9jXMreHkR2/9400d5dc095753a0bf86f93888e87340/-Blog_Header-__-Rework_-14-_Angular_vs_React_vs_Vue.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Coco Poley","slug":"coco-poley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Angular vs React vs Vue: Detailed Framework Comparison | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Discover which framework is best for your project. Our detailed comparison of Angular, React, and Vue covers performance, scalability, and community support."}},{"title":"Supercharge Your Learning Management System with TinyMCE 7","slug":"supercharge-your-lms-in-tinymce-7-webinar","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Aug 27th, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>Learn how TinyMCE 7 enhances your Learning Management System in our webinar. Get expert tips and see the features in action.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Learn how TinyMCE 7 enhances your Learning Management System in our webinar. Get expert tips and see the features in action."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"A picture of a book, media, spellcheck, and revision history to show learning management systems with TinyMCE","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7l6vsSzRu7xyED9vZgAn1G/5eddb92a34cff554382e07daab6c10a7/Supercharge_Your_Learning_Management_System_with_TinyMCE_7.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Bee Lawless","slug":"bee-lawless"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Supercharge Your Learning Management System with TinyMCE 7"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Learn how TinyMCE 7 enhances your Learning Management System in our webinar. Get expert tips and see the features in action."}},{"title":"Frontend Nation 2024: Exploring DevRel, Full Stack, and AI-Powered Apps","slug":"frontend-conference-wrapup","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Jul 3rd, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>This year&rsquo;s Frontend Nation conference was held from June 4th through 7th and showcased an impressive array of technical sessions and discussions, establishing itself as a must-attend event for front-end and full-stack developers globally. As Diamond sponsors for this year's event, TinyMCE had a front-row seat for this completely free, virtual conference. Read about the highlights that caught our attention!</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"This year’s Frontend Nation conference was held from June 4th through 7th and showcased an impressive array of technical sessions and discussions, establishing itself as a must-attend event for front-end and full-stack developers globally. As Diamond sponsors for this year's event, TinyMCE had a front-row seat for this completely free, virtual conference. Read about the highlights that caught our attention!"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Header image for the TinyMCE Fronend Nation 2024 Conference wrap up post that displays the logos for TinyMCE and Frontend Nation. ","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/27GgjDXGXoRRLWmBjVtOXv/624a5780405e8338b0278dc7a69bc2c9/Frontend_Nation_Wrapup_Post.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Mrina Sugosh","slug":"mrina-sugosh"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Frontend Nation 2024: TinyMCE Wrap-up"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Explore the highlights from Frontend Nation 2024, featuring DevRel insights, full stack and front end development, and OpenAI integration."}},{"title":"Understanding Uncaught TypeErrors in JavaScript","slug":"javascript-uncaught-typeerror","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Mar 7th, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>It's time for a refresh (or an introduction) to understanding and solving JavaScript Uncaught TypeErrors.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"It's time for a refresh (or an introduction) to understanding and solving JavaScript Uncaught TypeErrors."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Uncaught TypeErrors appears inside an editor with the JavaScript Icon, with colors capturing the error handling phase","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4M7RjXxIVOXAHZphdOOR0Q/d92f16510de2bfbcce97ac77a9212661/img-Understanding_uncaught_type_errors.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Understanding JavaScript uncaught type errors | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Discover all you need to know to solve JavaScript Uncaught TypeError messages, the most common kind of error you'll face learning JavaScript"}},{"title":"Understanding byte offset and WYSIWYG cursor position","slug":"byte-offset","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Apr 18th, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>Byte offsets, and how they affect WYSIWYGs, is important to know. Read on to find out more.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Byte offsets, and how they affect WYSIWYGs, is important to know. Read on to find out more."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"images representing javascript and numbers around the rich text editor","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7833333333333334,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=370&h=207&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=739&h=414&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=1926&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1926w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=370&h=207&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=739&h=414&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4IVzxBAQGLCegTCvwqBpSr/ec866cf7e42753fb7d7f9995307dacd2/Design_1.jpg?w=1926&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1926w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Understanding byte offset and byte offset meaning | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Find out the important byte offset information you need to know to understand more about byte offsets in your WYSIWYG"}},{"title":"Understanding cross platform app development","slug":"cross-platform-app-development","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Feb 21st, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>Getting started with cross platform app development is not without challenges. Find out the essentials in our new guide.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Getting started with cross platform app development is not without challenges. Find out the essentials in our new guide."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"The steps of cross platform app development shown with Android icons, a phone interface, and iOS icons","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6VjjHZN8Kr1nKHY4SJJerz/60d0ed9bae480cbf511582778f7796eb/img-Understanding-cross-platform-app-development-1.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"What is cross platform app development | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Cross platform app development can save time and resources, but it's not without challenges. Find out more about cross platform app development in our new guide."}},{"title":"Is there anything better than React? Discovering React alternatives","slug":"react-alternatives","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Feb 8th, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>What are the React alternatives? Find out what frameworks provide an answer when React isn't the right choice.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"What are the React alternatives? Find out what frameworks provide an answer when React isn't the right choice."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"A rocket launch showing the power of React","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4hsGQMZeid58sjsjKPwbw1/8a4af88ccd3792f3e764fcf7c6a36348/img-anything-better-than-React-1.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Is there anything better than React? Discovering React alternatives | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Explore top alternatives to React JS, evaluate its competitors, and learn how to choose the right framework for your needs."}},{"title":"Improving our engineering best practices with semantic versioning","slug":"improving-our-engineering-best-practices-with-semantic-versioning","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Feb 7th, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>What is semantic versioning, and what does it mean for you? Switching to semantic versioning is just one step you can take for engineering best practice.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"What is semantic versioning, and what does it mean for you? Switching to semantic versioning is just one step you can take for engineering best practice."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"The different stages and levels representing the specific numbering found in semantic versioning","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/Bd9ENssvqhYSiDbIORoTr/269ba3a4694f50bfe57506ecc8e4d3ca/img-Software-Versioning-best-1.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Millie Macdonald","slug":"millie-macdonald"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"Agile at Tiny: How we’ve adapted agile principles to work for us","slug":"agile-principles-at-tiny","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jan 17th, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>How do we use agile principles at Tiny? Find out how we put agile into practice and adapt the concepts to work for our teams.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"How do we use agile principles at Tiny? Find out how we put agile into practice and adapt the concepts to work for our teams."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"A collection of Agile related imagery such as notebooks, pinned cards, and a stop watch","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2deNFqN8uYnV3qCLfs4nR0/c9d8e0c108baa1cf58b0eaab0b748174/img-Using-agile-principles-adopt-or-adapt-1.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Using Agile principles: To adopt or adapt? | Tiny"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"How do we use agile principles at Tiny? Find out how we put agile into practice and adapt the concepts to work for our teams."}},{"title":"How to work with PHP escape quotes","slug":"php-escape","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Dec 7th, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>There's more to PHP escape quote procedures than using a backslash. Read on to find out the essentials of handling PHP escape characters.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"There's more to PHP escape quote procedures than using a backslash. Read on to find out the essentials of handling PHP escape characters."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"PHP content escaping a page, representing the PHP escape quote process","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3EihLXXBO1fnatkO9ozUld/884edeb3c23d2335cc3c4e56e9c36a38/img-Howto-work-with-PHP-escape-quotes.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"How to work with PHP escape quotes and characters | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Master PHP escape sequences with our guide. Learn string escape basics, single vs double quote usage, and how to navigate heredoc syntax."}},{"title":"How to get content and set content in TinyMCE","slug":"how-to-get-content-and-set-content-in-tinymce","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Jan 24th, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>A brief guide on how to get and set content in TinyMCE, including related FAQs like how to set content on initialization and how to get content without any HTML tags.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"A brief guide on how to get and set content in TinyMCE, including related FAQs like how to set content on initialization and how to get content without any HTML tags."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"All kinds of content including text, video, and images being collected and set in an editor","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.780758556891767,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=1925&h=1081&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ElZ819XSaYszxbXjWNQIm/0b9d3a3f5f46c2a6ecccb3b3d3db954b/How_to_get_content_and_set_content_in_TinyMCE.png?w=1925&h=1081&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"How to get content from the editor and set content | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"How to get content from the TinyMCE editor in JavaScript. How to set content in TinyMCE. How to get content out of TinyMCE without HTML tags."}},{"title":"2024 State of Rich Text Editors Developer Survey is open – have your say!","slug":"tinys-developer-survey","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Mar 8th, 2024","description":{"description":"<p>Announcing our developer survey! Tiny aims to lead innovation, and with your help, we hope to learn what the best practices are and how to cater to future needs of our community.&nbsp;</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Announcing our developer survey! Tiny aims to lead innovation, and with your help, we hope to learn what the best practices are and how to cater to future needs of our community. "}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"A symbolic version of a survey, with star rating, emoji, questions, and results represented.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7790178571428572,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=1478&h=831&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=1594&h=896&q=50&fit=scale 1594w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=1478&h=831&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5RkV4KkTsTDLYV5q0UwlHY/f0669377994d735f6a01ec7becfde967/image__1_.png?w=1594&h=896&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1594w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Di Mace","slug":"di-mace"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Annual developer survey for rich text editors opens now | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"The TinyMCE annual developer survey for the state of rich text editors is now open! Have your say on how you develop software with rich text editors."}},{"title":"Angular Change Detection and the OnPush strategy","slug":"angular-change-detection-onpush-strategy","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Mar 7th, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>There is an alternative method for detecting value changes faster in Angular applications with immutable reference types and the OnPush strategy. Read on to find out how this works.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"There is an alternative method for detecting value changes faster in Angular applications with immutable reference types and the OnPush strategy. Read on to find out how this works."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Angular logo on a yellow background with process elements","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7777777777777777,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=1478&h=831&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=1920&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1920w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=1478&h=831&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1LXmifcjJCDfpxF9LDdwnI/849dce013c1618601b0333fdc7a093f5/An_Angular_5_tutorial__step-by-step_guide_to_your_first_Angular_5_app.png?w=1920&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1920w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ahmet Shapiro-Erciyas","slug":"ahmet-shapiro-erciyas"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Angular change detection: how it works and strategies explained | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"AngularJS's change detection is one of its most powerful features. In this article we explain how it works and review some strategies for using it effectively."}},{"title":"Lessons learned over 20 years as a web developer","slug":"lessons-learned-over-20-years-as-a-web-developer","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Oct 5th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>A discussion of the top five areas of expertise that no web developer should be without, covering performance and optimization, tools, image compression, testing, and approaches to learning.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"A discussion of the top five areas of expertise that no web developer should be without, covering performance and optimization, tools, image compression, testing, and approaches to learning."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"The number 20.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6amp8fmeVDhXPf8o6nxzBC/65575f34ce81cc2cca8e7dba6c5d68d8/Image_default_LessonsLearned.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6amp8fmeVDhXPf8o6nxzBC/65575f34ce81cc2cca8e7dba6c5d68d8/Image_default_LessonsLearned.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6amp8fmeVDhXPf8o6nxzBC/65575f34ce81cc2cca8e7dba6c5d68d8/Image_default_LessonsLearned.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6amp8fmeVDhXPf8o6nxzBC/65575f34ce81cc2cca8e7dba6c5d68d8/Image_default_LessonsLearned.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6amp8fmeVDhXPf8o6nxzBC/65575f34ce81cc2cca8e7dba6c5d68d8/Image_default_LessonsLearned.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6amp8fmeVDhXPf8o6nxzBC/65575f34ce81cc2cca8e7dba6c5d68d8/Image_default_LessonsLearned.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6amp8fmeVDhXPf8o6nxzBC/65575f34ce81cc2cca8e7dba6c5d68d8/Image_default_LessonsLearned.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6amp8fmeVDhXPf8o6nxzBC/65575f34ce81cc2cca8e7dba6c5d68d8/Image_default_LessonsLearned.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6amp8fmeVDhXPf8o6nxzBC/65575f34ce81cc2cca8e7dba6c5d68d8/Image_default_LessonsLearned.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6amp8fmeVDhXPf8o6nxzBC/65575f34ce81cc2cca8e7dba6c5d68d8/Image_default_LessonsLearned.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Marty Friedel","slug":"marty-friedel"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"A how-to guide to SVG animation","slug":"guide-svg-animation","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Aug 29th, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>Find out different ways you can animate SVG with HTML, CSS, and JavaScript.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Find out different ways you can animate SVG with HTML, CSS, and JavaScript."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"SVG animation","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/AmJMd7T2Cbyjxwx8g4YrA/a2246d2d63ffe3542c5a5490991ab6fa/img-svg-howto-tinymce.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Juan Calou","slug":"juan-calou"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"How to create SVG animations | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Guide on different ways you can animate SVG with HTML, CSS, JavaScript with detailed instructions and examples."}},{"title":"Software development trends 2023: Stack Overflow survey analysis","slug":"software-development-trends","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Oct 4th, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>Curious about your career direction? Stack Overflow's software developer survey has some useful career insights. Read on to find out about education, business size, and AI adoption.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Curious about your career direction? Stack Overflow's software developer survey has some useful career insights. Read on to find out about education, business size, and AI adoption."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Charts and code brackets are arrayed together with a robot character completing results analysis","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/wpK4Dky9vEeRjCrUC76HV/66974732f1d0f49234f332fbc669e579/TinyMCE___-Blog_Header-_-Rework_-34-_v1.jpg?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Latest software development trends 2023: Stack Overflow survey | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"The most recent info on software development trends based Stack Overflow survey results for developers"}},{"title":"How to add rich text editor in Django ","slug":"django-tinymce","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"May 13th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>Thanks to the django-tinymce project, built and maintained by a dedicated community of open source contributors, developers can enhance their Django apps with the power and flexibility that comes with our TinyMCE rich text editor.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Thanks to the django-tinymce project, built and maintained by a dedicated community of open source contributors, developers can enhance their Django apps with the power and flexibility that comes with our TinyMCE rich text editor."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Text \"django-tinymce\".","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7C0UgRv1Jnh4eKxONOcOoU/615f7b30daaea58215eb692c0672c96c/Image_default_Django.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7C0UgRv1Jnh4eKxONOcOoU/615f7b30daaea58215eb692c0672c96c/Image_default_Django.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7C0UgRv1Jnh4eKxONOcOoU/615f7b30daaea58215eb692c0672c96c/Image_default_Django.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7C0UgRv1Jnh4eKxONOcOoU/615f7b30daaea58215eb692c0672c96c/Image_default_Django.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7C0UgRv1Jnh4eKxONOcOoU/615f7b30daaea58215eb692c0672c96c/Image_default_Django.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7C0UgRv1Jnh4eKxONOcOoU/615f7b30daaea58215eb692c0672c96c/Image_default_Django.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7C0UgRv1Jnh4eKxONOcOoU/615f7b30daaea58215eb692c0672c96c/Image_default_Django.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7C0UgRv1Jnh4eKxONOcOoU/615f7b30daaea58215eb692c0672c96c/Image_default_Django.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7C0UgRv1Jnh4eKxONOcOoU/615f7b30daaea58215eb692c0672c96c/Image_default_Django.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7C0UgRv1Jnh4eKxONOcOoU/615f7b30daaea58215eb692c0672c96c/Image_default_Django.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"How to add rich text editor in Django | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Enhance your Django apps with the power of a WYSIWYG rich text editor, thanks to the django-tinymce project."}},{"title":"React accessibility: making your React app accessible","slug":"react-accessibility","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Sep 6th, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>A11y best practices are essential. For a guide on getting started with accessibility in your React app, read on.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"A11y best practices are essential. For a guide on getting started with accessibility in your React app, read on."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"The text area and a react app expressed in symbols on a green background","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7824074074074074,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=1109&h=622&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=1478&h=829&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/336v6qodKUybJ7KZztKyiL/cb4079e45a50a4bb3c6b0a8bd082c1ec/How_to_enrich_React_textarea_with_TinyMCE.png?w=1925&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"React accessibility: making your React app accessible | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Dive into React accessibility: Understand web standards, build accessible components, learn a11y best practices, and master"}},{"title":"HTML editor with preview: single screen or side-by-side editing?","slug":"side-by-side-single-screen-wysiwyg-html-editing","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Sep 20th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>Side-by-side and single screen editing are two separate ways you can edit source code. WYSIWYG HTML editors running in web applications or websites typically use the single screen method for modifying any source code inside the editor. VS Code uses Side-by-side editing. An issue of trust and resources appear when thinking about implementing a side-by-side editing view in a WYSIWYG. It&rsquo;s possible to optimize TinyMCE for single screen HTML editing, and this article explains how.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Side-by-side and single screen editing are two separate ways you can edit source code. WYSIWYG HTML editors running in web applications or websites typically use the single screen method for modifying any source code inside the editor. VS Code uses Side-by-side editing. An issue of trust and resources appear when thinking about implementing a side-by-side editing view in a WYSIWYG. It’s possible to optimize TinyMCE for single screen HTML editing, and this article explains how."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"A laptop and notebook on a table, representing the single scree and side-by-side WYSIWYG HTML editing","artistName":"Mel Poole","image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.8120481927710843,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=185&h=102&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=370&h=204&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=739&h=408&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=1109&h=612&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=1478&h=816&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=2217&h=1223&q=50&fit=scale 2217w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=185&h=102&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=370&h=204&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=739&h=408&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=1109&h=612&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=1478&h=816&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/59sYysl1s64w37koGAoUN9/4dd8044db633f6824cc6a39fba9c2b07/mel-poole-nuFOLbZn6KA-unsplash-BW.jpg?w=2217&h=1223&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 2217w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"HTML editor with preview: single screen or side-by-side editing? | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"There are two ways to check HTML code changes in real time: with the help of a single screen or a side-by-side editing preview. We'll talk about both methods and considerations for their use."}},{"title":"Easy comparison of IDE vs text editors for developers","slug":"text-editor-vs-ide-vs-code-editor","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jan 12th, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>Confused how IDE differs from text editor? Get clarity in this article, which explores the major differences between the two.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Confused how IDE differs from text editor? Get clarity in this article, which explores the major differences between the two."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"IDE and Text Editors separated by a large slash character to represent the divide","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/0yNGl6CZizsVGScJAIfXz/08db183d82e5cc2285830849c35f1dbf/img-ide-vs-text-edtor-version2.png?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Difference between text editor and IDE and code editor | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Confused how IDE differs from text editor? We’ve covered the major differences and provided examples to clarify this"}},{"title":"Modular programming: beyond the spaghetti mess","slug":"modular-programming-principle","featured":true,"lastUpdated":"Jun 28th, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>Considering a modular programming approach? We unpack this programming principle with everything software developers need to know.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Considering a modular programming approach? We unpack this programming principle with everything software developers need to know."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"A bowl of spaghetti contrasted with modular code blocks","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.780758556891767,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=1925&h=1081&q=50&fit=scale 1925w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=739&h=415&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=1109&h=623&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=1478&h=830&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2ZBzMsB6nN3dZynFMfQSiJ/1e98de5f4623c4866183c9c126f7f404/Modular_programming__beyond_the_spaghetti_mess.png?w=1925&h=1081&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1925w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Millie Macdonald","slug":"millie-macdonald"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Modular programming: Definitions, benefits, and predictions"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Considering a modular programming approach? We unpack this programming principle with everything software developers need to know."}},{"title":"Javascript vs Python: A comparison for new web developers and rich text editors","slug":"python-vs-javascript","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Dec 15th, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>Find out whether Python or JavaScript is better for web development and rich text editor integration</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Find out whether Python or JavaScript is better for web development and rich text editor integration"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"JavaScript vs Python text displayed over a background with a pattern of diagonal lines","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5bvY0hnEYIbnWk5guqtJiZ/65aa65f60cb3f14abda14145229fc1ef/img-js-v-python-ver0.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Javascript vs Python: which is better for web development and rich text editors | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"We compare Python and JavaScript programming languages to help you decide which one to choose for web development and rich text editor integration."}},{"title":"How effective is your web application testing process? ","slug":"web-application-testing-process","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Aug 11th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>In this article, we take a look at normalization. A large part of the automated testing is making sure your app or website looks the same and works the same, across different browsers and operating systems. This process is called normalization.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"In this article, we take a look at normalization. A large part of the automated testing is making sure your app or website looks the same and works the same, across different browsers and operating systems. This process is called normalization."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Woman coding in her city apartment","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.4976353126642143,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=185&h=124&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=370&h=247&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=739&h=493&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=1109&h=741&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=1478&h=987&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=2217&h=1480&q=50&fit=scale 2217w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=2850&h=1903&q=50&fit=scale 2850w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=185&h=124&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=370&h=247&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=739&h=493&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=1109&h=741&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=1478&h=987&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=2217&h=1480&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 2217w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4SqRagiKVtUJM9PqLWrf6j/e597ec44d9103b0a42f1ed4877e73f8b/photo-1573495612937-f01934eeaaa7.jpeg?w=2850&h=1903&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 2850w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"How effective is your web application testing process? "},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"In this article, we take a look at normalization. A large part of the automated testing is making sure your app or website looks the same and works the same, across different browsers and operating systems. This process is called normalization.\n"}},{"title":"A quick guide to browser selection models","slug":"a-quick-guide-to-browser-selection-models","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Feb 20th, 2017","description":{"description":"<p>One of the complexities of writing a web-based text editor is accounting for differences between browser selection APIs.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"One of the complexities of writing a web-based text editor is accounting for differences between browser selection APIs."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Abstract image of browser tab and content.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.5633587786259542,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zfHmjbMtiVMcClusKRcHB/086ad9a0a8049df10d1fc4dd8d887df8/iStock-609056396_A-quick-guide-to-browser-selection-models-1024x655.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zfHmjbMtiVMcClusKRcHB/086ad9a0a8049df10d1fc4dd8d887df8/iStock-609056396_A-quick-guide-to-browser-selection-models-1024x655.jpg?w=185&h=118&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zfHmjbMtiVMcClusKRcHB/086ad9a0a8049df10d1fc4dd8d887df8/iStock-609056396_A-quick-guide-to-browser-selection-models-1024x655.jpg?w=370&h=237&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zfHmjbMtiVMcClusKRcHB/086ad9a0a8049df10d1fc4dd8d887df8/iStock-609056396_A-quick-guide-to-browser-selection-models-1024x655.jpg?w=739&h=473&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zfHmjbMtiVMcClusKRcHB/086ad9a0a8049df10d1fc4dd8d887df8/iStock-609056396_A-quick-guide-to-browser-selection-models-1024x655.jpg?w=1024&h=655&q=50&fit=scale 1024w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zfHmjbMtiVMcClusKRcHB/086ad9a0a8049df10d1fc4dd8d887df8/iStock-609056396_A-quick-guide-to-browser-selection-models-1024x655.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zfHmjbMtiVMcClusKRcHB/086ad9a0a8049df10d1fc4dd8d887df8/iStock-609056396_A-quick-guide-to-browser-selection-models-1024x655.jpg?w=185&h=118&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zfHmjbMtiVMcClusKRcHB/086ad9a0a8049df10d1fc4dd8d887df8/iStock-609056396_A-quick-guide-to-browser-selection-models-1024x655.jpg?w=370&h=237&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zfHmjbMtiVMcClusKRcHB/086ad9a0a8049df10d1fc4dd8d887df8/iStock-609056396_A-quick-guide-to-browser-selection-models-1024x655.jpg?w=739&h=473&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6zfHmjbMtiVMcClusKRcHB/086ad9a0a8049df10d1fc4dd8d887df8/iStock-609056396_A-quick-guide-to-browser-selection-models-1024x655.jpg?w=1024&h=655&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1024w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Team Tiny","slug":"team-tiny"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"Handling undo functions in rich text editors","slug":"undo-function-handling","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"May 16th, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>Undo redo in a rich text editor can be complicated, so this article explains how it works, and how to implement undo in TinyMCE with the Undo Manager API.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Undo redo in a rich text editor can be complicated, so this article explains how it works, and how to implement undo in TinyMCE with the Undo Manager API."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Undo functionality represented by writing and circular arrow symbols","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/IICBKTjU9L8gUFJukA9Uf/962ce44ac46123e01dcb3472d516359b/Image_TInyMCE_Undo_Functionality2.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ravgeet Dhillon","slug":"ravgeet-dhillon"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Handling undo function in rich text editors | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Undo redo function implementation in a rich text editor can be complicated. Learn how to implement undo in TinyMCE with Undo Manager API"}},{"title":"Benefits of gradual strong typing in JavaScript","slug":"benefits-of-gradual-strong-typing-in-javascript","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jan 24th, 2019","description":{"description":"<p>Engineer Andy Herron tells the story of the migration to vanilla ES5 at Tiny, and explores the future of TinyMCE with TypeScript. We also share Millie Macdonald's presentation at ForwardJS 2019.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Engineer Andy Herron tells the story of the migration to vanilla ES5 at Tiny, and explores the future of TinyMCE with TypeScript. We also share Millie Macdonald's presentation at ForwardJS 2019."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Developer coding on mac","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.510185185185185,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=185&h=123&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=370&h=245&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=739&h=489&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=1109&h=734&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=1478&h=979&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=1631&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1631w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=185&h=123&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=370&h=245&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=739&h=489&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=1109&h=734&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=1478&h=979&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/U4IZCLq00wIhd4eQe9yd6/d2895fc649d487c792bf2e6864a80277/pexels-photo-574071-1.jpeg?w=1631&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1631w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Andrew Herron","slug":"andrew-herron"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"How to select and highlight text in rich text editors","slug":"select-and-highlight-text","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jun 20th, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>Dive into the complex cases of text selection and highlighting in text editors, find out how they work, and solutions to common problems.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Dive into the complex cases of text selection and highlighting in text editors, find out how they work, and solutions to common problems."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Highlight and select text show with highlighting and selection elements","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4t4ougkRDOLfpI4ybW1MYA/97d3818532313f3fdaf94f68ac39cf88/img-without-background-icons-tinymce-selection.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Keanan Koppenhaver","slug":"keanan-koppenhaver"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"How to select and highlight text in rich text editors | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"In this article we have a deep dive into complex cases of text selection and highlighting in text editors and explain possible solutions."}},{"title":"Five common mistakes to avoid when using Angular","slug":"five-common-mistakes-to-avoid-when-using-angular","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jul 1st, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>Front-end frameworks like Angular enable developers to build scalable applications that can run on multiple device types. This article highlights five common mistakes to avoid when using Angular.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Front-end frameworks like Angular enable developers to build scalable applications that can run on multiple device types. This article highlights five common mistakes to avoid when using Angular."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Angular logo and a number 5.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5jvgQr5vdDWm9WguPC86YD/28a889ef6992534b85997557aa5ef664/Image_default_5angular-mistakes.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5jvgQr5vdDWm9WguPC86YD/28a889ef6992534b85997557aa5ef664/Image_default_5angular-mistakes.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5jvgQr5vdDWm9WguPC86YD/28a889ef6992534b85997557aa5ef664/Image_default_5angular-mistakes.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5jvgQr5vdDWm9WguPC86YD/28a889ef6992534b85997557aa5ef664/Image_default_5angular-mistakes.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5jvgQr5vdDWm9WguPC86YD/28a889ef6992534b85997557aa5ef664/Image_default_5angular-mistakes.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5jvgQr5vdDWm9WguPC86YD/28a889ef6992534b85997557aa5ef664/Image_default_5angular-mistakes.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5jvgQr5vdDWm9WguPC86YD/28a889ef6992534b85997557aa5ef664/Image_default_5angular-mistakes.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5jvgQr5vdDWm9WguPC86YD/28a889ef6992534b85997557aa5ef664/Image_default_5angular-mistakes.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5jvgQr5vdDWm9WguPC86YD/28a889ef6992534b85997557aa5ef664/Image_default_5angular-mistakes.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5jvgQr5vdDWm9WguPC86YD/28a889ef6992534b85997557aa5ef664/Image_default_5angular-mistakes.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"An Angular 5 tutorial: step-by-step guide to your first Angular 5 app","slug":"angular-5-tutorial-step-step-guide-first-angular-5-app","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Feb 21st, 2018","description":{"description":"<p>Get to know Angular 5 by building a simple notes application in this tutorial. Guest author Sergey Moiseev walks through the basics of using the Angular CLI, working with forms, and more.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Get to know Angular 5 by building a simple notes application in this tutorial. Guest author Sergey Moiseev walks through the basics of using the Angular CLI, working with forms, and more."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Build a simple notes app with Angular 5","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.9104477611940298,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T9SRFBlKsWAuFrOFm2YQR/1a4843866b0cf3642e355e17a332e03a/toptal-blog-image-1518187252525-03f6db7b1c131066061024c236c7e3ff-1024x536.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T9SRFBlKsWAuFrOFm2YQR/1a4843866b0cf3642e355e17a332e03a/toptal-blog-image-1518187252525-03f6db7b1c131066061024c236c7e3ff-1024x536.png?w=185&h=97&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T9SRFBlKsWAuFrOFm2YQR/1a4843866b0cf3642e355e17a332e03a/toptal-blog-image-1518187252525-03f6db7b1c131066061024c236c7e3ff-1024x536.png?w=370&h=194&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T9SRFBlKsWAuFrOFm2YQR/1a4843866b0cf3642e355e17a332e03a/toptal-blog-image-1518187252525-03f6db7b1c131066061024c236c7e3ff-1024x536.png?w=739&h=387&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T9SRFBlKsWAuFrOFm2YQR/1a4843866b0cf3642e355e17a332e03a/toptal-blog-image-1518187252525-03f6db7b1c131066061024c236c7e3ff-1024x536.png?w=1024&h=536&q=50&fit=scale 1024w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T9SRFBlKsWAuFrOFm2YQR/1a4843866b0cf3642e355e17a332e03a/toptal-blog-image-1518187252525-03f6db7b1c131066061024c236c7e3ff-1024x536.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T9SRFBlKsWAuFrOFm2YQR/1a4843866b0cf3642e355e17a332e03a/toptal-blog-image-1518187252525-03f6db7b1c131066061024c236c7e3ff-1024x536.png?w=185&h=97&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T9SRFBlKsWAuFrOFm2YQR/1a4843866b0cf3642e355e17a332e03a/toptal-blog-image-1518187252525-03f6db7b1c131066061024c236c7e3ff-1024x536.png?w=370&h=194&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T9SRFBlKsWAuFrOFm2YQR/1a4843866b0cf3642e355e17a332e03a/toptal-blog-image-1518187252525-03f6db7b1c131066061024c236c7e3ff-1024x536.png?w=739&h=387&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2T9SRFBlKsWAuFrOFm2YQR/1a4843866b0cf3642e355e17a332e03a/toptal-blog-image-1518187252525-03f6db7b1c131066061024c236c7e3ff-1024x536.png?w=1024&h=536&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1024w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Sergey Moiseev","slug":"sergey-moiseev"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"Six common mistakes to avoid when using React","slug":"six-common-mistakes-to-avoid-when-using-react","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jun 1st, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>React is an excellent JavaScript library for building user interfaces. However, if you don't use React properly, you could end up creating more problems than you solve. So, here are six common mistakes to avoid when using React.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"React is an excellent JavaScript library for building user interfaces. However, if you don't use React properly, you could end up creating more problems than you solve. So, here are six common mistakes to avoid when using React."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Number 6 with React logo inside.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KcZaJy3VX0YikyVL3rN6e/27e982f3f25644551ec376bf54b0950d/Image_default_ReactMistakes.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KcZaJy3VX0YikyVL3rN6e/27e982f3f25644551ec376bf54b0950d/Image_default_ReactMistakes.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KcZaJy3VX0YikyVL3rN6e/27e982f3f25644551ec376bf54b0950d/Image_default_ReactMistakes.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KcZaJy3VX0YikyVL3rN6e/27e982f3f25644551ec376bf54b0950d/Image_default_ReactMistakes.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KcZaJy3VX0YikyVL3rN6e/27e982f3f25644551ec376bf54b0950d/Image_default_ReactMistakes.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KcZaJy3VX0YikyVL3rN6e/27e982f3f25644551ec376bf54b0950d/Image_default_ReactMistakes.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KcZaJy3VX0YikyVL3rN6e/27e982f3f25644551ec376bf54b0950d/Image_default_ReactMistakes.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KcZaJy3VX0YikyVL3rN6e/27e982f3f25644551ec376bf54b0950d/Image_default_ReactMistakes.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KcZaJy3VX0YikyVL3rN6e/27e982f3f25644551ec376bf54b0950d/Image_default_ReactMistakes.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1KcZaJy3VX0YikyVL3rN6e/27e982f3f25644551ec376bf54b0950d/Image_default_ReactMistakes.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Six common mistakes to avoid when using React"},"metaDescription":null},{"title":"A guide to npm: The node.js package manager","slug":"a-guide-to-npm-the-node-js-package-manager","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Feb 22nd, 2023","description":{"description":"<p>Toptal Developer Martin Gouws walks through the in's and out's of working with npm. Read on to find out how to get the most out of npm.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Toptal Developer Martin Gouws walks through the in's and out's of working with npm. Read on to find out how to get the most out of npm."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"npm logo appearing on a grid background.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7777777777777777,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=1478&h=831&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=1920&h=1080&q=50&fit=scale 1920w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=1478&h=831&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/73Ay6sAygYK8Yzyf2i5z0j/e8ec8c9f403a22f0388820da22222c81/npm_guide.png?w=1920&h=1080&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1920w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Martin Gouws","slug":"martin-gouws"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"A guide to npm: How to install & configure npm for your project | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"npm is an essential tool for modern web development. It allows us to install and manage packages from npmjs.org. In this guide, we'll show you how to install and configure it for your project. A guide to npm: How to install & configure npm for your project"}},{"title":"4 essential skills developers can learn from doing QA","slug":"software-developer-skills-learned-from-qa","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Aug 26th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>Whether you&rsquo;re looking to improve your software developer skills, starting your first software developer job, or thinking about switching from QA to development, here are 4 essential developer skills you can learn from doing QA.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Whether you’re looking to improve your software developer skills, starting your first software developer job, or thinking about switching from QA to development, here are 4 essential developer skills you can learn from doing QA."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Photograph of chess pieces on a chess board. Image by Wooden Earth Ltd (https://www.woodenearth.com/)","artistName":"Image by Wooden Earth Ltd","image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7zZ4oY9AQgCkpPpdUfH8Hl/999b3e7a97cb7a6e4cfa0dd5069fe102/Image_default_4-dev-skills.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7zZ4oY9AQgCkpPpdUfH8Hl/999b3e7a97cb7a6e4cfa0dd5069fe102/Image_default_4-dev-skills.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7zZ4oY9AQgCkpPpdUfH8Hl/999b3e7a97cb7a6e4cfa0dd5069fe102/Image_default_4-dev-skills.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7zZ4oY9AQgCkpPpdUfH8Hl/999b3e7a97cb7a6e4cfa0dd5069fe102/Image_default_4-dev-skills.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7zZ4oY9AQgCkpPpdUfH8Hl/999b3e7a97cb7a6e4cfa0dd5069fe102/Image_default_4-dev-skills.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7zZ4oY9AQgCkpPpdUfH8Hl/999b3e7a97cb7a6e4cfa0dd5069fe102/Image_default_4-dev-skills.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7zZ4oY9AQgCkpPpdUfH8Hl/999b3e7a97cb7a6e4cfa0dd5069fe102/Image_default_4-dev-skills.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7zZ4oY9AQgCkpPpdUfH8Hl/999b3e7a97cb7a6e4cfa0dd5069fe102/Image_default_4-dev-skills.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7zZ4oY9AQgCkpPpdUfH8Hl/999b3e7a97cb7a6e4cfa0dd5069fe102/Image_default_4-dev-skills.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7zZ4oY9AQgCkpPpdUfH8Hl/999b3e7a97cb7a6e4cfa0dd5069fe102/Image_default_4-dev-skills.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Millie Macdonald","slug":"millie-macdonald"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"4 essential skills developers can learn from doing QA"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Whether you’re looking to improve your software developer skills, starting your first software developer job, or thinking about switching from QA to development, here are 4 essential developer skills you can learn from doing QA, covering problem solving, creative analysis, product understanding, and empathy."}},{"title":"The why and how behind Tiny’s RTC end-to-end encryption","slug":"real-time-collaboration-end-to-end-encryption","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jan 13th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>Find out more about how Tiny implements end-to-end encryption for real-time collaboration in TinyMCE, including a discussion of operational transformation methods. Secure real-time collaboration for document sharing and other team-based productivity and communication tools.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Find out more about how Tiny implements end-to-end encryption for real-time collaboration in TinyMCE, including a discussion of operational transformation methods. Secure real-time collaboration for document sharing and other team-based productivity and communication tools."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Text: \"Real-time Collaboration & End-to-end Encryption\"","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6enckfqO3a0fP0KlTPeNS5/d9ad146a33a4796f527b554f6b77e7a5/BlogImage_default_RTC-Encryption.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6enckfqO3a0fP0KlTPeNS5/d9ad146a33a4796f527b554f6b77e7a5/BlogImage_default_RTC-Encryption.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6enckfqO3a0fP0KlTPeNS5/d9ad146a33a4796f527b554f6b77e7a5/BlogImage_default_RTC-Encryption.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6enckfqO3a0fP0KlTPeNS5/d9ad146a33a4796f527b554f6b77e7a5/BlogImage_default_RTC-Encryption.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6enckfqO3a0fP0KlTPeNS5/d9ad146a33a4796f527b554f6b77e7a5/BlogImage_default_RTC-Encryption.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6enckfqO3a0fP0KlTPeNS5/d9ad146a33a4796f527b554f6b77e7a5/BlogImage_default_RTC-Encryption.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6enckfqO3a0fP0KlTPeNS5/d9ad146a33a4796f527b554f6b77e7a5/BlogImage_default_RTC-Encryption.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6enckfqO3a0fP0KlTPeNS5/d9ad146a33a4796f527b554f6b77e7a5/BlogImage_default_RTC-Encryption.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6enckfqO3a0fP0KlTPeNS5/d9ad146a33a4796f527b554f6b77e7a5/BlogImage_default_RTC-Encryption.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6enckfqO3a0fP0KlTPeNS5/d9ad146a33a4796f527b554f6b77e7a5/BlogImage_default_RTC-Encryption.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Tim Dettrick","slug":"tim-dettrick"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"TinyMCE’s real-time collaboration solution is end-to-end encrypted"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Find out why (and how) Tiny implements end-to-end encryption for real-time collaboration in TinyMCE, including a discussion of operational transformation methods. Secure real-time collaboration for document sharing and other team-based productivity and communication tools.\n"}},{"title":"Collaboration needs a clean Slate","slug":"real-time-collaborative-editing-slate-js","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Feb 20th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>Real-time collaboration in a rich text editing environment is a hard problem. In this article, we discuss why we have settled on Slate as the library that we will use to build a high-quality collaborative editing solution.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Real-time collaboration in a rich text editing environment is a hard problem. In this article, we discuss why we have settled on Slate as the library that we will use to build a high-quality collaborative editing solution."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Abstract browser window with six online avatars overlaid and the word Slate appearing above.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5joAuBjNUxkzxpmEuJxy6J/ff51e43bd540899ec12a9b93e125ecd6/Image_default_slate.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5joAuBjNUxkzxpmEuJxy6J/ff51e43bd540899ec12a9b93e125ecd6/Image_default_slate.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5joAuBjNUxkzxpmEuJxy6J/ff51e43bd540899ec12a9b93e125ecd6/Image_default_slate.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5joAuBjNUxkzxpmEuJxy6J/ff51e43bd540899ec12a9b93e125ecd6/Image_default_slate.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5joAuBjNUxkzxpmEuJxy6J/ff51e43bd540899ec12a9b93e125ecd6/Image_default_slate.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5joAuBjNUxkzxpmEuJxy6J/ff51e43bd540899ec12a9b93e125ecd6/Image_default_slate.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5joAuBjNUxkzxpmEuJxy6J/ff51e43bd540899ec12a9b93e125ecd6/Image_default_slate.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5joAuBjNUxkzxpmEuJxy6J/ff51e43bd540899ec12a9b93e125ecd6/Image_default_slate.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5joAuBjNUxkzxpmEuJxy6J/ff51e43bd540899ec12a9b93e125ecd6/Image_default_slate.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5joAuBjNUxkzxpmEuJxy6J/ff51e43bd540899ec12a9b93e125ecd6/Image_default_slate.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Andrew Herron","slug":"andrew-herron"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Collaborative editing: real-time collaboration with Slate.js"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Real-time collaboration in a rich text editing environment is a hard problem. In this article, we discuss why we have settled on Slate as the library that we will use to build a high-quality collaborative editing solution."}},{"title":"Functional Programming and Category Theory at Tiny","slug":"category-theory-functional-programming","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jun 7th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>Because Category Theory is abstract, it can be difficult to learn. At Tiny, we use Functional Programming, which is based on Category Theory. We have some recommendations for learning Category Theory: a book, a lecture series, and a talk recording.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Because Category Theory is abstract, it can be difficult to learn. At Tiny, we use Functional Programming, which is based on Category Theory. We have some recommendations for learning Category Theory: a book, a lecture series, and a talk recording."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Woman teaching and drawing diagrams on a whiteboard ","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.526542324246772,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5thrJiM0BoBnbhtsZcVduF/c8c4bd7c8873370b135c1070f9e5a8ae/Category_theory.jpeg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5thrJiM0BoBnbhtsZcVduF/c8c4bd7c8873370b135c1070f9e5a8ae/Category_theory.jpeg?w=185&h=121&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5thrJiM0BoBnbhtsZcVduF/c8c4bd7c8873370b135c1070f9e5a8ae/Category_theory.jpeg?w=370&h=242&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5thrJiM0BoBnbhtsZcVduF/c8c4bd7c8873370b135c1070f9e5a8ae/Category_theory.jpeg?w=739&h=484&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5thrJiM0BoBnbhtsZcVduF/c8c4bd7c8873370b135c1070f9e5a8ae/Category_theory.jpeg?w=1064&h=697&q=50&fit=scale 1064w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5thrJiM0BoBnbhtsZcVduF/c8c4bd7c8873370b135c1070f9e5a8ae/Category_theory.jpeg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5thrJiM0BoBnbhtsZcVduF/c8c4bd7c8873370b135c1070f9e5a8ae/Category_theory.jpeg?w=185&h=121&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5thrJiM0BoBnbhtsZcVduF/c8c4bd7c8873370b135c1070f9e5a8ae/Category_theory.jpeg?w=370&h=242&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5thrJiM0BoBnbhtsZcVduF/c8c4bd7c8873370b135c1070f9e5a8ae/Category_theory.jpeg?w=739&h=484&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5thrJiM0BoBnbhtsZcVduF/c8c4bd7c8873370b135c1070f9e5a8ae/Category_theory.jpeg?w=1064&h=697&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1064w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Team Tiny","slug":"team-tiny"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Functional Programming and Category Theory at Tiny"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Because Category Theory is abstract, it can be difficult to learn. At Tiny, we use Functional Programming, which is based on Category Theory. We have some recommendations for learning Category Theory: a book, a lecture series, and a talk recording."}},{"title":"New TinyMCE integration: How to get started with Blazor","slug":"how-to-get-started-with-blazor","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Mar 24th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>Blazor is now supported by TinyMCE and this article we go through the why's and how's about getting started with Blazor.&nbsp;</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Blazor is now supported by TinyMCE and this article we go through the why's and how's about getting started with Blazor. "}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Tessellating wires ","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.3332195288494366,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=185&h=139&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=370&h=278&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=739&h=554&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=1109&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=1478&h=1109&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=2217&h=1663&q=50&fit=scale 2217w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=3905&h=2929&q=50&fit=scale 3905w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=185&h=139&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=370&h=278&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=739&h=554&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=1109&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=1478&h=1109&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=2217&h=1663&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 2217w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5kHg6dSDavyVM59QHWQNXI/1f72da1dd6564c63b4e6f31efac4902e/jj-ying-7JX0-bfiuxQ-unsplash.jpg?w=3905&h=2929&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 3905w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Elise Bentley","slug":"elise-bentley"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"How to integrate TinyMCE with Blazor"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Blazor is now supported by TinyMCE. Learn how to get TinyMCE started with Blazor today. "}},{"title":"It’s hard to find a good chameleon","slug":"reduce-software-development-costs","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Apr 27th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>When you are building products that depend on other third party software components, think about choosing chameleon components that help you reduce software development costs.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"When you are building products that depend on other third party software components, think about choosing chameleon components that help you reduce software development costs."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Image of someone holding a green chameleon in their hand. ","artistName":"Amy Humphries","image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.3333333333333333,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=185&h=139&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=370&h=278&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=739&h=554&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=1109&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=1478&h=1109&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=2217&h=1663&q=50&fit=scale 2217w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=3264&h=2448&q=50&fit=scale 3264w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=185&h=139&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=370&h=278&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=739&h=554&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=1109&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=1478&h=1109&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=2217&h=1663&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 2217w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6aXhFgcTFlwOguPJuI6s4X/159fc74f55c7adabbae2f4ecfd344638/amy-humphries-Qb_eemSJg0k-unsplash.jpg?w=3264&h=2448&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 3264w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Reduce software development costs with chameleon components"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"When you are building products that depend on other third party software components, think about choosing chameleon components that help you reduce software development costs."}},{"title":"Top 10 JavaScript how-tos","slug":"javascript-how-to-top-ten","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"May 20th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>What are the top ten JavaScript how-tos? Check out this list of popular JavaScript FAQs with answers.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"What are the top ten JavaScript how-tos? Check out this list of popular JavaScript FAQs with answers."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Text \"How-tos\" with JavaScript logo nestled in the top of the 'H'.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7H0fdAxUhe8rvniGHk2j7h/5d47ce6a732e1143c5ea2bb35d138ce9/Image_default_JShow-tos.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7H0fdAxUhe8rvniGHk2j7h/5d47ce6a732e1143c5ea2bb35d138ce9/Image_default_JShow-tos.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7H0fdAxUhe8rvniGHk2j7h/5d47ce6a732e1143c5ea2bb35d138ce9/Image_default_JShow-tos.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7H0fdAxUhe8rvniGHk2j7h/5d47ce6a732e1143c5ea2bb35d138ce9/Image_default_JShow-tos.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7H0fdAxUhe8rvniGHk2j7h/5d47ce6a732e1143c5ea2bb35d138ce9/Image_default_JShow-tos.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7H0fdAxUhe8rvniGHk2j7h/5d47ce6a732e1143c5ea2bb35d138ce9/Image_default_JShow-tos.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7H0fdAxUhe8rvniGHk2j7h/5d47ce6a732e1143c5ea2bb35d138ce9/Image_default_JShow-tos.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7H0fdAxUhe8rvniGHk2j7h/5d47ce6a732e1143c5ea2bb35d138ce9/Image_default_JShow-tos.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7H0fdAxUhe8rvniGHk2j7h/5d47ce6a732e1143c5ea2bb35d138ce9/Image_default_JShow-tos.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/7H0fdAxUhe8rvniGHk2j7h/5d47ce6a732e1143c5ea2bb35d138ce9/Image_default_JShow-tos.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Top 10 JavaScript how-tos | JavaScript FAQ"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"What are the top ten JavaScript how-tos? Check out this list of popular JavaScript FAQs with answers."}},{"title":"How to integrate React with TinyMCE","slug":"how-to-integrate-react-with-tinymce","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Mar 26th, 2017","description":{"description":"<p>In this tutorial, I'll walk you through how to integrate React.js with TinyMCE. Without further ado, let's get started!</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"In this tutorial, I'll walk you through how to integrate React.js with TinyMCE. Without further ado, let's get started!"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"React and Tiny MCE","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/jC7yKmwpLMQQnMbORx6xn/fcc229b86e617c1e7becf3f74276462e/img-react-improvements-01.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Team Tiny","slug":"team-tiny"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"In this tutorial, I’ll walk you through how to integrate React.js with TinyMCE. Without further ado, let’s get started!"}},{"title":"A multi-language spell checker for our rich text editor","slug":"a-multi-language-spell-checker-for-our-rich-text-editor","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Mar 29th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>More situations are arising where more than one language needs to be included in a single piece of content. With the release of TinyMCE 5.2, you can check up to thirteen languages simultaneously.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"More situations are arising where more than one language needs to be included in a single piece of content. With the release of TinyMCE 5.2, you can check up to thirteen languages simultaneously."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Text 'Hello' in foreground with greetings in several languages in the background.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1AY9IY1ZyN0JlYtxBktwsW/fbca674d8cbfdb45cc52d213eb11f1de/Image_default_multilingual.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1AY9IY1ZyN0JlYtxBktwsW/fbca674d8cbfdb45cc52d213eb11f1de/Image_default_multilingual.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1AY9IY1ZyN0JlYtxBktwsW/fbca674d8cbfdb45cc52d213eb11f1de/Image_default_multilingual.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1AY9IY1ZyN0JlYtxBktwsW/fbca674d8cbfdb45cc52d213eb11f1de/Image_default_multilingual.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1AY9IY1ZyN0JlYtxBktwsW/fbca674d8cbfdb45cc52d213eb11f1de/Image_default_multilingual.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1AY9IY1ZyN0JlYtxBktwsW/fbca674d8cbfdb45cc52d213eb11f1de/Image_default_multilingual.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1AY9IY1ZyN0JlYtxBktwsW/fbca674d8cbfdb45cc52d213eb11f1de/Image_default_multilingual.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1AY9IY1ZyN0JlYtxBktwsW/fbca674d8cbfdb45cc52d213eb11f1de/Image_default_multilingual.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1AY9IY1ZyN0JlYtxBktwsW/fbca674d8cbfdb45cc52d213eb11f1de/Image_default_multilingual.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1AY9IY1ZyN0JlYtxBktwsW/fbca674d8cbfdb45cc52d213eb11f1de/Image_default_multilingual.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"API integrations and getting the most from TinyMCE’s APIs","slug":"api-release","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Dec 14th, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>Looking for API guides? This guide shows some of the essential API integrations availble with TinyMCE's APIs</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Looking for API guides? This guide shows some of the essential API integrations availble with TinyMCE's APIs"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"A cross icon and a cog icon representing APIs on a hexagon pattern background","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4aSJRwwfIUTbit3A6YGxFR/e147350256ecf89f26b014102e1c3a00/img-api-basics-guide-0.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joel Olawanle","slug":"joel-olawanle"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"API integrations and getting the most from TinyMCE’s APIs | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"API integrations can be confusing, but this guide shows API integration with TinyMCE APIs with API examples you can see to get started"}},{"title":"Using HTML and contenteditable to build a rich text editor","slug":"using-html-contenteditable","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Apr 18th, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>Learn about <code>contenteditable</code> attribute, how it is used in text editors, its limitations, and how to overcome those limits with rich text editors.</p>\n<p>&nbsp;</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Learn about "},{"type":"element","tagName":"code","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"contenteditable"}]},{"type":"text","value":" attribute, how it is used in text editors, its limitations, and how to overcome those limits with rich text editors."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":" "}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"An online HTML editor and the HTML displayed in real-time.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hBZlqB7HMp6MD6i1LQMdL/7d62ec1165ff209d9ec5c9af839ff5ce/Image_default_OnlineHTMLEditor.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hBZlqB7HMp6MD6i1LQMdL/7d62ec1165ff209d9ec5c9af839ff5ce/Image_default_OnlineHTMLEditor.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hBZlqB7HMp6MD6i1LQMdL/7d62ec1165ff209d9ec5c9af839ff5ce/Image_default_OnlineHTMLEditor.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hBZlqB7HMp6MD6i1LQMdL/7d62ec1165ff209d9ec5c9af839ff5ce/Image_default_OnlineHTMLEditor.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hBZlqB7HMp6MD6i1LQMdL/7d62ec1165ff209d9ec5c9af839ff5ce/Image_default_OnlineHTMLEditor.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hBZlqB7HMp6MD6i1LQMdL/7d62ec1165ff209d9ec5c9af839ff5ce/Image_default_OnlineHTMLEditor.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hBZlqB7HMp6MD6i1LQMdL/7d62ec1165ff209d9ec5c9af839ff5ce/Image_default_OnlineHTMLEditor.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hBZlqB7HMp6MD6i1LQMdL/7d62ec1165ff209d9ec5c9af839ff5ce/Image_default_OnlineHTMLEditor.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hBZlqB7HMp6MD6i1LQMdL/7d62ec1165ff209d9ec5c9af839ff5ce/Image_default_OnlineHTMLEditor.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/hBZlqB7HMp6MD6i1LQMdL/7d62ec1165ff209d9ec5c9af839ff5ce/Image_default_OnlineHTMLEditor.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Shahed Nasser","slug":"shahed-nasser"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Using HTML Contententeditable to build a RTE | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Learn about contenteditable attribute, how it is used in text editors, its limitations and how to overcome those.\n"}},{"title":"HTML compliance and rich text editors","slug":"html-compliance","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Mar 21st, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>HTML compliance and validity is an essential part of web development. RTE can introduce possible HTML issues &ndash; compliance features and best practices keep the HTML validity of the web content.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"HTML compliance and validity is an essential part of web development. RTE can introduce possible HTML issues – compliance features and best practices keep the HTML validity of the web content."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Rich Text Editor HTML compliance and validity representation","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/42G3GpDezOShsBGbMDqQWi/83d067e9f3af4af9ed0d68d2ec11250e/Image_HTML_Compliance_Valid_explore.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Prakash Verma","slug":"prakash-verma"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"HTML compliance and compliance features of RTE editors | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Learn more about HTML compliance of RTE editors: possible issues, compliance features and best practices to keep the html validity of the web content."}},{"title":"How HTML focus works in rich text editors","slug":"text-editor-focus","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Mar 2nd, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>HTML focus can be complex &ndash; this is especially true for the textarea HTML element. Find out what HTML focus means, and how HTML focus works in rich text editors.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"HTML focus can be complex – this is especially true for the textarea HTML element. Find out what HTML focus means, and how HTML focus works in rich text editors."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"How HTML focus works in rich text editors.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/64w7Q9hY2R5s7AiLyzkqR1/93897c5aad3bb563440429b810bb1561/Image_Focus_HTML_Textarea__1_.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Keanan Koppenhaver","slug":"keanan-koppenhaver"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"What is HTML focus, and how focus works for rich text editors | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"HTML focus can be complex, especially in textarea focus cases. Find out what HTML focus means, and how HTML focus works in rich text editors."}},{"title":"HTML content models in rich text editors","slug":"html-content-models","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Feb 21st, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>HTML content models are essential for rich text editors. They define what HTML element the content should have. Knowing how they work makes producing content in a rich text editor easier, and improves your flow.&nbsp;</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"HTML content models are essential for rich text editors. They define what HTML element the content should have. Knowing how they work makes producing content in a rich text editor easier, and improves your flow. "}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"HTML mapping is important to understand for writing quickly in rich text editors","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=185&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=370&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=739&h=416&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=1109&h=624&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=1478&h=832&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6ohdvJvwCih51h92ht2eEd/7f9a8d9953f402ef97dfbd212260b98f/Image_HTML_Mapping__1_.jpg?w=1528&h=860&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ochuko Onojakpor","slug":"ochuko-onojakpor"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"HTML content models in rich text editors | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"HTML content models define the type of content each element is allowed to have. Learn about how rich text editors convert content to HTML."}},{"title":"Open source security pros and cons","slug":"open-source-software-security","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jan 27th, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>How can you know if an open source software dependency you&rsquo;d like to use is secure (or not)? Find out more..</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"How can you know if an open source software dependency you’d like to use is secure (or not)? Find out more.."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Learn more on how to assess the security of the open source project, possible risks and best practices on how to avoid those.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.0979142526071843,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=185&h=169&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=370&h=337&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=739&h=673&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=1109&h=1010&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=1478&h=1346&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=1895&h=1726&q=50&fit=scale 1895w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=185&h=169&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=370&h=337&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=739&h=673&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=1109&h=1010&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=1478&h=1346&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4cFCQEovjuciYoGlvAtYda/00ab5c450ecafff220d3b3108e3c3cc6/Image_Github_Security.png?w=1895&h=1726&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1895w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Open source software security: better or bad from the start? "},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Learn more on how to assess the security of the open source project, possible risks and best practices on how to avoid those."}},{"title":"Tracking engineering performance with analytics","slug":"tracking-engineering-performance-with-analytics","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jan 10th, 2022","description":{"description":"<p>Engineering performance metrics are essential for supporting software development.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Engineering performance metrics are essential for supporting software development."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Engineering performance and culture are better with analytics","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.0979142526071843,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=185&h=169&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=370&h=337&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=739&h=673&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=1109&h=1010&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=1478&h=1346&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=1895&h=1726&q=50&fit=scale 1895w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=185&h=169&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=370&h=337&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=739&h=673&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=1109&h=1010&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=1478&h=1346&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/48GmaUah7PNcm3jKAxP9KT/16251ff0f9d7cceb46ebbba7cff5dec2/Image_engineering_Analytics_Header.png?w=1895&h=1726&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1895w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Tracking engineering performance with analytics | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Learn about why it’s important to track your engineering performance and what software development metrics you can use."}},{"title":"Open source software and managing technical debt ","slug":"open-source-manage-technical-debt","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Oct 4th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>While technical debt may appear to be an issue for large, private software products, open source software projects can experience it when they expand in size, or when volunteers depart projects. It's possible to identify the skill set needed to manage it, apply for funding resources to attract contributors with the relevant skills, or even create an associated business to garner attention and resources for an open source project.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"While technical debt may appear to be an issue for large, private software products, open source software projects can experience it when they expand in size, or when volunteers depart projects. It's possible to identify the skill set needed to manage it, apply for funding resources to attract contributors with the relevant skills, or even create an associated business to garner attention and resources for an open source project."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"An hour glass, a pair of hands holding it, and a computer screen. The hour glass represents the time pressures associated with technical debt.","artistName":"Fakurian Design","image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.4922222222222221,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=185&h=124&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=370&h=248&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=739&h=495&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=1109&h=743&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=1478&h=990&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=2217&h=1486&q=50&fit=scale 2217w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=2686&h=1800&q=50&fit=scale 2686w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=185&h=124&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=370&h=248&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=739&h=495&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=1109&h=743&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=1478&h=990&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=2217&h=1486&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 2217w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/658ocwXKWBWtrGwltiTxmx/c4f6c0bd42690c0fee34705a2bcb18ba/fakurian-design-mqm-Ze_q_9A-unsplash-technical-debt.png?w=2686&h=1800&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 2686w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"Learn JavaScript in 2021: Hassib Moddasser’s recommendation ","slug":"learn-javascript-guide-2021","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Sep 21st, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>To learn JavaScript in 2021, we have a resource to share - a twitter thread from Hassib Moddasser. Their recommendations can help users to start to learn JavaScript with the best resources in 2021.&nbsp;</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"To learn JavaScript in 2021, we have a resource to share - a twitter thread from Hassib Moddasser. Their recommendations can help users to start to learn JavaScript with the best resources in 2021. "}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"The twitter handle of @hassibmoddasser who's tweets are showcased in this blog to learn JavaScript","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.4169570267131242,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5YYKT2puI3GQH5cMJcj2j0/c0cbe2799bdd2ff7c8a3141892d2fc10/twitter-showcase-blog2.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5YYKT2puI3GQH5cMJcj2j0/c0cbe2799bdd2ff7c8a3141892d2fc10/twitter-showcase-blog2.png?w=185&h=131&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5YYKT2puI3GQH5cMJcj2j0/c0cbe2799bdd2ff7c8a3141892d2fc10/twitter-showcase-blog2.png?w=370&h=261&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5YYKT2puI3GQH5cMJcj2j0/c0cbe2799bdd2ff7c8a3141892d2fc10/twitter-showcase-blog2.png?w=739&h=522&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5YYKT2puI3GQH5cMJcj2j0/c0cbe2799bdd2ff7c8a3141892d2fc10/twitter-showcase-blog2.png?w=1109&h=783&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5YYKT2puI3GQH5cMJcj2j0/c0cbe2799bdd2ff7c8a3141892d2fc10/twitter-showcase-blog2.png?w=1220&h=861&q=50&fit=scale 1220w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5YYKT2puI3GQH5cMJcj2j0/c0cbe2799bdd2ff7c8a3141892d2fc10/twitter-showcase-blog2.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5YYKT2puI3GQH5cMJcj2j0/c0cbe2799bdd2ff7c8a3141892d2fc10/twitter-showcase-blog2.png?w=185&h=131&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5YYKT2puI3GQH5cMJcj2j0/c0cbe2799bdd2ff7c8a3141892d2fc10/twitter-showcase-blog2.png?w=370&h=261&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5YYKT2puI3GQH5cMJcj2j0/c0cbe2799bdd2ff7c8a3141892d2fc10/twitter-showcase-blog2.png?w=739&h=522&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5YYKT2puI3GQH5cMJcj2j0/c0cbe2799bdd2ff7c8a3141892d2fc10/twitter-showcase-blog2.png?w=1109&h=783&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5YYKT2puI3GQH5cMJcj2j0/c0cbe2799bdd2ff7c8a3141892d2fc10/twitter-showcase-blog2.png?w=1220&h=861&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1220w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joe Robinson","slug":"joseph-robinson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"How tiny.cloud uses free monads for testing","slug":"tiny-cloud-free-monads","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jul 19th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>At Tiny, we devised a solution to a file system problem using a solution from mathematics: Free Monads. In this deep dive into our process, we walk through what went into implementing Free Monads for testing our rich text editor.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"At Tiny, we devised a solution to a file system problem using a solution from mathematics: Free Monads. In this deep dive into our process, we walk through what went into implementing Free Monads for testing our rich text editor."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Graphics of TinyMCE and the Cloud","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=1109&h=911&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=1478&h=1214&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=1792&h=1472&q=50&fit=scale 1792w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=1109&h=911&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=1478&h=1214&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/sQsL5FErxkutJXb8qwwFy/5d0f772e5c09dec7689b38b895717830/How_Cloud_used_Free_Monads_for_testability.png?w=1792&h=1472&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1792w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Morgan Smith","slug":"morgan-smith"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"How tiny.cloud uses free monads for testing"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"At Tiny, we devised a solution to a file system problem using mathematics: a concept called Free Monads. In this deep dive into our process, we walk through what went into implementing Free Monads for testing our rich text editor."}},{"title":"The essential git stash and git reset guide","slug":"the-essential-git-stash-and-git-reset-guide","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jun 9th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>In this guide, we take you through two essential git commands. Git stash saves your work and lets you switch branches.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"In this guide, we take you through two essential git commands. Git stash saves your work and lets you switch branches."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":" An octocat figurine stands in front of a computer screen","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.5316091954022988,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3kGjWY2aHvXl6Hjad2Ch7V/3bb82ab03e8e0e44db961e742cb3505f/GitHub_reset.jpeg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3kGjWY2aHvXl6Hjad2Ch7V/3bb82ab03e8e0e44db961e742cb3505f/GitHub_reset.jpeg?w=185&h=121&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3kGjWY2aHvXl6Hjad2Ch7V/3bb82ab03e8e0e44db961e742cb3505f/GitHub_reset.jpeg?w=370&h=242&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3kGjWY2aHvXl6Hjad2Ch7V/3bb82ab03e8e0e44db961e742cb3505f/GitHub_reset.jpeg?w=739&h=482&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3kGjWY2aHvXl6Hjad2Ch7V/3bb82ab03e8e0e44db961e742cb3505f/GitHub_reset.jpeg?w=1066&h=696&q=50&fit=scale 1066w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3kGjWY2aHvXl6Hjad2Ch7V/3bb82ab03e8e0e44db961e742cb3505f/GitHub_reset.jpeg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3kGjWY2aHvXl6Hjad2Ch7V/3bb82ab03e8e0e44db961e742cb3505f/GitHub_reset.jpeg?w=185&h=121&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3kGjWY2aHvXl6Hjad2Ch7V/3bb82ab03e8e0e44db961e742cb3505f/GitHub_reset.jpeg?w=370&h=242&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3kGjWY2aHvXl6Hjad2Ch7V/3bb82ab03e8e0e44db961e742cb3505f/GitHub_reset.jpeg?w=739&h=482&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3kGjWY2aHvXl6Hjad2Ch7V/3bb82ab03e8e0e44db961e742cb3505f/GitHub_reset.jpeg?w=1066&h=696&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1066w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Team Tiny","slug":"team-tiny"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"The essential git stash and git reset guide | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Guide to git stash and get reset - essential git commands. Git stash makes a temporary, local save of your code. Git reset lets you tidy up your code before doing a commit."}},{"title":"3 reasons why a great developer experience is crucial","slug":"why-have-a-great-developer-experience","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Apr 14th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>More often than not, we cater to our users by creating an intuitive user experience, but we should also focus on building a great developer experience. Learn the benefits of having a great developer experience in our latest blog.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"More often than not, we cater to our users by creating an intuitive user experience, but we should also focus on building a great developer experience. Learn the benefits of having a great developer experience in our latest blog."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Laptop at a desk office","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.5,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=185&h=123&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=370&h=247&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=739&h=493&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=1109&h=739&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=1478&h=985&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=2217&h=1478&q=50&fit=scale 2217w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=185&h=123&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=370&h=247&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=739&h=493&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=1109&h=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=1478&h=985&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4wRTVDqpVEIDf4C7Q0bNxx/c2b0d83dd4770065cbb9dd1e23ed5322/christopher-gower-vjMgqUkS8q8-unsplash.jpg?w=2217&h=1478&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 2217w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Qiran Gabrielle-Grace","slug":"qiran-gabrielle-grace"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"The importance of a great developer experience?"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"More often than not, we cater to our users by creating an intuitive user experience, but we should also focus on building a great developer experience. Learn the benefits of having a great developer experience in our latest blog. "}},{"title":"Collecting and analyzing metrics in engineering","slug":"collecting-and-analyzing-engineering-metrics","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Feb 10th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>Software development metrics done right can be extremely fascinating and illuminating. They can save your development teams from myriad unnecessary costs and frustrations, and improve performance as a result.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Software development metrics done right can be extremely fascinating and illuminating. They can save your development teams from myriad unnecessary costs and frustrations, and improve performance as a result."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Series of graphs on a screen ","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6PhK9JTfUHcfDbO6sE4S6J/b60deb9f420181df16d4fc311d799cb5/BlogImage_Feb2021_default_analytics.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6PhK9JTfUHcfDbO6sE4S6J/b60deb9f420181df16d4fc311d799cb5/BlogImage_Feb2021_default_analytics.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6PhK9JTfUHcfDbO6sE4S6J/b60deb9f420181df16d4fc311d799cb5/BlogImage_Feb2021_default_analytics.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6PhK9JTfUHcfDbO6sE4S6J/b60deb9f420181df16d4fc311d799cb5/BlogImage_Feb2021_default_analytics.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6PhK9JTfUHcfDbO6sE4S6J/b60deb9f420181df16d4fc311d799cb5/BlogImage_Feb2021_default_analytics.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6PhK9JTfUHcfDbO6sE4S6J/b60deb9f420181df16d4fc311d799cb5/BlogImage_Feb2021_default_analytics.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6PhK9JTfUHcfDbO6sE4S6J/b60deb9f420181df16d4fc311d799cb5/BlogImage_Feb2021_default_analytics.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6PhK9JTfUHcfDbO6sE4S6J/b60deb9f420181df16d4fc311d799cb5/BlogImage_Feb2021_default_analytics.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6PhK9JTfUHcfDbO6sE4S6J/b60deb9f420181df16d4fc311d799cb5/BlogImage_Feb2021_default_analytics.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6PhK9JTfUHcfDbO6sE4S6J/b60deb9f420181df16d4fc311d799cb5/BlogImage_Feb2021_default_analytics.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Dylan Just","slug":"dylan-just"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Collecting and analyzing metrics in engineering"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Software development metrics done right can be extremely fascinating and illuminating. They can save your development teams from myriad unnecessary costs and frustrations, and improve performance as a result."}},{"title":"Tiny Programming Principles: The concept of Optionals","slug":"javascript-optionals","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Feb 8th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>Just because you can use null or undefined doesn&rsquo;t mean you should. We talk about the problems that come up and how Optionals can help overcome them.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Just because you can use null or undefined doesn’t mean you should. We talk about the problems that come up and how Optionals can help overcome them."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"People discussing at a table in an office ","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.5,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=185&h=123&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=370&h=247&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=739&h=493&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=1109&h=739&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=1478&h=985&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=1950&h=1300&q=50&fit=scale 1950w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=185&h=123&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=370&h=247&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=739&h=493&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=1109&h=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=1478&h=985&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/6kqW0LP4TCJbdW2de79axH/b8ab73e7c040b67c0caf3667069d33d7/Optionals.jpeg?w=1950&h=1300&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1950w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Millie Macdonald","slug":"millie-macdonald"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Programming Principles: Optionals Vs Null Or Undefined"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Just because you can use null or undefined doesn’t mean you should. We talk about the problems that come up and how Optionals can help overcome them."}},{"title":"Tiny Programming Principles: Immutability","slug":"mutable-vs-immutable-javascript","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jan 26th, 2021","description":{"description":"<p>We share key benefits of immutability, and why JavaScript developers (in particular) should choose immutable objects over mutating functions.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"We share key benefits of immutability, and why JavaScript developers (in particular) should choose immutable objects over mutating functions."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Five eggs are stacked precariously on top of each other.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":0.6669390614055568,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=185&h=277&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=370&h=555&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=739&h=1108&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=1109&h=1663&q=50&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=1478&h=2216&q=50&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=2217&h=3324&q=50&fit=scale 2217w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=185&h=277&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=370&h=555&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=739&h=1108&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=1109&h=1663&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1109w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=1478&h=2216&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1478w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5b81UPp1646TlwGYqCwI2U/8a0d08a26791a54e23998303dfa9a0f2/jiangxulei1990-eIzzzwtkBjU-unsplash.jpg?w=2217&h=3324&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 2217w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Millie Macdonald","slug":"millie-macdonald"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Immutable vs mutable: Definitions, benefits & practical tips"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"We share key benefits of immutability, and why JavaScript developers (in particular) should choose immutable objects over mutating functions."}},{"title":"What is DevOps?","slug":"what-is-devops","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Sep 20th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>DevOps is a mashup of &ldquo;development&rdquo; and &ldquo;operations&rdquo;, but it has become shorthand for a significant culture shift that, done right, can drive meaningful organizational change.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"DevOps is a mashup of “development” and “operations”, but it has become shorthand for a significant culture shift that, done right, can drive meaningful organizational change."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"At least three cogs interlocked.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1OC5CO8rBreAg4edplgfGY/d323567754d2a63829544c582c9be790/Image_default_WhatIsDevOps.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1OC5CO8rBreAg4edplgfGY/d323567754d2a63829544c582c9be790/Image_default_WhatIsDevOps.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1OC5CO8rBreAg4edplgfGY/d323567754d2a63829544c582c9be790/Image_default_WhatIsDevOps.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1OC5CO8rBreAg4edplgfGY/d323567754d2a63829544c582c9be790/Image_default_WhatIsDevOps.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1OC5CO8rBreAg4edplgfGY/d323567754d2a63829544c582c9be790/Image_default_WhatIsDevOps.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1OC5CO8rBreAg4edplgfGY/d323567754d2a63829544c582c9be790/Image_default_WhatIsDevOps.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1OC5CO8rBreAg4edplgfGY/d323567754d2a63829544c582c9be790/Image_default_WhatIsDevOps.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1OC5CO8rBreAg4edplgfGY/d323567754d2a63829544c582c9be790/Image_default_WhatIsDevOps.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1OC5CO8rBreAg4edplgfGY/d323567754d2a63829544c582c9be790/Image_default_WhatIsDevOps.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1OC5CO8rBreAg4edplgfGY/d323567754d2a63829544c582c9be790/Image_default_WhatIsDevOps.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Cameron Bowden","slug":"cameron-bowden"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"XSS security issue - Tiny’s commitment","slug":"xss-security-issue-tinys-commitment","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Aug 12th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>Tiny has released a security update for its open source HTML editor based on a cross-site scripting (XSS) vulnerability discovered by Bishop Fox Labs.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Tiny has released a security update for its open source HTML editor based on a cross-site scripting (XSS) vulnerability discovered by Bishop Fox Labs."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Laptop keyboard viewed from the side with screen half closed.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/RfipD0YfixdLF2pYVYTZd/059012812c4fa3815751fc619c66ef02/Image_default_security__1_.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/RfipD0YfixdLF2pYVYTZd/059012812c4fa3815751fc619c66ef02/Image_default_security__1_.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/RfipD0YfixdLF2pYVYTZd/059012812c4fa3815751fc619c66ef02/Image_default_security__1_.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/RfipD0YfixdLF2pYVYTZd/059012812c4fa3815751fc619c66ef02/Image_default_security__1_.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/RfipD0YfixdLF2pYVYTZd/059012812c4fa3815751fc619c66ef02/Image_default_security__1_.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/RfipD0YfixdLF2pYVYTZd/059012812c4fa3815751fc619c66ef02/Image_default_security__1_.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/RfipD0YfixdLF2pYVYTZd/059012812c4fa3815751fc619c66ef02/Image_default_security__1_.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/RfipD0YfixdLF2pYVYTZd/059012812c4fa3815751fc619c66ef02/Image_default_security__1_.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/RfipD0YfixdLF2pYVYTZd/059012812c4fa3815751fc619c66ef02/Image_default_security__1_.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/RfipD0YfixdLF2pYVYTZd/059012812c4fa3815751fc619c66ef02/Image_default_security__1_.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Dylan Just","slug":"dylan-just"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"Full-stack developer skills and the importance of learning","slug":"full-stack-developer-skills-and-the-importance-of-learning","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jun 29th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>What skills are required for a full-stack developer? We list 12 essential skills, and discuss the importance of learning, theory vs practice, depth vs breadth, and more.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"What skills are required for a full-stack developer? We list 12 essential skills, and discuss the importance of learning, theory vs practice, depth vs breadth, and more."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Laptop with hands poised ready to type code.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2mHaYURLMpWxhkwcb3T4m7/9568def5d5cfe4003dd8cb9838febc85/Image_default_fullstackdevskills.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2mHaYURLMpWxhkwcb3T4m7/9568def5d5cfe4003dd8cb9838febc85/Image_default_fullstackdevskills.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2mHaYURLMpWxhkwcb3T4m7/9568def5d5cfe4003dd8cb9838febc85/Image_default_fullstackdevskills.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2mHaYURLMpWxhkwcb3T4m7/9568def5d5cfe4003dd8cb9838febc85/Image_default_fullstackdevskills.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2mHaYURLMpWxhkwcb3T4m7/9568def5d5cfe4003dd8cb9838febc85/Image_default_fullstackdevskills.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2mHaYURLMpWxhkwcb3T4m7/9568def5d5cfe4003dd8cb9838febc85/Image_default_fullstackdevskills.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2mHaYURLMpWxhkwcb3T4m7/9568def5d5cfe4003dd8cb9838febc85/Image_default_fullstackdevskills.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2mHaYURLMpWxhkwcb3T4m7/9568def5d5cfe4003dd8cb9838febc85/Image_default_fullstackdevskills.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2mHaYURLMpWxhkwcb3T4m7/9568def5d5cfe4003dd8cb9838febc85/Image_default_fullstackdevskills.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2mHaYURLMpWxhkwcb3T4m7/9568def5d5cfe4003dd8cb9838febc85/Image_default_fullstackdevskills.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Dylan Just","slug":"dylan-just"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"12 essential skills for full-stack developers and the importance of learning"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"What skills are required for a full-stack developer? We list 12 essential skills, and discuss the importance of learning, theory vs practice, depth vs breadth, and more."}},{"title":"Tiny takes security seriously","slug":"tinymce-security-tiny-takes-security-seriously","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jun 18th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>When it comes to developing software for commercial use, more and more developers understand the importance of security. That&rsquo;s why, at Tiny, security is a top priority.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"When it comes to developing software for commercial use, more and more developers understand the importance of security. That’s why, at Tiny, security is a top priority."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Blurred code on a screen in shades of blue and purple.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2Zcdq5Pd0z0UVsJbHukFqR/54e32cfad87249c4c86e6cd5edf09405/Image_default_Security.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2Zcdq5Pd0z0UVsJbHukFqR/54e32cfad87249c4c86e6cd5edf09405/Image_default_Security.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2Zcdq5Pd0z0UVsJbHukFqR/54e32cfad87249c4c86e6cd5edf09405/Image_default_Security.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2Zcdq5Pd0z0UVsJbHukFqR/54e32cfad87249c4c86e6cd5edf09405/Image_default_Security.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2Zcdq5Pd0z0UVsJbHukFqR/54e32cfad87249c4c86e6cd5edf09405/Image_default_Security.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2Zcdq5Pd0z0UVsJbHukFqR/54e32cfad87249c4c86e6cd5edf09405/Image_default_Security.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2Zcdq5Pd0z0UVsJbHukFqR/54e32cfad87249c4c86e6cd5edf09405/Image_default_Security.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2Zcdq5Pd0z0UVsJbHukFqR/54e32cfad87249c4c86e6cd5edf09405/Image_default_Security.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2Zcdq5Pd0z0UVsJbHukFqR/54e32cfad87249c4c86e6cd5edf09405/Image_default_Security.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2Zcdq5Pd0z0UVsJbHukFqR/54e32cfad87249c4c86e6cd5edf09405/Image_default_Security.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"TinyMCE security: Tiny takes security seriously"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"When it comes to developing software for commercial use, more and more developers understand the importance of security. That’s why, at Tiny, security is a top priority."}},{"title":"8 habits of successful development teams","slug":"habits-successful-developers","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jun 8th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>Successful developers work well with other people, continually learn new skills, and build up their team. We talk about 8 regular habits for success as a developer.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Successful developers work well with other people, continually learn new skills, and build up their team. We talk about 8 regular habits for success as a developer."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Two developers working at a laptop.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2NQfs1Q4jjau62Xjmesxqk/88c25f3e7f6c73c45f7b2cbcbce04153/Image_default_8Habits.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2NQfs1Q4jjau62Xjmesxqk/88c25f3e7f6c73c45f7b2cbcbce04153/Image_default_8Habits.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2NQfs1Q4jjau62Xjmesxqk/88c25f3e7f6c73c45f7b2cbcbce04153/Image_default_8Habits.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2NQfs1Q4jjau62Xjmesxqk/88c25f3e7f6c73c45f7b2cbcbce04153/Image_default_8Habits.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2NQfs1Q4jjau62Xjmesxqk/88c25f3e7f6c73c45f7b2cbcbce04153/Image_default_8Habits.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2NQfs1Q4jjau62Xjmesxqk/88c25f3e7f6c73c45f7b2cbcbce04153/Image_default_8Habits.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2NQfs1Q4jjau62Xjmesxqk/88c25f3e7f6c73c45f7b2cbcbce04153/Image_default_8Habits.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2NQfs1Q4jjau62Xjmesxqk/88c25f3e7f6c73c45f7b2cbcbce04153/Image_default_8Habits.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2NQfs1Q4jjau62Xjmesxqk/88c25f3e7f6c73c45f7b2cbcbce04153/Image_default_8Habits.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/2NQfs1Q4jjau62Xjmesxqk/88c25f3e7f6c73c45f7b2cbcbce04153/Image_default_8Habits.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Lee Newson","slug":"lee-newson"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"8 habits of highly successful developers and their teams"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Successful developers work well with other people, continually learn new skills, and build up their team. We talk about 8 regular habits for success as a developer. "}},{"title":"How to stay relevant as a software developer","slug":"software-developer-skills-stay-relevant","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Jun 2nd, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>What skills do software developers need to stay relevant and up-to-date with the industry? Find out how to stay on top of the changes.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"What skills do software developers need to stay relevant and up-to-date with the industry? Find out how to stay on top of the changes."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Man sips a hot beverage from a yellow teacup, while sitting in front of an open laptop on a yellow table and reading a book.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/PJYmjB39Nlq96Z4vODIYE/18726eacd95cd7302069bef2f488be9b/Image_default_StayRelevant.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/PJYmjB39Nlq96Z4vODIYE/18726eacd95cd7302069bef2f488be9b/Image_default_StayRelevant.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/PJYmjB39Nlq96Z4vODIYE/18726eacd95cd7302069bef2f488be9b/Image_default_StayRelevant.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/PJYmjB39Nlq96Z4vODIYE/18726eacd95cd7302069bef2f488be9b/Image_default_StayRelevant.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/PJYmjB39Nlq96Z4vODIYE/18726eacd95cd7302069bef2f488be9b/Image_default_StayRelevant.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/PJYmjB39Nlq96Z4vODIYE/18726eacd95cd7302069bef2f488be9b/Image_default_StayRelevant.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/PJYmjB39Nlq96Z4vODIYE/18726eacd95cd7302069bef2f488be9b/Image_default_StayRelevant.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/PJYmjB39Nlq96Z4vODIYE/18726eacd95cd7302069bef2f488be9b/Image_default_StayRelevant.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/PJYmjB39Nlq96Z4vODIYE/18726eacd95cd7302069bef2f488be9b/Image_default_StayRelevant.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/PJYmjB39Nlq96Z4vODIYE/18726eacd95cd7302069bef2f488be9b/Image_default_StayRelevant.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"How to stay relevant as a software developer: Skills, habits & more"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"What skills do software developers need to stay relevant and up-to-date with the industry? Find out how to stay on top of the changes."}},{"title":"13 soft skills that will future proof your career as a developer","slug":"developer-soft-skills-career","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"May 24th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>How can developers benefit from soft skills? Learn about the soft skills that can help software developers work better in teams and deliver better outcomes.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"How can developers benefit from soft skills? Learn about the soft skills that can help software developers work better in teams and deliver better outcomes."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"A stack of colored plastic cups, each a different color, forming a pyramid.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5JI6NTpdUsbj4rD49IyJJK/a7ac4ceed24edb35de056299e55b71d2/Image_default_DeveloperSoftSkills.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5JI6NTpdUsbj4rD49IyJJK/a7ac4ceed24edb35de056299e55b71d2/Image_default_DeveloperSoftSkills.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5JI6NTpdUsbj4rD49IyJJK/a7ac4ceed24edb35de056299e55b71d2/Image_default_DeveloperSoftSkills.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5JI6NTpdUsbj4rD49IyJJK/a7ac4ceed24edb35de056299e55b71d2/Image_default_DeveloperSoftSkills.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5JI6NTpdUsbj4rD49IyJJK/a7ac4ceed24edb35de056299e55b71d2/Image_default_DeveloperSoftSkills.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5JI6NTpdUsbj4rD49IyJJK/a7ac4ceed24edb35de056299e55b71d2/Image_default_DeveloperSoftSkills.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5JI6NTpdUsbj4rD49IyJJK/a7ac4ceed24edb35de056299e55b71d2/Image_default_DeveloperSoftSkills.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5JI6NTpdUsbj4rD49IyJJK/a7ac4ceed24edb35de056299e55b71d2/Image_default_DeveloperSoftSkills.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5JI6NTpdUsbj4rD49IyJJK/a7ac4ceed24edb35de056299e55b71d2/Image_default_DeveloperSoftSkills.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/5JI6NTpdUsbj4rD49IyJJK/a7ac4ceed24edb35de056299e55b71d2/Image_default_DeveloperSoftSkills.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Future proof your career as a developer with soft skills"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"How can developers benefit from soft skills? Learn about the soft skills that can help software developers work better in teams and deliver better outcomes."}},{"title":"Facing your fears: marketing for developers","slug":"marketing-for-developers-facing-your-fears","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"May 17th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>These days, everyone&rsquo;s a marketer - even developers. But that doesn&rsquo;t mean marketing comes easy. We talk about the fear of marketing and how devs can overcome it.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"These days, everyone’s a marketer - even developers. But that doesn’t mean marketing comes easy. We talk about the fear of marketing and how devs can overcome it."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Person standing on a rickety wooden bridge over rushing water.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1itszOsRAXmbc7Zac7noOy/4121db9f80d7cca4e9753b5b9aae5696/Image_default_FaceFears.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1itszOsRAXmbc7Zac7noOy/4121db9f80d7cca4e9753b5b9aae5696/Image_default_FaceFears.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1itszOsRAXmbc7Zac7noOy/4121db9f80d7cca4e9753b5b9aae5696/Image_default_FaceFears.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1itszOsRAXmbc7Zac7noOy/4121db9f80d7cca4e9753b5b9aae5696/Image_default_FaceFears.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1itszOsRAXmbc7Zac7noOy/4121db9f80d7cca4e9753b5b9aae5696/Image_default_FaceFears.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1itszOsRAXmbc7Zac7noOy/4121db9f80d7cca4e9753b5b9aae5696/Image_default_FaceFears.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1itszOsRAXmbc7Zac7noOy/4121db9f80d7cca4e9753b5b9aae5696/Image_default_FaceFears.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1itszOsRAXmbc7Zac7noOy/4121db9f80d7cca4e9753b5b9aae5696/Image_default_FaceFears.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1itszOsRAXmbc7Zac7noOy/4121db9f80d7cca4e9753b5b9aae5696/Image_default_FaceFears.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1itszOsRAXmbc7Zac7noOy/4121db9f80d7cca4e9753b5b9aae5696/Image_default_FaceFears.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Marketing for developers: How to face your fears"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"These days, everyone’s a marketer - even developers. But that doesn’t mean marketing comes easy. We talk about the fear of marketing and how devs can overcome it."}},{"title":"Why every developer should write a blog","slug":"developer-blog-writing-social-networks","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"May 5th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>Why should developers write blogs or post on social media? Whether you&rsquo;re freelance or looking to advance your career, creating your own content has a lot of benefits.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Why should developers write blogs or post on social media? Whether you’re freelance or looking to advance your career, creating your own content has a lot of benefits."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Woman with red hair, black top, and blue jeans sits on a blue armchair and looks at her laptop screen. The back of the screen is covered in stickers including the hashtag #LoveTwitter.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lOZNyY8P0M6dnhhv2GrYZ/1d90b43562d44cc60a524570b11b9c04/Image_default_DevelopersBlogging.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lOZNyY8P0M6dnhhv2GrYZ/1d90b43562d44cc60a524570b11b9c04/Image_default_DevelopersBlogging.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lOZNyY8P0M6dnhhv2GrYZ/1d90b43562d44cc60a524570b11b9c04/Image_default_DevelopersBlogging.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lOZNyY8P0M6dnhhv2GrYZ/1d90b43562d44cc60a524570b11b9c04/Image_default_DevelopersBlogging.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lOZNyY8P0M6dnhhv2GrYZ/1d90b43562d44cc60a524570b11b9c04/Image_default_DevelopersBlogging.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lOZNyY8P0M6dnhhv2GrYZ/1d90b43562d44cc60a524570b11b9c04/Image_default_DevelopersBlogging.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lOZNyY8P0M6dnhhv2GrYZ/1d90b43562d44cc60a524570b11b9c04/Image_default_DevelopersBlogging.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lOZNyY8P0M6dnhhv2GrYZ/1d90b43562d44cc60a524570b11b9c04/Image_default_DevelopersBlogging.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lOZNyY8P0M6dnhhv2GrYZ/1d90b43562d44cc60a524570b11b9c04/Image_default_DevelopersBlogging.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/lOZNyY8P0M6dnhhv2GrYZ/1d90b43562d44cc60a524570b11b9c04/Image_default_DevelopersBlogging.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Why developers should write: From developer blogs to social media"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Why should developers write blogs or post on social media? Whether you’re freelance or looking to advance your career, creating your own content has a lot of benefits."}},{"title":"How to increase developer productivity: 15 tips to get more done","slug":"developer-productivity","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Apr 30th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>Looking for ways to boost your team&rsquo;s productivity? We share 15 ideas including how to measure developer productivity, along with useful tools and best practices.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Looking for ways to boost your team’s productivity? We share 15 ideas including how to measure developer productivity, along with useful tools and best practices."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Photograph of honeycomb with honey bee at work on top.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3M114CzdkBjj5Maljt3vOA/3b051a266bda0a85bed916d64ec5b4ab/Bee.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3M114CzdkBjj5Maljt3vOA/3b051a266bda0a85bed916d64ec5b4ab/Bee.jpg?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3M114CzdkBjj5Maljt3vOA/3b051a266bda0a85bed916d64ec5b4ab/Bee.jpg?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3M114CzdkBjj5Maljt3vOA/3b051a266bda0a85bed916d64ec5b4ab/Bee.jpg?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3M114CzdkBjj5Maljt3vOA/3b051a266bda0a85bed916d64ec5b4ab/Bee.jpg?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3M114CzdkBjj5Maljt3vOA/3b051a266bda0a85bed916d64ec5b4ab/Bee.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3M114CzdkBjj5Maljt3vOA/3b051a266bda0a85bed916d64ec5b4ab/Bee.jpg?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3M114CzdkBjj5Maljt3vOA/3b051a266bda0a85bed916d64ec5b4ab/Bee.jpg?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3M114CzdkBjj5Maljt3vOA/3b051a266bda0a85bed916d64ec5b4ab/Bee.jpg?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3M114CzdkBjj5Maljt3vOA/3b051a266bda0a85bed916d64ec5b4ab/Bee.jpg?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"15 tips to increase developer productivity | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"Looking for ways to boost your team’s productivity? We share 15 tips on how to improve developer productivity from our own software developers and team leaders."}},{"title":"Continuously refactoring 100000 lines of code","slug":"modern-javascript-refactoring-tinymce","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Apr 28th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>Tiny has adopted a continuous improvement process to move TinyMCE to modern JavaScript. Read how we are continuously refactoring 100000 lines of code.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Tiny has adopted a continuous improvement process to move TinyMCE to modern JavaScript. Read how we are continuously refactoring 100000 lines of code."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"An evolution of the JavaScript logo (JS) to the TypeScript logo (TS), with a made up logo that looks like a combination of the two in between.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3194qQ7O0Fx9mJSzNE3nUx/07e28e06b2cb9573186a2586d8786bd6/Image_default_ModernJavascript.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3194qQ7O0Fx9mJSzNE3nUx/07e28e06b2cb9573186a2586d8786bd6/Image_default_ModernJavascript.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3194qQ7O0Fx9mJSzNE3nUx/07e28e06b2cb9573186a2586d8786bd6/Image_default_ModernJavascript.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3194qQ7O0Fx9mJSzNE3nUx/07e28e06b2cb9573186a2586d8786bd6/Image_default_ModernJavascript.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3194qQ7O0Fx9mJSzNE3nUx/07e28e06b2cb9573186a2586d8786bd6/Image_default_ModernJavascript.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3194qQ7O0Fx9mJSzNE3nUx/07e28e06b2cb9573186a2586d8786bd6/Image_default_ModernJavascript.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3194qQ7O0Fx9mJSzNE3nUx/07e28e06b2cb9573186a2586d8786bd6/Image_default_ModernJavascript.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3194qQ7O0Fx9mJSzNE3nUx/07e28e06b2cb9573186a2586d8786bd6/Image_default_ModernJavascript.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3194qQ7O0Fx9mJSzNE3nUx/07e28e06b2cb9573186a2586d8786bd6/Image_default_ModernJavascript.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/3194qQ7O0Fx9mJSzNE3nUx/07e28e06b2cb9573186a2586d8786bd6/Image_default_ModernJavascript.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Joakim Lindkvist","slug":"joakim-lindkvist"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Moving TinyMCE to Modern Javascript"},"metaDescription":null},{"title":"5 tips for building successful agile development teams","slug":"tips-for-agile-development-teams","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Apr 16th, 2020","description":{"description":"<p>What is agile development? How are agile teams structured? We cover all the basics and 5 key tips to agile success within your dev teams.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"What is agile development? How are agile teams structured? We cover all the basics and 5 key tips to agile success within your dev teams."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Four people meet in a room in front of a cork board covered in notes. They’re smiling at each other as they sit or stand at a table with laptops, notepads, and pens.","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4Hlc7ucsf6Mu8kyW56XL39/2fa25f943eb0d408e5476f7e498b35c8/woman-wearing-gray-shirt-3184298-cropped.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4Hlc7ucsf6Mu8kyW56XL39/2fa25f943eb0d408e5476f7e498b35c8/woman-wearing-gray-shirt-3184298-cropped.jpg?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4Hlc7ucsf6Mu8kyW56XL39/2fa25f943eb0d408e5476f7e498b35c8/woman-wearing-gray-shirt-3184298-cropped.jpg?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4Hlc7ucsf6Mu8kyW56XL39/2fa25f943eb0d408e5476f7e498b35c8/woman-wearing-gray-shirt-3184298-cropped.jpg?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4Hlc7ucsf6Mu8kyW56XL39/2fa25f943eb0d408e5476f7e498b35c8/woman-wearing-gray-shirt-3184298-cropped.jpg?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4Hlc7ucsf6Mu8kyW56XL39/2fa25f943eb0d408e5476f7e498b35c8/woman-wearing-gray-shirt-3184298-cropped.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4Hlc7ucsf6Mu8kyW56XL39/2fa25f943eb0d408e5476f7e498b35c8/woman-wearing-gray-shirt-3184298-cropped.jpg?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4Hlc7ucsf6Mu8kyW56XL39/2fa25f943eb0d408e5476f7e498b35c8/woman-wearing-gray-shirt-3184298-cropped.jpg?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4Hlc7ucsf6Mu8kyW56XL39/2fa25f943eb0d408e5476f7e498b35c8/woman-wearing-gray-shirt-3184298-cropped.jpg?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4Hlc7ucsf6Mu8kyW56XL39/2fa25f943eb0d408e5476f7e498b35c8/woman-wearing-gray-shirt-3184298-cropped.jpg?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Ben Long","slug":"ben-long"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Agile development teams: Practices, roles, and structure"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"What is agile development? How are agile teams structured? We cover all the basics and 5 key tips to agile success within your dev teams."}},{"title":"3 tips to improve TinyMCE performance in the cloud","slug":"3-tips-to-improve-tinymce-performance-in-the-cloud","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Nov 18th, 2019","description":{"description":"<p>Three tips to increase the performance of TinyMCE running on the cloud and take full advantage of our new CDN infrastructure.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Three tips to increase the performance of TinyMCE running on the cloud and take full advantage of our new CDN infrastructure."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Abstract illustration of a person standing at production line","artistName":"Sanni Sahil","image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.2173913043478262,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tMojlaPQtZyX7oiawtwXu/fdcee45a2bd08b2d1c7bfa74e46e6ff5/Image_default_machine.png?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tMojlaPQtZyX7oiawtwXu/fdcee45a2bd08b2d1c7bfa74e46e6ff5/Image_default_machine.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tMojlaPQtZyX7oiawtwXu/fdcee45a2bd08b2d1c7bfa74e46e6ff5/Image_default_machine.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tMojlaPQtZyX7oiawtwXu/fdcee45a2bd08b2d1c7bfa74e46e6ff5/Image_default_machine.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tMojlaPQtZyX7oiawtwXu/fdcee45a2bd08b2d1c7bfa74e46e6ff5/Image_default_machine.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fit=scale 896w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tMojlaPQtZyX7oiawtwXu/fdcee45a2bd08b2d1c7bfa74e46e6ff5/Image_default_machine.png?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tMojlaPQtZyX7oiawtwXu/fdcee45a2bd08b2d1c7bfa74e46e6ff5/Image_default_machine.png?w=185&h=152&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tMojlaPQtZyX7oiawtwXu/fdcee45a2bd08b2d1c7bfa74e46e6ff5/Image_default_machine.png?w=370&h=304&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tMojlaPQtZyX7oiawtwXu/fdcee45a2bd08b2d1c7bfa74e46e6ff5/Image_default_machine.png?w=739&h=607&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/4tMojlaPQtZyX7oiawtwXu/fdcee45a2bd08b2d1c7bfa74e46e6ff5/Image_default_machine.png?w=896&h=736&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 896w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Tim Dettrick","slug":"tim-dettrick"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null},{"title":"Charting with TinyMCE and Highcharts","slug":"charting-with-tinymce-and-highcharts","featured":false,"lastUpdated":"Oct 10th, 2018","description":{"description":"<p>Highcharts makes it easy to add beautiful, interactive charts to TinyMCE. The Tiny team is proud to introduce Highcharts as one of our Technical Partner Program launch partners.</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Highcharts makes it easy to add beautiful, interactive charts to TinyMCE. The Tiny team is proud to introduce Highcharts as one of our Technical Partner Program launch partners."}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"heroImage":{"alt":"Tiny Partner Highcharts","artistName":null,"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":3.5555555555555554,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1dfahjeX2JWq6jfH9340oH/01042bca83f8eac5257135ccdfe53f50/tiny-partner-blog-header-highcharts-1024x288.jpg?w=739&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1dfahjeX2JWq6jfH9340oH/01042bca83f8eac5257135ccdfe53f50/tiny-partner-blog-header-highcharts-1024x288.jpg?w=185&h=52&q=50&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1dfahjeX2JWq6jfH9340oH/01042bca83f8eac5257135ccdfe53f50/tiny-partner-blog-header-highcharts-1024x288.jpg?w=370&h=104&q=50&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1dfahjeX2JWq6jfH9340oH/01042bca83f8eac5257135ccdfe53f50/tiny-partner-blog-header-highcharts-1024x288.jpg?w=739&h=208&q=50&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1dfahjeX2JWq6jfH9340oH/01042bca83f8eac5257135ccdfe53f50/tiny-partner-blog-header-highcharts-1024x288.jpg?w=1024&h=288&q=50&fit=scale 1024w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1dfahjeX2JWq6jfH9340oH/01042bca83f8eac5257135ccdfe53f50/tiny-partner-blog-header-highcharts-1024x288.jpg?w=739&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1dfahjeX2JWq6jfH9340oH/01042bca83f8eac5257135ccdfe53f50/tiny-partner-blog-header-highcharts-1024x288.jpg?w=185&h=52&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 185w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1dfahjeX2JWq6jfH9340oH/01042bca83f8eac5257135ccdfe53f50/tiny-partner-blog-header-highcharts-1024x288.jpg?w=370&h=104&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 370w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1dfahjeX2JWq6jfH9340oH/01042bca83f8eac5257135ccdfe53f50/tiny-partner-blog-header-highcharts-1024x288.jpg?w=739&h=208&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 739w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1dfahjeX2JWq6jfH9340oH/01042bca83f8eac5257135ccdfe53f50/tiny-partner-blog-header-highcharts-1024x288.jpg?w=1024&h=288&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 1024w","sizes":"(max-width: 739px) 100vw, 739px"}}},"author":{"name":"Christer Vasseng","slug":"christer-vasseng"},"category":{"title":"Developer Insights","slug":"engineering"},"metaTitle":null,"metaDescription":null}]},"description":{"description":"<p>Read the story of our team's technical debt experience: handling cases of technical debt accrual in rich text editors, and how we approach the issue</p>","childMarkdownRemark":{"htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Read the story of our team's technical debt experience: handling cases of technical debt accrual in rich text editors, and how we approach the issue"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"tags":[{"slug":"technical-debt","title":"Technical Debt"},{"slug":"buy-vs-build","title":"Buy-vs-build"},{"slug":"product-development","title":"Product Development"},{"slug":"developers","title":"Developers"}],"body":{"body":"<blockquote>From January 2023, TinyMCE no longer offers Real-Time Collaboration (RTC) for new customers. For Existing customers, we'll be in contact to discuss options. Please reach out to your Account Manager if you are a customer using RTC, and you have any questions about the plugin.</blockquote>\n<div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_2\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"10\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\" data-gtm-vis-has-fired-10171822_255=\"1\">Developer insights</strong></p>\n<h1 class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1 stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1635835947787\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Dangerous examples of technical debt in rich text editors</h1>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Published {{setkaPost.lastUpdated}}</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"9\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><img class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3740221 stk-icon\" src=\"https://ceditor.setka.io/clients/D3SuW9_Vtk6NhYeFXfduUy55A4Dromkt/css/assets/44178/img/icon_clock-2022112504394454.svg\" alt=\"\" />&nbsp;{{setkaPost.readTime}}</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_15\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"9\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517294418 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">In an ideal world, the technical debt in your project is intentional and controllable. But rich text editors are complex beasts that exist in an ever-changing environment &ndash; which means one of the biggest dangers to rich text editor development is environmental tech debt.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid stk-grid__layout_columns\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last valign-middle\" data-col-width=\"2\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_0 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Millie Macdonald</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Product Manager at Halo Connect</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<hr class=\"stk-theme_44178__separator_basic_divider stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-reset\" />\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Many modern software projects rely on numerous external dependencies &ndash; libraries, frameworks, and other tools that make development easier. Usually though, you have a degree of control over those dependencies.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editors aren&rsquo;t so lucky.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editors aren&rsquo;t standalone applications</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">A rich text editor by itself isn&rsquo;t very useful &ndash; it has to be used within the context of another application. That means it has to be compatible with that application &ndash; or multiple applications, depending on how it&rsquo;s used &ndash; and be able to adapt to outside changes.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The rich text editor environment is complex</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">A rich text editor needs to support numerous browser and operating system (OS) combinations. But there are dozens of combinations, and both browsers and OSes constantly change, which makes for a very complex environment.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editors are at the mercy of many standards and specifications</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Security. Privacy. Even just the HTML specification. Rich text editors have to support, work with, implement, and comply with a wide range of standards and specifications &ndash; all of which restrict some features and require others.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Staying on top of all these external factors isn&rsquo;t simple.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">You have to know what to monitor, how to monitor it, and how to assess modification news for its impact on your rich text editor. It requires dedication, domain knowledge, and significant time investment.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Because if you don&rsquo;t do that, you&rsquo;re risking the accrual of significant environmental tech debt.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stk_f1eZ\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"OSopQ\" data-anim-trigger=\"sticky\" data-anim-sticky-offset=\"20\" data-anim-sticky-direction=\"top\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1 stk-theme_44178__mb_0\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">TABLE OF&nbsp;CONTENTS</strong></p>\n<hr class=\"stk-theme_44178__separator_basic_divider stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" />\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-1\">What is environmental tech debt?</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-2\">No new features, yet tech debt still accrues</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-3\">Tech debt example 1: User environment changes</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-4\">Tech debt example 2: Backwards compatibility in the HTML specification</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-5\">Tech debt example 3: Rich text editor security attacks and exposure</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-6\">Easiest way to avoid technical debt, is buying RTE components</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h2 id=\"stk-1\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">What is environmental tech debt?</h2>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Programmer <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ward_Cunningham\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Ward Cunningham </a>originated the technical debt metaphor, in his <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"http://c2.com/doc/oopsla92.html\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">1992 article</a>. A Google search uncovers many types of tech debt that have since been defined &ndash; especially seeing there's no rigid lines of delineation between what is and what isn&rsquo;t considered tech debt.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Three key examples of technical debt that affect a rich text editor (RTE) are:</p>\n<ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\">\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Environmental tech debt</strong> is technical debt that accumulates not because of anything <em class=\"stk-reset\">you do</em>, but because of changes in the <em class=\"stk-reset\">surrounding environment</em>. <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.splunk.com/en_us/data-insider/what-is-tech-debt.html\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Splunk goes on to say</a> that &ldquo;Failure to keep up with these changes will inevitably result in an application that no longer functions properly, and like any other form of tech debt, it is a problem that gets worse over time.&rdquo;</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Intentional tech debt</strong> is technical debt that you&rsquo;ve chosen to take on after weighing the pros and cons. <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.construx.com/10x_Software_Development/Technical_Debt/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Defined in 2007 by Steve McConnell</a>, he suggested that intentional technical debt is debt that&rsquo;s taken on consciously as a strategic tool.</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Unintentional tech debt</strong> is tech debt you don&rsquo;t realize you&rsquo;re choosing, often due to time constraints or a lack of knowledge. This type of tech debt is usually caused by internal factors and accrues while adding features, or because an aging codebase has started to accumulate cruft. In Steve McConnell&rsquo;s words, he called it &ldquo;the non-strategic result of doing a poor job.&rdquo;</li>\n</ul>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkHGId9\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkeWHiV\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stk8f6MH\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkdwH9Z\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Insights on the complexities of RTEs</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stk9u1uW\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/buy-vs-build-whitepaper/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Buy vs Build: The Great Debate White Paper</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkayc-B\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/technical-debt-whitepaper/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Opportunity Cost of Technical Debt White Paper</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkaReP5\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/cost-of-building-rich-text-editor/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Tiny puts a price tag on building your own core rich text editor</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Following McConnell&rsquo;s definition of intentional and unintentional tech debt, Martin Fowler took McConnell&rsquo;s concept a step further and published what he calls the &ldquo;<a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://martinfowler.com/bliki/TechnicalDebtQuadrant.html\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Technical Debt Quadrant.</a>&rdquo;</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Each quadrant carries different opportunity costs and trade-offs, and seemingly small decisions can have big consequences.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, environmental tech debt differs from both intentional and unintentional debt, because you have no control over the timing, frequency or rationale behind the changes forced on your codebase. All you can control is the speed of response and level of domain expertise you apply to the issues.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h2 id=\"stk-2\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">No new features, yet tech debt still accrues</h2>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">A rich text editor is inherently a very complicated application that accrues technical debt of its own accord, very easily. However, they also exist in a very complex environment.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">There&rsquo;s a lengthy list of external factors that make rich text editors prone to accumulating environmental tech debt, simply by the very fact of them existing and functioning. For a rich text editor, the source of just a few of the many potentially dangerous examples of tech debt include:</p>\n<ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\">\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Browser and OS changes</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">HTML, CSS, and JavaScript specification and implementation changes</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Changes to accessibility standards (e.g. WCAG and ARIA)</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Changes to accessibility tools (such as screen readers like Jaws)</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">New security exploits, and changes to security standards (e.g. OWASP&rsquo;s annual Top 10)</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Privacy standard changes (e.g. GDPR and SOC2)</li>\n</ul>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Changes to any one (or all) of these factors likely requires your rich text editor to adapt. Often, each of these sources has its own inherent limitations and issues (i.e the cruft in the HTML specification &ndash; see Tech Debt Example 2) which you also need to work around.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For each and every environmental change and problem, there&rsquo;s a decision to make: do you invest the time to deal with it, or do you take it on as environmental tech debt?</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">And, that&rsquo;s just for the environmental issues you know about &ndash; if you miss the news about a change or don&rsquo;t have the domain knowledge to spot a problem, you can get slammed by environmental tech debt with no warning. And it's well known you never knowingly accrue more technical debt (let alone unknown technical debt) that you have to pay off.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">To more clearly expose the potential dangers lurking in your rich text editor, here&rsquo;s a few examples of tech debt that have had major consequences.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_2\" data-stk-css=\"stkznOtI\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-jackInTheBox\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_ver_2 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628585803915 align-center stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkV_kBW\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Get more insights in our<br />Technical Debt White Paper</p>\n<a class=\"stk-theme_44178__stk-btn_1628586253530 stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628586133109 align-center stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/technical-debt-whitepaper/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\" data-stk-button=\"1\" data-ce-tag=\"button\">READ THE WHITE PAPER</a></div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Tech debt example 1</strong></p>\n<h2 id=\"stk-3\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">User environment changes</h2>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">To behave correctly, a rich text editor has to account for the environment it runs in:</p>\n<ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\">\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">The browser</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">The operating system, and</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">The device/s its users use.</li>\n</ul>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, browsers update constantly. Operating systems change in significant ways, overnight. And different device types can have very different needs and behaviors.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">It&rsquo;s difficult to develop a rich text editor that accounts for all these complications, as well as the multiple environments that constantly change&hellip; unless you have deep domain knowledge of rich text editors and their idiosyncrasies.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">There&rsquo;s worse news. Keeping track of all the changes that can </strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\">potentially</strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\"> cause you to accrue </strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\">environmental tech debt,</strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\"> is sometimes even harder than finding it all.</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h3 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_medium_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editor tech debt example: Chrome User Agent changes</h3>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">One complication that ensues from functioning within so many environments, is that the creation and maintenance of a great user experience (UX), sometimes requires environment-specific code. For example, customizing shortcuts for MacOS and Windows, or switching mouse clicks for touch gestures on phones and tablets. Or even fixing browser-specific bugs with code that only runs on that browser.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">One way to differentiate environments is by using the browser&rsquo;s User Agent string. However, this browser feature is under heavy debate, and has been for quite some years.</p>\n<h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Customisation vs end-user privacy</h4>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Unfortunately, the same features that make the User Agent string great for UX, also make it bad for privacy &ndash; because it can be used by bad actors to grab end-user data without their knowledge. This has led to far reaching discussions within the engineering community, about restricting or even replacing the User Agent string.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkBpZPo\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkJEN4L\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkFZ0ZI\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stk4uHTB\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">User agents are a complicated topic</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stk2_oEX\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">This <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Browser_detection_using_the_user_agent\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">MDN article about browser detection using the user agent</a> explains what user agents can and can&rsquo;t be used for, and the privacy risks inherent to user agents.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"11\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><span style=\"font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;\">The Chrome User Agent saga</span></div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Some parts of the User Agent string have already been frozen, resulting in <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/web-platform/how-to-detect-win11\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Windows 11</a> and <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23910280\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">MacOS Big Sur</a> onwards being reported as previous OS versions. Whereas <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Browser_detection_using_the_user_agent\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">MDN already recommends using feature detection and other methods</a> instead of the User Agent string. But one of the most controversial and debated changes has been <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/User-Agent_Client_Hints_API\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Chrome's User Agent Client Hints API</a>.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">In January 2020, <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/g/blink-dev/c/-2JIRNMWJ7s/m/yHe4tQNLCgAJ?pli=1\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Chrome announced a plan to freeze and deprecate the User Agent string</a> and replace it with the User Agent Client Hints (UA-CH) API. Compared to the User Agent string &ndash; which makes a lot of data easily accessible &ndash; UA-CH would only provide specific information to websites, if they requested it, and only over a secure connection.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">This would be a great step forward for privacy.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, other browsers haven&rsquo;t adopted UA-CH, and there are many concerns about whether UA-CH is a sufficiently strong enough replacement for the User Agent string. There are also concerns about how much development work is required to adjust to using UA-CH.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">To their credit, Chrome has delayed and changed their plans several times in response to feedback. Unfortunately, this has created uncertainty around what changes will happen, and when.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Across the world, software companies are keeping a close eye on Chrome&rsquo;s announcements.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">And given the work required to adjust, decisions have had to be made about whether to change code ahead of time, or wait until change is a requirement. <strong class=\"stk-reset\">In other words, engineering teams everywhere are deciding whether to add the User Agent string to their pile of </strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\">intentional technical debt </strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\">that&rsquo;s accumulating, or whether to pay it down.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, browser changes aren't the only problem. The opposite can be just as bad, too.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkjqjKY\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Timeline of Chrome&rsquo;s User-Agent announcements</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/user-agent-reduction-oct-2022-updates/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Aug 2022: \"Prepare for User-Agent Reduction changes in October\"</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/user-agent-reduction-deprecation-trial/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Feb 2022: \"Prepare for User-Agent Reduction changes in October\"</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/force-major-version-to-100/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Nov 2021: \"Force Chrome major version to 100 in the User-Agent string\"</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/docs/privacy-sandbox/user-agent/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Nov 2021 (updated July 2022): \"User-Agent reduction\"</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/user-agent-reduction-origin-trial/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Sept 2021 (updated Jan 2022): \"User-Agent Reduction origin trial\"</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_0 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/g/blink-dev/c/-2JIRNMWJ7s/m/yHe4tQNLCgAJ?pli=1\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Jan 2020: \"Intent to Deprecate and Freeze: The User-Agent string\"</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Tech debt example 2</p>\n<h2 id=\"stk-4\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Backwards compatibility in the HTML specification</h2>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">At first glance, tables might seem like a simple concept. However, in reality, working with HTML tables is very difficult &ndash; especially in rich text editors.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The HTML specification for tables has changed a lot since <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.w3.org/TR/2018/SPSD-html32-20180315/#table\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">tables were first added in HTML 3.2</a>. However, in order to not break old websites that are using old features, browsers tend to support both the new features <em class=\"stk-reset\">and</em> the old ones.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">This makes HTML tables a nightmare of cruft and tech debt &ndash; and rich text editors potentially have to implement and support the entire resulting mess.</strong></p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkQ7hWo\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_0\" data-stk-css=\"stkea3wZ\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkKTrXf\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">FURTHER INSIGHTS</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stklrTMY\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/technical-debt-whitepaper\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Download and read Technical Debt in Rich Text Editors White Paper &rarr;</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h3 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_medium_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editor tech debt example: RTE table complexities</h3>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Table support is one of the most complicated pieces of the TinyMCE codebase. It spans several libraries and modules, including:</p>\n<ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\">\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">Advanced Tables premium plugin</strong> repository, which implements advanced features like sorting</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/tinymce/src/plugins/table\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">Tables plugin</strong></a> module, which implements basic features like styling and adding rows and columns</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/snooker\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">Snooker</strong> module</a>, which handles manipulating table HTML for the plugin features</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/darwin\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">Darwin</strong> module</a>, which handles selection in tables</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/tinymce/src/models/dom/main/ts/table\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">DOM Table Model</strong></a>, which adds basic table support to the TinyMCE core editor</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Several more libraries and modules which are shared with other parts of TinyMCE core editor</li>\n</ul>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">&nbsp;</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">A lot of the complexity in TinyMCE&rsquo;s table code is caused by having to absorb and handle the environmental tech debt inherent in the HTML specification for tables, and the way the various browsers implement it. Why bother to do that? Because otherwise bad things happen.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Put simply, unless you ensure the table HTML can be absorbed, your whole rich text editor breaks when a user copy-pastes content from anywhere, into the table.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, to handle the HTML specifications, there&rsquo;s only two alternatives: add explicit support for it, or do the absolute minimum to prevent the editor breaking&hellip; and assign any further support to your tech debt pile.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">But remember&hellip; for every feature you do support for the HTML specifications, your code complexity grows, again making the code more prone to accruing tech debt. It&rsquo;s almost a no-win situation for rich text editors.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Let&rsquo;s look at two examples of technical debt in TinyMCE&rsquo;s table code.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Small table changes = big table problems</h4>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The modularisation of TinyMCE&rsquo;s table code usually makes development easier by isolating code for specific functionality into specific places. However, it doesn&rsquo;t completely remove the risk of changes in one library, causing ripples across the entire dependency tree.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For example, a bug fix in the Snooker module might require changes to every other library. While a new feature in the Advanced Tables premium plugin might require cascading changes all the way down to the DOM Table Model.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">This makes it easy to accrue unintentional tech debt, if you miss seeing the side-effect of a change made. And, if a fix or feature snowballs because of the ripple effect, you may well have to choose between technical debt or meeting your launch deadline.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The only real way to mitigate these issues is tapping into the deep domain knowledge of rich text editor specialists, like TinyMCE, and accessing their inhouse developer expertise.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkyGcm3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkJF7V7\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkXuPVn\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkncsJ7\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">More insights on the complexities of RTEs</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stkgDC_q\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/reduce-technical-debt/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Reduce technical debt with the right rich text editor</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkInzC1\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Managing technical debt is difficult in rich text editors</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><img class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3670816 stk-icon\" src=\"https://ceditor.setka.io/clients/D3SuW9_Vtk6NhYeFXfduUy55A4Dromkt/css/assets/44178/img/arrow-2021102714091113.svg\" alt=\"\" />&nbsp;Big table codebase = big table mess</h4>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Complex code tends to breed cruft, code rot, and tech debt, and TinyMCE&rsquo;s table code isn&rsquo;t immune. Bug fixes are fine, but occasionally, implementing new features can hit roadblocks. And sometimes, all the future-proofing and good design you&rsquo;ve done can&rsquo;t save you from needing to just rewrite the code.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For example, Advanced Tables (premium) was originally designed to only enable table sorting. It was well-designed, but a bit rushed and very focused. This caused issues when adding new features, due to how different the new features were, from sorting. In the end, it was more efficient to replace large amounts of the original code than to try to fit the new features into the old code.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-col-width=\"1\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><span style=\"font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;\">The 3-year Aggregate Decay in an Advanced Tables plugin Individual commits in a repo, by yearly cohorts, across 3 years</span></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">If HTML tables weren&rsquo;t so complicated, or browsers could support only the newest table features without breaking half the internet, this likely wouldn&rsquo;t have been necessary. But that&rsquo;s not possible, and it&rsquo;s not unique to rich text editor&rsquo;s table features and plugins.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">It applies to many aspects of rich text editors and why their code half-life is so short.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">You may be tempted to think that tables are fairly low risk, if you decide to relegate any improvements to your ever growing list of technical debt. But other aspects of rich text editors are much more dangerous. They need attention. Now.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkzFN5f\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkf4tW5\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stk-qD2s\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkOf_hd\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Is your code&rsquo;s half-life this short?</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stk9dunH\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/rte-code-half-life/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Is your code half-life shorter than your engineering career</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Tech debt example 3</p>\n<h2 id=\"stk-5\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editor security attacks and exposure</h2>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Privacy and security are always a key concern when handling user input. In a plain text form, the ways to mitigate the usual risks are well known and documented. However, rich text editors are much rarer, and much more complicated.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Security attacks can target the editor itself, the application it&rsquo;s embedded in, the environment in which it&rsquo;s running, or the server where the editor content is eventually saved. </strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">XSS attacks, DOM clobbering, JavaScript prototype pollution and structural damage to the HTML are all attack types you have to mitigate. Every rich text editor feature you add, has to be checked for privacy violations. And on top of all that, there are security and privacy standards that need to be met, such as SOC2.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkHbTMj\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397 stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">What is SOC2?</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Paraphrasing <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://secureframe.com/hub/soc-2/what-is-soc-2\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Secureframe, a SOC2 audit looks at how</a>&nbsp;<a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://secureframe.com/hub/soc-2/what-is-soc-2\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">a company handles user data</a> with regards to its security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Many big software companies, such as <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://cloud.google.com/security/compliance/soc-2\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Google</a> and <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.atlassian.com/trust/compliance/resources/soc2\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Atlassian</a>, as well as open source maintainers like <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://blog.tidelift.com/tidelift-completes-soc-2-type-2-examination\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Tidelift</a>, publicize their SOC2 attainment and results.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">There&rsquo;s a lot to manage, with rich text editor security:</p>\n<ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\">\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Defending against attack vectors</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Protecting your users&rsquo; privacy</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Meeting the relevant standards.</li>\n</ul>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">All that takes time and domain expertise in rich text editors. And it isn&rsquo;t a one-off problem. New vulnerabilities are constantly being found. New attacks are constantly being reported. Privacy standards are constantly changing. It doesn't ever end.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For rich text editors, it&rsquo;s never-ending work, and relegating tasks to the tech debt &lsquo;fix later&rsquo; list can be dangerous, especially when it comes to security issues. Sometimes though, the really hard issues just <em class=\"stk-reset\">have</em> to be fixed.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>","childMarkdownRemark":{"html":"<blockquote>From January 2023, TinyMCE no longer offers Real-Time Collaboration (RTC) for new customers. For Existing customers, we'll be in contact to discuss options. Please reach out to your Account Manager if you are a customer using RTC, and you have any questions about the plugin.</blockquote>\n<div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_2\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"10\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\" data-gtm-vis-has-fired-10171822_255=\"1\">Developer insights</strong></p>\n<h1 class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1 stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1635835947787\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Dangerous examples of technical debt in rich text editors</h1>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Published {{setkaPost.lastUpdated}}</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"9\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><img class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3740221 stk-icon\" src=\"https://ceditor.setka.io/clients/D3SuW9_Vtk6NhYeFXfduUy55A4Dromkt/css/assets/44178/img/icon_clock-2022112504394454.svg\" alt=\"\" />&nbsp;{{setkaPost.readTime}}</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_15\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"9\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517294418 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">In an ideal world, the technical debt in your project is intentional and controllable. But rich text editors are complex beasts that exist in an ever-changing environment &ndash; which means one of the biggest dangers to rich text editor development is environmental tech debt.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid stk-grid__layout_columns\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last valign-middle\" data-col-width=\"2\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_0 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Millie Macdonald</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Product Manager at Halo Connect</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<hr class=\"stk-theme_44178__separator_basic_divider stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-reset\" />\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Many modern software projects rely on numerous external dependencies &ndash; libraries, frameworks, and other tools that make development easier. Usually though, you have a degree of control over those dependencies.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editors aren&rsquo;t so lucky.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editors aren&rsquo;t standalone applications</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">A rich text editor by itself isn&rsquo;t very useful &ndash; it has to be used within the context of another application. That means it has to be compatible with that application &ndash; or multiple applications, depending on how it&rsquo;s used &ndash; and be able to adapt to outside changes.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The rich text editor environment is complex</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">A rich text editor needs to support numerous browser and operating system (OS) combinations. But there are dozens of combinations, and both browsers and OSes constantly change, which makes for a very complex environment.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editors are at the mercy of many standards and specifications</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Security. Privacy. Even just the HTML specification. Rich text editors have to support, work with, implement, and comply with a wide range of standards and specifications &ndash; all of which restrict some features and require others.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Staying on top of all these external factors isn&rsquo;t simple.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">You have to know what to monitor, how to monitor it, and how to assess modification news for its impact on your rich text editor. It requires dedication, domain knowledge, and significant time investment.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Because if you don&rsquo;t do that, you&rsquo;re risking the accrual of significant environmental tech debt.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stk_f1eZ\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"OSopQ\" data-anim-trigger=\"sticky\" data-anim-sticky-offset=\"20\" data-anim-sticky-direction=\"top\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1 stk-theme_44178__mb_0\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">TABLE OF&nbsp;CONTENTS</strong></p>\n<hr class=\"stk-theme_44178__separator_basic_divider stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" />\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-1\">What is environmental tech debt?</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-2\">No new features, yet tech debt still accrues</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-3\">Tech debt example 1: User environment changes</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-4\">Tech debt example 2: Backwards compatibility in the HTML specification</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-5\">Tech debt example 3: Rich text editor security attacks and exposure</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-6\">Easiest way to avoid technical debt, is buying RTE components</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h2 id=\"stk-1\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">What is environmental tech debt?</h2>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Programmer <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ward_Cunningham\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Ward Cunningham </a>originated the technical debt metaphor, in his <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"http://c2.com/doc/oopsla92.html\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">1992 article</a>. A Google search uncovers many types of tech debt that have since been defined &ndash; especially seeing there's no rigid lines of delineation between what is and what isn&rsquo;t considered tech debt.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Three key examples of technical debt that affect a rich text editor (RTE) are:</p>\n<ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\">\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Environmental tech debt</strong> is technical debt that accumulates not because of anything <em class=\"stk-reset\">you do</em>, but because of changes in the <em class=\"stk-reset\">surrounding environment</em>. <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.splunk.com/en_us/data-insider/what-is-tech-debt.html\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Splunk goes on to say</a> that &ldquo;Failure to keep up with these changes will inevitably result in an application that no longer functions properly, and like any other form of tech debt, it is a problem that gets worse over time.&rdquo;</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Intentional tech debt</strong> is technical debt that you&rsquo;ve chosen to take on after weighing the pros and cons. <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.construx.com/10x_Software_Development/Technical_Debt/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Defined in 2007 by Steve McConnell</a>, he suggested that intentional technical debt is debt that&rsquo;s taken on consciously as a strategic tool.</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Unintentional tech debt</strong> is tech debt you don&rsquo;t realize you&rsquo;re choosing, often due to time constraints or a lack of knowledge. This type of tech debt is usually caused by internal factors and accrues while adding features, or because an aging codebase has started to accumulate cruft. In Steve McConnell&rsquo;s words, he called it &ldquo;the non-strategic result of doing a poor job.&rdquo;</li>\n</ul>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkHGId9\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkeWHiV\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stk8f6MH\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkdwH9Z\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Insights on the complexities of RTEs</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stk9u1uW\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/buy-vs-build-whitepaper/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Buy vs Build: The Great Debate White Paper</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkayc-B\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/technical-debt-whitepaper/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Opportunity Cost of Technical Debt White Paper</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkaReP5\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/cost-of-building-rich-text-editor/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Tiny puts a price tag on building your own core rich text editor</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Following McConnell&rsquo;s definition of intentional and unintentional tech debt, Martin Fowler took McConnell&rsquo;s concept a step further and published what he calls the &ldquo;<a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://martinfowler.com/bliki/TechnicalDebtQuadrant.html\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Technical Debt Quadrant.</a>&rdquo;</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Each quadrant carries different opportunity costs and trade-offs, and seemingly small decisions can have big consequences.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, environmental tech debt differs from both intentional and unintentional debt, because you have no control over the timing, frequency or rationale behind the changes forced on your codebase. All you can control is the speed of response and level of domain expertise you apply to the issues.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h2 id=\"stk-2\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">No new features, yet tech debt still accrues</h2>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">A rich text editor is inherently a very complicated application that accrues technical debt of its own accord, very easily. However, they also exist in a very complex environment.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">There&rsquo;s a lengthy list of external factors that make rich text editors prone to accumulating environmental tech debt, simply by the very fact of them existing and functioning. For a rich text editor, the source of just a few of the many potentially dangerous examples of tech debt include:</p>\n<ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\">\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Browser and OS changes</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">HTML, CSS, and JavaScript specification and implementation changes</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Changes to accessibility standards (e.g. WCAG and ARIA)</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Changes to accessibility tools (such as screen readers like Jaws)</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">New security exploits, and changes to security standards (e.g. OWASP&rsquo;s annual Top 10)</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Privacy standard changes (e.g. GDPR and SOC2)</li>\n</ul>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Changes to any one (or all) of these factors likely requires your rich text editor to adapt. Often, each of these sources has its own inherent limitations and issues (i.e the cruft in the HTML specification &ndash; see Tech Debt Example 2) which you also need to work around.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For each and every environmental change and problem, there&rsquo;s a decision to make: do you invest the time to deal with it, or do you take it on as environmental tech debt?</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">And, that&rsquo;s just for the environmental issues you know about &ndash; if you miss the news about a change or don&rsquo;t have the domain knowledge to spot a problem, you can get slammed by environmental tech debt with no warning. And it's well known you never knowingly accrue more technical debt (let alone unknown technical debt) that you have to pay off.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">To more clearly expose the potential dangers lurking in your rich text editor, here&rsquo;s a few examples of tech debt that have had major consequences.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_2\" data-stk-css=\"stkznOtI\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-jackInTheBox\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_ver_2 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628585803915 align-center stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkV_kBW\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Get more insights in our<br />Technical Debt White Paper</p>\n<a class=\"stk-theme_44178__stk-btn_1628586253530 stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628586133109 align-center stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/technical-debt-whitepaper/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\" data-stk-button=\"1\" data-ce-tag=\"button\">READ THE WHITE PAPER</a></div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Tech debt example 1</strong></p>\n<h2 id=\"stk-3\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">User environment changes</h2>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">To behave correctly, a rich text editor has to account for the environment it runs in:</p>\n<ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\">\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">The browser</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">The operating system, and</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">The device/s its users use.</li>\n</ul>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, browsers update constantly. Operating systems change in significant ways, overnight. And different device types can have very different needs and behaviors.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">It&rsquo;s difficult to develop a rich text editor that accounts for all these complications, as well as the multiple environments that constantly change&hellip; unless you have deep domain knowledge of rich text editors and their idiosyncrasies.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">There&rsquo;s worse news. Keeping track of all the changes that can </strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\">potentially</strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\"> cause you to accrue </strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\">environmental tech debt,</strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\"> is sometimes even harder than finding it all.</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h3 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_medium_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editor tech debt example: Chrome User Agent changes</h3>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">One complication that ensues from functioning within so many environments, is that the creation and maintenance of a great user experience (UX), sometimes requires environment-specific code. For example, customizing shortcuts for MacOS and Windows, or switching mouse clicks for touch gestures on phones and tablets. Or even fixing browser-specific bugs with code that only runs on that browser.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">One way to differentiate environments is by using the browser&rsquo;s User Agent string. However, this browser feature is under heavy debate, and has been for quite some years.</p>\n<h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Customisation vs end-user privacy</h4>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Unfortunately, the same features that make the User Agent string great for UX, also make it bad for privacy &ndash; because it can be used by bad actors to grab end-user data without their knowledge. This has led to far reaching discussions within the engineering community, about restricting or even replacing the User Agent string.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkBpZPo\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkJEN4L\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkFZ0ZI\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stk4uHTB\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">User agents are a complicated topic</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stk2_oEX\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">This <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Browser_detection_using_the_user_agent\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">MDN article about browser detection using the user agent</a> explains what user agents can and can&rsquo;t be used for, and the privacy risks inherent to user agents.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"11\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><span style=\"font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;\">The Chrome User Agent saga</span></div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Some parts of the User Agent string have already been frozen, resulting in <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/web-platform/how-to-detect-win11\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Windows 11</a> and <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23910280\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">MacOS Big Sur</a> onwards being reported as previous OS versions. Whereas <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Browser_detection_using_the_user_agent\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">MDN already recommends using feature detection and other methods</a> instead of the User Agent string. But one of the most controversial and debated changes has been <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/User-Agent_Client_Hints_API\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Chrome's User Agent Client Hints API</a>.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">In January 2020, <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/g/blink-dev/c/-2JIRNMWJ7s/m/yHe4tQNLCgAJ?pli=1\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Chrome announced a plan to freeze and deprecate the User Agent string</a> and replace it with the User Agent Client Hints (UA-CH) API. Compared to the User Agent string &ndash; which makes a lot of data easily accessible &ndash; UA-CH would only provide specific information to websites, if they requested it, and only over a secure connection.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">This would be a great step forward for privacy.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, other browsers haven&rsquo;t adopted UA-CH, and there are many concerns about whether UA-CH is a sufficiently strong enough replacement for the User Agent string. There are also concerns about how much development work is required to adjust to using UA-CH.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">To their credit, Chrome has delayed and changed their plans several times in response to feedback. Unfortunately, this has created uncertainty around what changes will happen, and when.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Across the world, software companies are keeping a close eye on Chrome&rsquo;s announcements.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">And given the work required to adjust, decisions have had to be made about whether to change code ahead of time, or wait until change is a requirement. <strong class=\"stk-reset\">In other words, engineering teams everywhere are deciding whether to add the User Agent string to their pile of </strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\">intentional technical debt </strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\">that&rsquo;s accumulating, or whether to pay it down.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, browser changes aren't the only problem. The opposite can be just as bad, too.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkjqjKY\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Timeline of Chrome&rsquo;s User-Agent announcements</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/user-agent-reduction-oct-2022-updates/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Aug 2022: \"Prepare for User-Agent Reduction changes in October\"</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/user-agent-reduction-deprecation-trial/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Feb 2022: \"Prepare for User-Agent Reduction changes in October\"</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/force-major-version-to-100/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Nov 2021: \"Force Chrome major version to 100 in the User-Agent string\"</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/docs/privacy-sandbox/user-agent/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Nov 2021 (updated July 2022): \"User-Agent reduction\"</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/user-agent-reduction-origin-trial/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Sept 2021 (updated Jan 2022): \"User-Agent Reduction origin trial\"</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_0 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/g/blink-dev/c/-2JIRNMWJ7s/m/yHe4tQNLCgAJ?pli=1\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Jan 2020: \"Intent to Deprecate and Freeze: The User-Agent string\"</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Tech debt example 2</p>\n<h2 id=\"stk-4\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Backwards compatibility in the HTML specification</h2>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">At first glance, tables might seem like a simple concept. However, in reality, working with HTML tables is very difficult &ndash; especially in rich text editors.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The HTML specification for tables has changed a lot since <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.w3.org/TR/2018/SPSD-html32-20180315/#table\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">tables were first added in HTML 3.2</a>. However, in order to not break old websites that are using old features, browsers tend to support both the new features <em class=\"stk-reset\">and</em> the old ones.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">This makes HTML tables a nightmare of cruft and tech debt &ndash; and rich text editors potentially have to implement and support the entire resulting mess.</strong></p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkQ7hWo\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_0\" data-stk-css=\"stkea3wZ\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkKTrXf\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">FURTHER INSIGHTS</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stklrTMY\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/technical-debt-whitepaper\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Download and read Technical Debt in Rich Text Editors White Paper &rarr;</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h3 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_medium_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editor tech debt example: RTE table complexities</h3>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Table support is one of the most complicated pieces of the TinyMCE codebase. It spans several libraries and modules, including:</p>\n<ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\">\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">Advanced Tables premium plugin</strong> repository, which implements advanced features like sorting</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/tinymce/src/plugins/table\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">Tables plugin</strong></a> module, which implements basic features like styling and adding rows and columns</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/snooker\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">Snooker</strong> module</a>, which handles manipulating table HTML for the plugin features</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/darwin\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">Darwin</strong> module</a>, which handles selection in tables</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/tinymce/src/models/dom/main/ts/table\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">DOM Table Model</strong></a>, which adds basic table support to the TinyMCE core editor</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Several more libraries and modules which are shared with other parts of TinyMCE core editor</li>\n</ul>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">&nbsp;</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">A lot of the complexity in TinyMCE&rsquo;s table code is caused by having to absorb and handle the environmental tech debt inherent in the HTML specification for tables, and the way the various browsers implement it. Why bother to do that? Because otherwise bad things happen.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Put simply, unless you ensure the table HTML can be absorbed, your whole rich text editor breaks when a user copy-pastes content from anywhere, into the table.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, to handle the HTML specifications, there&rsquo;s only two alternatives: add explicit support for it, or do the absolute minimum to prevent the editor breaking&hellip; and assign any further support to your tech debt pile.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">But remember&hellip; for every feature you do support for the HTML specifications, your code complexity grows, again making the code more prone to accruing tech debt. It&rsquo;s almost a no-win situation for rich text editors.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Let&rsquo;s look at two examples of technical debt in TinyMCE&rsquo;s table code.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Small table changes = big table problems</h4>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The modularisation of TinyMCE&rsquo;s table code usually makes development easier by isolating code for specific functionality into specific places. However, it doesn&rsquo;t completely remove the risk of changes in one library, causing ripples across the entire dependency tree.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For example, a bug fix in the Snooker module might require changes to every other library. While a new feature in the Advanced Tables premium plugin might require cascading changes all the way down to the DOM Table Model.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">This makes it easy to accrue unintentional tech debt, if you miss seeing the side-effect of a change made. And, if a fix or feature snowballs because of the ripple effect, you may well have to choose between technical debt or meeting your launch deadline.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The only real way to mitigate these issues is tapping into the deep domain knowledge of rich text editor specialists, like TinyMCE, and accessing their inhouse developer expertise.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkyGcm3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkJF7V7\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkXuPVn\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkncsJ7\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">More insights on the complexities of RTEs</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stkgDC_q\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/reduce-technical-debt/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Reduce technical debt with the right rich text editor</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkInzC1\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Managing technical debt is difficult in rich text editors</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><img class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3670816 stk-icon\" src=\"https://ceditor.setka.io/clients/D3SuW9_Vtk6NhYeFXfduUy55A4Dromkt/css/assets/44178/img/arrow-2021102714091113.svg\" alt=\"\" />&nbsp;Big table codebase = big table mess</h4>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Complex code tends to breed cruft, code rot, and tech debt, and TinyMCE&rsquo;s table code isn&rsquo;t immune. Bug fixes are fine, but occasionally, implementing new features can hit roadblocks. And sometimes, all the future-proofing and good design you&rsquo;ve done can&rsquo;t save you from needing to just rewrite the code.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For example, Advanced Tables (premium) was originally designed to only enable table sorting. It was well-designed, but a bit rushed and very focused. This caused issues when adding new features, due to how different the new features were, from sorting. In the end, it was more efficient to replace large amounts of the original code than to try to fit the new features into the old code.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-col-width=\"1\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><span style=\"font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;\">The 3-year Aggregate Decay in an Advanced Tables plugin Individual commits in a repo, by yearly cohorts, across 3 years</span></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">If HTML tables weren&rsquo;t so complicated, or browsers could support only the newest table features without breaking half the internet, this likely wouldn&rsquo;t have been necessary. But that&rsquo;s not possible, and it&rsquo;s not unique to rich text editor&rsquo;s table features and plugins.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">It applies to many aspects of rich text editors and why their code half-life is so short.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">You may be tempted to think that tables are fairly low risk, if you decide to relegate any improvements to your ever growing list of technical debt. But other aspects of rich text editors are much more dangerous. They need attention. Now.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkzFN5f\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkf4tW5\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stk-qD2s\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkOf_hd\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Is your code&rsquo;s half-life this short?</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stk9dunH\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/rte-code-half-life/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Is your code half-life shorter than your engineering career</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Tech debt example 3</p>\n<h2 id=\"stk-5\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editor security attacks and exposure</h2>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Privacy and security are always a key concern when handling user input. In a plain text form, the ways to mitigate the usual risks are well known and documented. However, rich text editors are much rarer, and much more complicated.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Security attacks can target the editor itself, the application it&rsquo;s embedded in, the environment in which it&rsquo;s running, or the server where the editor content is eventually saved. </strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">XSS attacks, DOM clobbering, JavaScript prototype pollution and structural damage to the HTML are all attack types you have to mitigate. Every rich text editor feature you add, has to be checked for privacy violations. And on top of all that, there are security and privacy standards that need to be met, such as SOC2.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkHbTMj\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397 stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">What is SOC2?</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Paraphrasing <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://secureframe.com/hub/soc-2/what-is-soc-2\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Secureframe, a SOC2 audit looks at how</a>&nbsp;<a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://secureframe.com/hub/soc-2/what-is-soc-2\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">a company handles user data</a> with regards to its security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Many big software companies, such as <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://cloud.google.com/security/compliance/soc-2\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Google</a> and <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.atlassian.com/trust/compliance/resources/soc2\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Atlassian</a>, as well as open source maintainers like <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://blog.tidelift.com/tidelift-completes-soc-2-type-2-examination\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Tidelift</a>, publicize their SOC2 attainment and results.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">There&rsquo;s a lot to manage, with rich text editor security:</p>\n<ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\">\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Defending against attack vectors</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Protecting your users&rsquo; privacy</li>\n<li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Meeting the relevant standards.</li>\n</ul>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">All that takes time and domain expertise in rich text editors. And it isn&rsquo;t a one-off problem. New vulnerabilities are constantly being found. New attacks are constantly being reported. Privacy standards are constantly changing. It doesn't ever end.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For rich text editors, it&rsquo;s never-ending work, and relegating tasks to the tech debt &lsquo;fix later&rsquo; list can be dangerous, especially when it comes to security issues. Sometimes though, the really hard issues just <em class=\"stk-reset\">have</em> to be fixed.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>","htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"blockquote","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"From January 2023, TinyMCE no longer offers Real-Time Collaboration (RTC) for new customers. For Existing customers, we'll be in contact to discuss options. Please reach out to your Account Manager if you are a customer using RTC, and you have any questions about the plugin."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid","stk-theme_44178__mb_2"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"12","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"10","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2","stk-theme_44178__mb_05"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataGtmVisHasFired-10171822_255":"1"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Developer insights"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h1","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1","stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1635835947787"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Dangerous examples of technical debt in rich text editors"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataStkCss":"","dataStkCssM":"","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Published {{setkaPost.lastUpdated}}"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"9","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"img","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3740221","stk-icon"],"src":"https://ceditor.setka.io/clients/D3SuW9_Vtk6NhYeFXfduUy55A4Dromkt/css/assets/44178/img/icon_clock-2022112504394454.svg","alt":""},"children":[]},{"type":"text","value":" {{setkaPost.readTime}}"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid","stk-theme_44178__mb_15"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"9","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517294418","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"In an ideal world, the technical debt in your project is intentional and controllable. But rich text editors are complex beasts that exist in an ever-changing environment – which means one of the biggest dangers to rich text editor development is environmental tech debt."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid","stk-grid__layout_columns"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last","valign-middle"],"dataColWidth":"2","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-theme_44178__mb_0","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Millie Macdonald"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Product Manager at Halo Connect"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"hr","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__separator_basic_divider","stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-reset"]},"children":[]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Many modern software projects rely on numerous external dependencies – libraries, frameworks, and other tools that make development easier. Usually though, you have a degree of control over those dependencies."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Rich text editors aren’t so lucky."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Rich text editors aren’t standalone applications"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"A rich text editor by itself isn’t very useful – it has to be used within the context of another application. That means it has to be compatible with that application – or multiple applications, depending on how it’s used – and be able to adapt to outside changes."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The rich text editor environment is complex"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"A rich text editor needs to support numerous browser and operating system (OS) combinations. But there are dozens of combinations, and both browsers and OSes constantly change, which makes for a very complex environment."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Rich text editors are at the mercy of many standards and specifications"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Security. Privacy. Even just the HTML specification. Rich text editors have to support, work with, implement, and comply with a wide range of standards and specifications – all of which restrict some features and require others."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Staying on top of all these external factors isn’t simple."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"You have to know what to monitor, how to monitor it, and how to assess modification news for its impact on your rich text editor. It requires dedication, domain knowledge, and significant time investment."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Because if you don’t do that, you’re risking the accrual of significant environmental tech debt."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stk_f1eZ","dataAnimM":"false","dataCeTag":"grid","dataAnim":"true","dataAnimName":"OSopQ","dataAnimTrigger":"sticky","dataAnimStickyOffset":"20","dataAnimStickyDirection":"top"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1","stk-theme_44178__mb_0"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"TABLE OF CONTENTS"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"hr","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__separator_basic_divider","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"]},"children":[]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"#stk-1"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"What is environmental tech debt?"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"#stk-2"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"No new features, yet tech debt still accrues"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"#stk-3"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Tech debt example 1: User environment changes"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__mb_05"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"#stk-4"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Tech debt example 2: Backwards compatibility in the HTML specification"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"#stk-5"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Tech debt example 3: Rich text editor security attacks and exposure"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"#stk-6"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Easiest way to avoid technical debt, is buying RTE components"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h2","properties":{"id":"stk-1","className":["stk-theme_44178__style_large_header","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"What is environmental tech debt?"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Programmer "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ward_Cunningham","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Ward Cunningham "}]},{"type":"text","value":"originated the technical debt metaphor, in his "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"http://c2.com/doc/oopsla92.html","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"1992 article"}]},{"type":"text","value":". A Google search uncovers many types of tech debt that have since been defined – especially seeing there's no rigid lines of delineation between what is and what isn’t considered tech debt."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Three key examples of technical debt that affect a rich text editor (RTE) are:"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"ul","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"list"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Environmental tech debt"}]},{"type":"text","value":" is technical debt that accumulates not because of anything "},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"you do"}]},{"type":"text","value":", but because of changes in the "},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"surrounding environment"}]},{"type":"text","value":". "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://www.splunk.com/en_us/data-insider/what-is-tech-debt.html","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Splunk goes on to say"}]},{"type":"text","value":" that “Failure to keep up with these changes will inevitably result in an application that no longer functions properly, and like any other form of tech debt, it is a problem that gets worse over time.”"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Intentional tech debt"}]},{"type":"text","value":" is technical debt that you’ve chosen to take on after weighing the pros and cons. "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://www.construx.com/10x_Software_Development/Technical_Debt/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Defined in 2007 by Steve McConnell"}]},{"type":"text","value":", he suggested that intentional technical debt is debt that’s taken on consciously as a strategic tool."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Unintentional tech debt"}]},{"type":"text","value":" is tech debt you don’t realize you’re choosing, often due to time constraints or a lack of knowledge. This type of tech debt is usually caused by internal factors and accrues while adding features, or because an aging codebase has started to accumulate cruft. In Steve McConnell’s words, he called it “the non-strategic result of doing a poor job.”"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["valign-middle","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkHGId9","dataCeTag":"grid","dataAnimM":"false","dataAnim":"true","dataAnimName":"preset-slideInRight","dataAnimTrigger":"scroll","dataAnimDuration":"1","dataAnimDelay":"0","dataAnimScrollStart":"10","dataAnimScrollFinish":"90"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkeWHiV","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataStkCss":"stk8f6MH","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"read MORE"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataStkCss":"stkdwH9Z","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Insights on the complexities of RTEs"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__mb_05"],"dataStkCss":"stk9u1uW","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://www.tiny.cloud/buy-vs-build-whitepaper/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Buy vs Build: The Great Debate White Paper"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataStkCss":"stkayc-B","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://www.tiny.cloud/technical-debt-whitepaper/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Opportunity Cost of Technical Debt White Paper"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset"],"dataStkCss":"stkaReP5","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/cost-of-building-rich-text-editor/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Tiny puts a price tag on building your own core rich text editor"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Following McConnell’s definition of intentional and unintentional tech debt, Martin Fowler took McConnell’s concept a step further and published what he calls the “"},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://martinfowler.com/bliki/TechnicalDebtQuadrant.html","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Technical Debt Quadrant."}]},{"type":"text","value":"”"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Each quadrant carries different opportunity costs and trade-offs, and seemingly small decisions can have big consequences."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"However, environmental tech debt differs from both intentional and unintentional debt, because you have no control over the timing, frequency or rationale behind the changes forced on your codebase. All you can control is the speed of response and level of domain expertise you apply to the issues."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h2","properties":{"id":"stk-2","className":["stk-theme_44178__style_large_header","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"No new features, yet tech debt still accrues"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"A rich text editor is inherently a very complicated application that accrues technical debt of its own accord, very easily. However, they also exist in a very complex environment."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"There’s a lengthy list of external factors that make rich text editors prone to accumulating environmental tech debt, simply by the very fact of them existing and functioning. For a rich text editor, the source of just a few of the many potentially dangerous examples of tech debt include:"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"ul","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"list"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Browser and OS changes"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"HTML, CSS, and JavaScript specification and implementation changes"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Changes to accessibility standards (e.g. WCAG and ARIA)"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Changes to accessibility tools (such as screen readers like Jaws)"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"New security exploits, and changes to security standards (e.g. OWASP’s annual Top 10)"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Privacy standard changes (e.g. GDPR and SOC2)"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Changes to any one (or all) of these factors likely requires your rich text editor to adapt. Often, each of these sources has its own inherent limitations and issues (i.e the cruft in the HTML specification – see Tech Debt Example 2) which you also need to work around."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"For each and every environmental change and problem, there’s a decision to make: do you invest the time to deal with it, or do you take it on as environmental tech debt?"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"And, that’s just for the environmental issues you know about – if you miss the news about a change or don’t have the domain knowledge to spot a problem, you can get slammed by environmental tech debt with no warning. And it's well known you never knowingly accrue more technical debt (let alone unknown technical debt) that you have to pay off."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"To more clearly expose the potential dangers lurking in your rich text editor, here’s a few examples of tech debt that have had major consequences."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid","stk-theme_44178__mb_2"],"dataStkCss":"stkznOtI","dataAnimM":"false","dataAnim":"true","dataAnimName":"preset-jackInTheBox","dataAnimTrigger":"scroll","dataAnimDuration":"1","dataAnimDelay":"0","dataAnimScrollStart":"10","dataAnimScrollFinish":"90","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__pad_ver_2","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"12","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628585803915","align-center","stk-reset"],"dataStkCss":"stkV_kBW","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Get more insights in our"},{"type":"element","tagName":"br","properties":{},"children":[]},{"type":"text","value":"Technical Debt White Paper"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__stk-btn_1628586253530","stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628586133109","align-center","stk-reset"],"href":"https://www.tiny.cloud/technical-debt-whitepaper/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"],"dataStkButton":"1","dataCeTag":"button"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"READ THE WHITE PAPER"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"12","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2","stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Tech debt example 1"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h2","properties":{"id":"stk-3","className":["stk-theme_44178__style_large_header","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"User environment changes"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"To behave correctly, a rich text editor has to account for the environment it runs in:"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"ul","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"list"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The browser"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The operating system, and"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The device/s its users use."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"However, browsers update constantly. Operating systems change in significant ways, overnight. And different device types can have very different needs and behaviors."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"It’s difficult to develop a rich text editor that accounts for all these complications, as well as the multiple environments that constantly change… unless you have deep domain knowledge of rich text editors and their idiosyncrasies."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"There’s worse news. Keeping track of all the changes that can "}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"potentially"}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":" cause you to accrue "}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"environmental tech debt,"}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":" is sometimes even harder than finding it all."}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h3","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_medium_header","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Rich text editor tech debt example: Chrome User Agent changes"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"One complication that ensues from functioning within so many environments, is that the creation and maintenance of a great user experience (UX), sometimes requires environment-specific code. For example, customizing shortcuts for MacOS and Windows, or switching mouse clicks for touch gestures on phones and tablets. Or even fixing browser-specific bugs with code that only runs on that browser."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_15","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"One way to differentiate environments is by using the browser’s User Agent string. However, this browser feature is under heavy debate, and has been for quite some years."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h4","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_header","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Customisation vs end-user privacy"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Unfortunately, the same features that make the User Agent string great for UX, also make it bad for privacy – because it can be used by bad actors to grab end-user data without their knowledge. This has led to far reaching discussions within the engineering community, about restricting or even replacing the User Agent string."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["valign-middle","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkBpZPo","dataCeTag":"grid","dataAnimM":"false","dataAnim":"true","dataAnimName":"preset-slideInRight","dataAnimTrigger":"scroll","dataAnimDuration":"1","dataAnimDelay":"0","dataAnimScrollStart":"10","dataAnimScrollFinish":"90"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkJEN4L","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataStkCss":"stkFZ0ZI","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"read MORE"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataStkCss":"stk4uHTB","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"User agents are a complicated topic"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__mb_05"],"dataStkCss":"stk2_oEX","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"This "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Browser_detection_using_the_user_agent","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"MDN article about browser detection using the user agent"}]},{"type":"text","value":" explains what user agents can and can’t be used for, and the privacy risks inherent to user agents."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"11","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"span","properties":{"style":"font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The Chrome User Agent saga"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Some parts of the User Agent string have already been frozen, resulting in "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/web-platform/how-to-detect-win11","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Windows 11"}]},{"type":"text","value":" and "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23910280","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"MacOS Big Sur"}]},{"type":"text","value":" onwards being reported as previous OS versions. Whereas "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Browser_detection_using_the_user_agent","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"MDN already recommends using feature detection and other methods"}]},{"type":"text","value":" instead of the User Agent string. But one of the most controversial and debated changes has been "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/User-Agent_Client_Hints_API","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Chrome's User Agent Client Hints API"}]},{"type":"text","value":"."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"In January 2020, "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/g/blink-dev/c/-2JIRNMWJ7s/m/yHe4tQNLCgAJ?pli=1","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Chrome announced a plan to freeze and deprecate the User Agent string"}]},{"type":"text","value":" and replace it with the User Agent Client Hints (UA-CH) API. Compared to the User Agent string – which makes a lot of data easily accessible – UA-CH would only provide specific information to websites, if they requested it, and only over a secure connection."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"This would be a great step forward for privacy."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"However, other browsers haven’t adopted UA-CH, and there are many concerns about whether UA-CH is a sufficiently strong enough replacement for the User Agent string. There are also concerns about how much development work is required to adjust to using UA-CH."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"To their credit, Chrome has delayed and changed their plans several times in response to feedback. Unfortunately, this has created uncertainty around what changes will happen, and when."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Across the world, software companies are keeping a close eye on Chrome’s announcements."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"And given the work required to adjust, decisions have had to be made about whether to change code ahead of time, or wait until change is a requirement. "},{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"In other words, engineering teams everywhere are deciding whether to add the User Agent string to their pile of "}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"intentional technical debt "}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"that’s accumulating, or whether to pay it down."}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"However, browser changes aren't the only problem. The opposite can be just as bad, too."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkjqjKY","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Timeline of Chrome’s User-Agent announcements"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/user-agent-reduction-oct-2022-updates/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Aug 2022: \"Prepare for User-Agent Reduction changes in October\""}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/user-agent-reduction-deprecation-trial/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Feb 2022: \"Prepare for User-Agent Reduction changes in October\""}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/force-major-version-to-100/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Nov 2021: \"Force Chrome major version to 100 in the User-Agent string\""}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://developer.chrome.com/docs/privacy-sandbox/user-agent/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Nov 2021 (updated July 2022): \"User-Agent reduction\""}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/user-agent-reduction-origin-trial/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Sept 2021 (updated Jan 2022): \"User-Agent Reduction origin trial\""}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__mb_0","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/g/blink-dev/c/-2JIRNMWJ7s/m/yHe4tQNLCgAJ?pli=1","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Jan 2020: \"Intent to Deprecate and Freeze: The User-Agent string\""}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"12","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Tech debt example 2"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h2","properties":{"id":"stk-4","className":["stk-theme_44178__style_large_header","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Backwards compatibility in the HTML specification"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"At first glance, tables might seem like a simple concept. However, in reality, working with HTML tables is very difficult – especially in rich text editors."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The HTML specification for tables has changed a lot since "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://www.w3.org/TR/2018/SPSD-html32-20180315/#table","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"tables were first added in HTML 3.2"}]},{"type":"text","value":". However, in order to not break old websites that are using old features, browsers tend to support both the new features "},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"and"}]},{"type":"text","value":" the old ones."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"This makes HTML tables a nightmare of cruft and tech debt – and rich text editors potentially have to implement and support the entire resulting mess."}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["valign-middle","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkQ7hWo","dataCeTag":"grid","dataAnimM":"false","dataAnim":"true","dataAnimName":"preset-slideInRight","dataAnimTrigger":"scroll","dataAnimDuration":"1","dataAnimDelay":"0","dataAnimScrollStart":"10","dataAnimScrollFinish":"90"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid","stk-theme_44178__mb_0"],"dataStkCss":"stkea3wZ","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataStkCss":"stkKTrXf","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"FURTHER INSIGHTS"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset"],"dataStkCss":"stklrTMY","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://www.tiny.cloud/technical-debt-whitepaper","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Download and read Technical Debt in Rich Text Editors White Paper →"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h3","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_medium_header","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Rich text editor tech debt example: RTE table complexities"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Table support is one of the most complicated pieces of the TinyMCE codebase. It spans several libraries and modules, including:"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"ul","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"list"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The "},{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Advanced Tables premium plugin"}]},{"type":"text","value":" repository, which implements advanced features like sorting"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/tinymce/src/plugins/table","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The "},{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Tables plugin"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":" module, which implements basic features like styling and adding rows and columns"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/snooker","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The "},{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Snooker"}]},{"type":"text","value":" module"}]},{"type":"text","value":", which handles manipulating table HTML for the plugin features"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/darwin","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The "},{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Darwin"}]},{"type":"text","value":" module"}]},{"type":"text","value":", which handles selection in tables"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/tinymce/src/models/dom/main/ts/table","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The "},{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"DOM Table Model"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":", which adds basic table support to the TinyMCE core editor"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Several more libraries and modules which are shared with other parts of TinyMCE core editor"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":" "}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_15","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"A lot of the complexity in TinyMCE’s table code is caused by having to absorb and handle the environmental tech debt inherent in the HTML specification for tables, and the way the various browsers implement it. Why bother to do that? Because otherwise bad things happen."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Put simply, unless you ensure the table HTML can be absorbed, your whole rich text editor breaks when a user copy-pastes content from anywhere, into the table."}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"However, to handle the HTML specifications, there’s only two alternatives: add explicit support for it, or do the absolute minimum to prevent the editor breaking… and assign any further support to your tech debt pile."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"But remember… for every feature you do support for the HTML specifications, your code complexity grows, again making the code more prone to accruing tech debt. It’s almost a no-win situation for rich text editors."}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Let’s look at two examples of technical debt in TinyMCE’s table code."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_15","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h4","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_header","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Small table changes = big table problems"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The modularisation of TinyMCE’s table code usually makes development easier by isolating code for specific functionality into specific places. However, it doesn’t completely remove the risk of changes in one library, causing ripples across the entire dependency tree."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"For example, a bug fix in the Snooker module might require changes to every other library. While a new feature in the Advanced Tables premium plugin might require cascading changes all the way down to the DOM Table Model."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"This makes it easy to accrue unintentional tech debt, if you miss seeing the side-effect of a change made. And, if a fix or feature snowballs because of the ripple effect, you may well have to choose between technical debt or meeting your launch deadline."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The only real way to mitigate these issues is tapping into the deep domain knowledge of rich text editor specialists, like TinyMCE, and accessing their inhouse developer expertise."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["valign-middle","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkyGcm3","dataCeTag":"grid","dataAnimM":"false","dataAnim":"true","dataAnimName":"preset-slideInRight","dataAnimTrigger":"scroll","dataAnimDuration":"1","dataAnimDelay":"0","dataAnimScrollStart":"10","dataAnimScrollFinish":"90"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkJF7V7","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataStkCss":"stkXuPVn","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"read MORE"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataStkCss":"stkncsJ7","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"More insights on the complexities of RTEs"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__mb_05"],"dataStkCss":"stkgDC_q","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/reduce-technical-debt/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Reduce technical debt with the right rich text editor"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataStkCss":"stkInzC1","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Managing technical debt is difficult in rich text editors"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h4","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_header","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"img","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3670816","stk-icon"],"src":"https://ceditor.setka.io/clients/D3SuW9_Vtk6NhYeFXfduUy55A4Dromkt/css/assets/44178/img/arrow-2021102714091113.svg","alt":""},"children":[]},{"type":"text","value":" Big table codebase = big table mess"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Complex code tends to breed cruft, code rot, and tech debt, and TinyMCE’s table code isn’t immune. Bug fixes are fine, but occasionally, implementing new features can hit roadblocks. And sometimes, all the future-proofing and good design you’ve done can’t save you from needing to just rewrite the code."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"For example, Advanced Tables (premium) was originally designed to only enable table sorting. It was well-designed, but a bit rushed and very focused. This caused issues when adding new features, due to how different the new features were, from sorting. In the end, it was more efficient to replace large amounts of the original code than to try to fit the new features into the old code."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_empty"],"dataColWidth":"1","dataStkCss":"","dataStkCssM":"","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["ce-element--empty","stk-element_no-text","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"span","properties":{"style":"font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The 3-year Aggregate Decay in an Advanced Tables plugin Individual commits in a repo, by yearly cohorts, across 3 years"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"If HTML tables weren’t so complicated, or browsers could support only the newest table features without breaking half the internet, this likely wouldn’t have been necessary. But that’s not possible, and it’s not unique to rich text editor’s table features and plugins."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"It applies to many aspects of rich text editors and why their code half-life is so short."}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"You may be tempted to think that tables are fairly low risk, if you decide to relegate any improvements to your ever growing list of technical debt. But other aspects of rich text editors are much more dangerous. They need attention. Now."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkzFN5f","dataCeTag":"grid","dataAnimM":"false","dataAnim":"true","dataAnimName":"preset-slideInRight","dataAnimTrigger":"scroll","dataAnimDuration":"1","dataAnimDelay":"0","dataAnimScrollStart":"10","dataAnimScrollFinish":"90"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkf4tW5","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataStkCss":"stk-qD2s","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"read MORE"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataStkCss":"stkOf_hd","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Is your code’s half-life this short?"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__mb_05"],"dataStkCss":"stk9dunH","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/rte-code-half-life/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Is your code half-life shorter than your engineering career"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"12","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Tech debt example 3"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h2","properties":{"id":"stk-5","className":["stk-theme_44178__style_large_header","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Rich text editor security attacks and exposure"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Privacy and security are always a key concern when handling user input. In a plain text form, the ways to mitigate the usual risks are well known and documented. However, rich text editors are much rarer, and much more complicated."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Security attacks can target the editor itself, the application it’s embedded in, the environment in which it’s running, or the server where the editor content is eventually saved. "}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"XSS attacks, DOM clobbering, JavaScript prototype pollution and structural damage to the HTML are all attack types you have to mitigate. Every rich text editor feature you add, has to be checked for privacy violations. And on top of all that, there are security and privacy standards that need to be met, such as SOC2."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkHbTMj","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397","stk-theme_44178__mb_05"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"What is SOC2?"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Paraphrasing "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://secureframe.com/hub/soc-2/what-is-soc-2","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Secureframe, a SOC2 audit looks at how"}]},{"type":"text","value":" "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://secureframe.com/hub/soc-2/what-is-soc-2","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"a company handles user data"}]},{"type":"text","value":" with regards to its security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Many big software companies, such as "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://cloud.google.com/security/compliance/soc-2","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Google"}]},{"type":"text","value":" and "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://www.atlassian.com/trust/compliance/resources/soc2","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Atlassian"}]},{"type":"text","value":", as well as open source maintainers like "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://blog.tidelift.com/tidelift-completes-soc-2-type-2-examination","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Tidelift"}]},{"type":"text","value":", publicize their SOC2 attainment and results."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"There’s a lot to manage, with rich text editor security:"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"ul","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"list"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Defending against attack vectors"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Protecting your users’ privacy"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"li","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-list-item"],"dataCeTag":"list-item"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Meeting the relevant standards."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"All that takes time and domain expertise in rich text editors. And it isn’t a one-off problem. New vulnerabilities are constantly being found. New attacks are constantly being reported. Privacy standards are constantly changing. It doesn't ever end."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_15","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"For rich text editors, it’s never-ending work, and relegating tasks to the tech debt ‘fix later’ list can be dangerous, especially when it comes to security issues. Sometimes though, the really hard issues just "},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"have"}]},{"type":"text","value":" to be fixed."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"body2":{"body2":"<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h3 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_medium_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editor tech debt example: DOM Parsing update in TinyMCE 6.0</h3>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">HTML is a very flexible markup language, and that means it has hundreds if not thousands of security vulnerabilities. Both CSS and JavaScript also have their own plethora of issues.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">A HTML-based rich text editor has to handle all these vulnerabilities.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The TinyMCE rich text editor does this by parsing and sanitizing every piece of content added to the editor &ndash; whether it comes from code, the clipboard, or a user typing something. Doing this without affecting the performance of the editor (or affecting other editor features) is a considerable <em class=\"stk-reset\">mission</em>.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">That&rsquo;s why TinyMCE recently switched its in-house DOM parser and sanitizer, for a third-party tool.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkVMzO6\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397 stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">What is the OWASP Foundation?</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://owasp.org/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The Open Web Application Security Project&reg; (OWASP)</a> is a nonprofit foundation and community that works to improve the security of software.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">It conducts community-led open-source software projects, educational and training conferences, and produces freely-available articles, methodologies, documentation, tools, and technologies in the field of web application security.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Build our own or buy it?</h4>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">TinyMCE is an editor with heritage. For many years, handling the security of its content was something our engineers solely handled, because there were no third-party libraries available to use. Therefore, we reacted quickly when a new exploit was discovered, and easily customized the parsing and sanitizing to our needs.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">However, it also required a lot of work.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Recent years have seen an increase in the number and complexity of known vulnerabilities. The domain knowledge required to ensure the security of a rich text editor has grown in relation to that, and the amount of code needed to mitigate all the potential attacks has exploded.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stki8_oo\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkRsmPy\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkt9lPU\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stkrsSKO\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://owasp.org/www-project-top-ten/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The OWASP Top Ten</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkxEV8a\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://cheatsheetseries.owasp.org/cheatsheets/HTML5_Security_Cheat_Sheet.html\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">HTML5 Security Cheat Sheet</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stk6Ja_V\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://cheatsheetseries.owasp.org/cheatsheets/XSS_Filter_Evasion_Cheat_Sheet.html\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">XSS Filter Cheat Sheet</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">At the same time, industry standards have appeared, and seemingly stabilized. Whole new industries have grown up around software security and privacy, while security tools have improved by leaps and bounds.</p>\n<table class=\"stk-table--bordered_h stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__var_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-table\" data-responsive-type=\"cards\" data-ce-tag=\"table\"><colgroup> <col class=\"stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset\" data-stk-id=\"347\" /> <col class=\"stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset\" data-stk-id=\"348\" /> <col class=\"stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset\" data-stk-id=\"349\" /> </colgroup>\n<thead class=\"stk-reset\">\n<tr class=\"stk-reset stk-table-row\">\n<th class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"th\">&nbsp;</th>\n<th class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"th\">In-house DOM Parser</th>\n<th class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"th\">Third-party DOM Parser</th>\n</tr>\n</thead>\n<tbody class=\"stk-reset\">\n<tr class=\"stk-reset stk-table-row\">\n<td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Pros</strong></td>\n<td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\" data-cell-header=\"In-house DOM Parser\">Can be easily customized, and quickly patched when new exploits are found.</td>\n<td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\" data-cell-header=\"Third-party DOM Parser\">Maintenance overhead is passed to third-party developers.</td>\n</tr>\n<tr class=\"stk-reset stk-table-row\">\n<td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Cons</strong></td>\n<td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\" data-cell-header=\"In-house DOM Parser\">Maintenance costs grow as the age and complexity of the code increases.</td>\n<td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\" data-cell-header=\"Third-party DOM Parser\">Reliance on a third-party to be responsive and maintain a high quality.</td>\n</tr>\n</tbody>\n</table>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Switching to a third-party security solution was a difficult decision. As was finding the right tool and implementing the switch. However, it was necessary.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">TinyMCE&rsquo;s DOM parser was a big, complex piece of code that only a few developers understood, and working on it was fraught with complications and delays. Plus, the volume of maintenance and tech debt wasn&rsquo;t sustainable, on top of every other moving part in the rich text editor and 50+ plugins.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">However, not fixing security issues wasn&rsquo;t an option. The risks associated with accumulating security tech debt are much too high.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">In the end, switching to an industry-standard, third-party security solution that&rsquo;s maintained by experts, was a win-win for everyone: Tiny spends more time on rich text editing &ndash; our area of expertise &ndash; and our users receive the high security standards they expect, and need.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-stk-css=\"stkD4Y_X\" data-anim-zoom=\"100\" data-anim-shift=\"40\" data-anim-rotation=\"0\" data-anim-opacity=\"100\" data-anim-direction=\"right\" data-anim-duration=\"0.8\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-sticky-direction=\"top\" data-anim-sticky-offset=\"20\" data-anim-name=\"aDQKFS\" data-anim=\"true\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stkoxIzS\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkGtSQ5\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">FURTHER INSIGHTS</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937\" data-stk-css=\"stk-5MBp\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/buy-vs-build-whitepaper/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Download and read Build vs Buy White Paper &rarr;</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><img class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3670816 stk-icon\" src=\"https://ceditor.setka.io/clients/D3SuW9_Vtk6NhYeFXfduUy55A4Dromkt/css/assets/44178/img/arrow-2021102714091113.svg\" alt=\"\" />&nbsp;Protecting user privacy</h4>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The flip side of rich text editor security is privacy. While rich text editors mostly only deal with user input within the user&rsquo;s browser, any data that&rsquo;s collected from the editor or transferred elsewhere must follow privacy best practices. Otherwise, you&rsquo;re liable for data breaches &ndash; whether that&rsquo;s during data transfer or while it&rsquo;s stored in your servers.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Similar to security, privacy is another aspect of rich text editor development, where taking on tech debt can be very risky.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Data management must be implemented right the first time &ndash; and it needs to be regularly maintained. Especially when new laws or standards are introduced, such as <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://gdpr-info.eu/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Europe&rsquo;s GDPR</a>.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For TinyMCE, one of our biggest privacy challenges came with the implementation of our Real-time Collaboration (RTC) premium plugin. By nature, RTC functionality requires user data to be transmitted over the internet, so that users can <em class=\"stk-reset\">see</em> what others are doing. Doing that securely, without overly impacting the plugin&rsquo;s functionality was complex work, and required us to implement new features such as <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/docs/tinymce/6/how-the-rtc-plugin-encrypts-content/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">content encryption during transmission</a>.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">This was a case where technical debt needed to be carefully managed, to ensure its negative consequences didn&rsquo;t exceed its advantages.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">In the case of RTC, if we hadn&rsquo;t put the work in to protect our users' privacy and data, and had instead relegated such measures to technical debt work to be scheduled, it would have resulted in unacceptable risks to users&rsquo; security and privacy.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Our goal has never been to reach zero tech debt. Because sometimes, some debt has been a good thing for our growth. Why&rsquo;s that?</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Ideally, a &lsquo;Goldilocks level of tech debt&rsquo; is what you want to carry &ndash; not too much, not too little. Your tech debt management plan needs to balance growth aspirations and housekeeping duties, to ensure you&rsquo;re continuing to deliver value at high speed, without sacrificing quality, security or privacy.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">But there is another way to minimize your tech debt.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkgAJjW\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkVg3as\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkhGEMT\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Reading resources</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stkf5Dfv\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.atlassian.com/platform/marketplace/data-privacy-guidelines/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Atlassian&rsquo;s data privacy guidelines</a> are a great rundown of privacy best practices.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stk9LMRn\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://web.dev/learn/forms/security-privacy/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">web.dev&rsquo;s lesson on forms and privacy</a> has several useful examples.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkWXTqY\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Firewall Times maintains <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://firewalltimes.com/recent-data-breaches/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">a terrifying timeline of recent data breaches</a>.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h2 id=\"stk-6\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Easiest way to avoid technical debt, is buying RTE components</h2>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Cost drives much of today&rsquo;s technology.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The typical cost of managing the technical debt generated by a rich text editor &ndash; and its advanced features &ndash; isn&rsquo;t small. As you can see, even discussing the possibility of adding functionality or fixing a bug and then deciding not to do it, takes time.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">And the more rework you have to do, the higher the price tag and opportunities lost.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">By curating a repository of vetted, pre-approved components and release versions (open source, purchased and subscribed), you&rsquo;re minimizing security exposures, ongoing maintenance and technical debt accumulation. The components can be safely used and reused within your tech stack, across the enterprise.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">That allows your development work to quickly move, more safely, and avoids last-minute blockers during a development cycle.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Assembling pre-approved specialist components lets you safely walk the tightrope between technical debt and innovation. And it maximizes your opportunity cost.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-layout__overhangs_both stk-theme_44178__mb_0 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkl-1FZ\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_ver_2 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"align-center stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Download the white paper</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628585803915 align-center stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Opportunity Cost of Technical Debt: Minimize Your Rich Text Editor Development</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-col-width=\"2\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">&nbsp;</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<figure class=\"stk-reset stk-embed_rendered\" data-ce-tag=\"embed\"><code class=\"stk-code\"><iframe style=\"border: 0px;\" src=\"https://www2.ephox.com/l/2202/2022-09-29/d9d458\" width=\"100%\" height=\"500\" frameborder=\"0\" data-mce-fragment=\"1\"></iframe></code></figure>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-layout__overhangs_both stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkEIBtG\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last stk-theme_44178__pad_ver_3\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1-m\" data-col-width=\"6\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_0 stk-theme_44178__mb_0 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Millie Macdonald</h4>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Product Manager at Halo Connect</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_0 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Millie is a Product Manager at Halo Connect who dabbles in writing. Previously, she worked at Tiny as a Product Owner, dev, and QA engineer. She loves learning above all else, whether it's about people, tech, or leadership.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>","childMarkdownRemark":{"html":"<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h3 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_medium_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editor tech debt example: DOM Parsing update in TinyMCE 6.0</h3>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">HTML is a very flexible markup language, and that means it has hundreds if not thousands of security vulnerabilities. Both CSS and JavaScript also have their own plethora of issues.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">A HTML-based rich text editor has to handle all these vulnerabilities.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The TinyMCE rich text editor does this by parsing and sanitizing every piece of content added to the editor &ndash; whether it comes from code, the clipboard, or a user typing something. Doing this without affecting the performance of the editor (or affecting other editor features) is a considerable <em class=\"stk-reset\">mission</em>.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">That&rsquo;s why TinyMCE recently switched its in-house DOM parser and sanitizer, for a third-party tool.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkVMzO6\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397 stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">What is the OWASP Foundation?</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://owasp.org/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The Open Web Application Security Project&reg; (OWASP)</a> is a nonprofit foundation and community that works to improve the security of software.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">It conducts community-led open-source software projects, educational and training conferences, and produces freely-available articles, methodologies, documentation, tools, and technologies in the field of web application security.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Build our own or buy it?</h4>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">TinyMCE is an editor with heritage. For many years, handling the security of its content was something our engineers solely handled, because there were no third-party libraries available to use. Therefore, we reacted quickly when a new exploit was discovered, and easily customized the parsing and sanitizing to our needs.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">However, it also required a lot of work.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Recent years have seen an increase in the number and complexity of known vulnerabilities. The domain knowledge required to ensure the security of a rich text editor has grown in relation to that, and the amount of code needed to mitigate all the potential attacks has exploded.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stki8_oo\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkRsmPy\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkt9lPU\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stkrsSKO\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://owasp.org/www-project-top-ten/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The OWASP Top Ten</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkxEV8a\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://cheatsheetseries.owasp.org/cheatsheets/HTML5_Security_Cheat_Sheet.html\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">HTML5 Security Cheat Sheet</a></p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stk6Ja_V\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://cheatsheetseries.owasp.org/cheatsheets/XSS_Filter_Evasion_Cheat_Sheet.html\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">XSS Filter Cheat Sheet</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">At the same time, industry standards have appeared, and seemingly stabilized. Whole new industries have grown up around software security and privacy, while security tools have improved by leaps and bounds.</p>\n<table class=\"stk-table--bordered_h stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__var_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-table\" data-responsive-type=\"cards\" data-ce-tag=\"table\"><colgroup> <col class=\"stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset\" data-stk-id=\"347\" /> <col class=\"stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset\" data-stk-id=\"348\" /> <col class=\"stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset\" data-stk-id=\"349\" /> </colgroup>\n<thead class=\"stk-reset\">\n<tr class=\"stk-reset stk-table-row\">\n<th class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"th\">&nbsp;</th>\n<th class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"th\">In-house DOM Parser</th>\n<th class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"th\">Third-party DOM Parser</th>\n</tr>\n</thead>\n<tbody class=\"stk-reset\">\n<tr class=\"stk-reset stk-table-row\">\n<td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Pros</strong></td>\n<td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\" data-cell-header=\"In-house DOM Parser\">Can be easily customized, and quickly patched when new exploits are found.</td>\n<td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\" data-cell-header=\"Third-party DOM Parser\">Maintenance overhead is passed to third-party developers.</td>\n</tr>\n<tr class=\"stk-reset stk-table-row\">\n<td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Cons</strong></td>\n<td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\" data-cell-header=\"In-house DOM Parser\">Maintenance costs grow as the age and complexity of the code increases.</td>\n<td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\" data-cell-header=\"Third-party DOM Parser\">Reliance on a third-party to be responsive and maintain a high quality.</td>\n</tr>\n</tbody>\n</table>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Switching to a third-party security solution was a difficult decision. As was finding the right tool and implementing the switch. However, it was necessary.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">TinyMCE&rsquo;s DOM parser was a big, complex piece of code that only a few developers understood, and working on it was fraught with complications and delays. Plus, the volume of maintenance and tech debt wasn&rsquo;t sustainable, on top of every other moving part in the rich text editor and 50+ plugins.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">However, not fixing security issues wasn&rsquo;t an option. The risks associated with accumulating security tech debt are much too high.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">In the end, switching to an industry-standard, third-party security solution that&rsquo;s maintained by experts, was a win-win for everyone: Tiny spends more time on rich text editing &ndash; our area of expertise &ndash; and our users receive the high security standards they expect, and need.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-stk-css=\"stkD4Y_X\" data-anim-zoom=\"100\" data-anim-shift=\"40\" data-anim-rotation=\"0\" data-anim-opacity=\"100\" data-anim-direction=\"right\" data-anim-duration=\"0.8\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-sticky-direction=\"top\" data-anim-sticky-offset=\"20\" data-anim-name=\"aDQKFS\" data-anim=\"true\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stkoxIzS\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkGtSQ5\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">FURTHER INSIGHTS</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937\" data-stk-css=\"stk-5MBp\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/buy-vs-build-whitepaper/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Download and read Build vs Buy White Paper &rarr;</a></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><img class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3670816 stk-icon\" src=\"https://ceditor.setka.io/clients/D3SuW9_Vtk6NhYeFXfduUy55A4Dromkt/css/assets/44178/img/arrow-2021102714091113.svg\" alt=\"\" />&nbsp;Protecting user privacy</h4>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The flip side of rich text editor security is privacy. While rich text editors mostly only deal with user input within the user&rsquo;s browser, any data that&rsquo;s collected from the editor or transferred elsewhere must follow privacy best practices. Otherwise, you&rsquo;re liable for data breaches &ndash; whether that&rsquo;s during data transfer or while it&rsquo;s stored in your servers.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Similar to security, privacy is another aspect of rich text editor development, where taking on tech debt can be very risky.</strong></p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Data management must be implemented right the first time &ndash; and it needs to be regularly maintained. Especially when new laws or standards are introduced, such as <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://gdpr-info.eu/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Europe&rsquo;s GDPR</a>.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For TinyMCE, one of our biggest privacy challenges came with the implementation of our Real-time Collaboration (RTC) premium plugin. By nature, RTC functionality requires user data to be transmitted over the internet, so that users can <em class=\"stk-reset\">see</em> what others are doing. Doing that securely, without overly impacting the plugin&rsquo;s functionality was complex work, and required us to implement new features such as <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/docs/tinymce/6/how-the-rtc-plugin-encrypts-content/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">content encryption during transmission</a>.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">This was a case where technical debt needed to be carefully managed, to ensure its negative consequences didn&rsquo;t exceed its advantages.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">In the case of RTC, if we hadn&rsquo;t put the work in to protect our users' privacy and data, and had instead relegated such measures to technical debt work to be scheduled, it would have resulted in unacceptable risks to users&rsquo; security and privacy.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Our goal has never been to reach zero tech debt. Because sometimes, some debt has been a good thing for our growth. Why&rsquo;s that?</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Ideally, a &lsquo;Goldilocks level of tech debt&rsquo; is what you want to carry &ndash; not too much, not too little. Your tech debt management plan needs to balance growth aspirations and housekeeping duties, to ensure you&rsquo;re continuing to deliver value at high speed, without sacrificing quality, security or privacy.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">But there is another way to minimize your tech debt.</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkgAJjW\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkVg3as\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"3\" data-stk-css=\"stkhGEMT\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Reading resources</strong></p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stkf5Dfv\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.atlassian.com/platform/marketplace/data-privacy-guidelines/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Atlassian&rsquo;s data privacy guidelines</a> are a great rundown of privacy best practices.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stk9LMRn\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://web.dev/learn/forms/security-privacy/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">web.dev&rsquo;s lesson on forms and privacy</a> has several useful examples.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkWXTqY\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Firewall Times maintains <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://firewalltimes.com/recent-data-breaches/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">a terrifying timeline of recent data breaches</a>.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h2 id=\"stk-6\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Easiest way to avoid technical debt, is buying RTE components</h2>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Cost drives much of today&rsquo;s technology.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The typical cost of managing the technical debt generated by a rich text editor &ndash; and its advanced features &ndash; isn&rsquo;t small. As you can see, even discussing the possibility of adding functionality or fixing a bug and then deciding not to do it, takes time.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">And the more rework you have to do, the higher the price tag and opportunities lost.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">By curating a repository of vetted, pre-approved components and release versions (open source, purchased and subscribed), you&rsquo;re minimizing security exposures, ongoing maintenance and technical debt accumulation. The components can be safely used and reused within your tech stack, across the enterprise.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">That allows your development work to quickly move, more safely, and avoids last-minute blockers during a development cycle.</p>\n<p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Assembling pre-approved specialist components lets you safely walk the tightrope between technical debt and innovation. And it maximizes your opportunity cost.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-layout__overhangs_both stk-theme_44178__mb_0 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkl-1FZ\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_ver_2 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"align-center stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Download the white paper</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628585803915 align-center stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Opportunity Cost of Technical Debt: Minimize Your Rich Text Editor Development</p>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-col-width=\"2\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">&nbsp;</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-col-width=\"8\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<figure class=\"stk-reset stk-embed_rendered\" data-ce-tag=\"embed\"><code class=\"stk-code\"><iframe style=\"border: 0px;\" src=\"https://www2.ephox.com/l/2202/2022-09-29/d9d458\" width=\"100%\" height=\"500\" frameborder=\"0\" data-mce-fragment=\"1\"></iframe></code></figure>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"stk-layout__overhangs_both stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkEIBtG\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last stk-theme_44178__pad_ver_3\" data-col-width=\"12\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\">\n<div class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1-m\" data-col-width=\"6\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\">\n<h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_0 stk-theme_44178__mb_0 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Millie Macdonald</h4>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Product Manager at Halo Connect</p>\n<p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_0 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Millie is a Product Manager at Halo Connect who dabbles in writing. Previously, she worked at Tiny as a Product Owner, dev, and QA engineer. She loves learning above all else, whether it's about people, tech, or leadership.</p>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>\n</div>","htmlAst":{"type":"root","children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"12","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h3","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_medium_header","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Rich text editor tech debt example: DOM Parsing update in TinyMCE 6.0"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"HTML is a very flexible markup language, and that means it has hundreds if not thousands of security vulnerabilities. Both CSS and JavaScript also have their own plethora of issues."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"A HTML-based rich text editor has to handle all these vulnerabilities."}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The TinyMCE rich text editor does this by parsing and sanitizing every piece of content added to the editor – whether it comes from code, the clipboard, or a user typing something. Doing this without affecting the performance of the editor (or affecting other editor features) is a considerable "},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"mission"}]},{"type":"text","value":"."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"That’s why TinyMCE recently switched its in-house DOM parser and sanitizer, for a third-party tool."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkVMzO6","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397","stk-theme_44178__mb_05"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"What is the OWASP Foundation?"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://owasp.org/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The Open Web Application Security Project® (OWASP)"}]},{"type":"text","value":" is a nonprofit foundation and community that works to improve the security of software."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"It conducts community-led open-source software projects, educational and training conferences, and produces freely-available articles, methodologies, documentation, tools, and technologies in the field of web application security."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h4","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_header","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Build our own or buy it?"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"TinyMCE is an editor with heritage. For many years, handling the security of its content was something our engineers solely handled, because there were no third-party libraries available to use. Therefore, we reacted quickly when a new exploit was discovered, and easily customized the parsing and sanitizing to our needs."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"However, it also required a lot of work."}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Recent years have seen an increase in the number and complexity of known vulnerabilities. The domain knowledge required to ensure the security of a rich text editor has grown in relation to that, and the amount of code needed to mitigate all the potential attacks has exploded."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["valign-middle","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stki8_oo","dataCeTag":"grid","dataAnimM":"false","dataAnim":"true","dataAnimName":"preset-slideInRight","dataAnimTrigger":"scroll","dataAnimDuration":"1","dataAnimDelay":"0","dataAnimScrollStart":"10","dataAnimScrollFinish":"90"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkRsmPy","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataStkCss":"stkt9lPU","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"read MORE"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__mb_05"],"dataStkCss":"stkrsSKO","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://owasp.org/www-project-top-ten/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The OWASP Top Ten"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataStkCss":"stkxEV8a","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://cheatsheetseries.owasp.org/cheatsheets/HTML5_Security_Cheat_Sheet.html","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"HTML5 Security Cheat Sheet"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataStkCss":"stk6Ja_V","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://cheatsheetseries.owasp.org/cheatsheets/XSS_Filter_Evasion_Cheat_Sheet.html","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"XSS Filter Cheat Sheet"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_15","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"At the same time, industry standards have appeared, and seemingly stabilized. Whole new industries have grown up around software security and privacy, while security tools have improved by leaps and bounds."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"table","properties":{"className":["stk-table--bordered_h","stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__var_44178_custom_color_3","stk-reset","stk-table"],"dataResponsiveType":"cards","dataCeTag":"table"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"colgroup","properties":{},"children":[{"type":"text","value":" "},{"type":"element","tagName":"col","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-reset","stk-reset","stk-reset","stk-reset","stk-reset"],"dataStkId":"347"},"children":[]},{"type":"text","value":" "},{"type":"element","tagName":"col","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-reset","stk-reset","stk-reset","stk-reset","stk-reset"],"dataStkId":"348"},"children":[]},{"type":"text","value":" "},{"type":"element","tagName":"col","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-reset","stk-reset","stk-reset","stk-reset","stk-reset"],"dataStkId":"349"},"children":[]},{"type":"text","value":" "}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"thead","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"tr","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-table-row"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"th","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","ce-element--empty","stk-element_no-text","stk-reset","stk-table-cell"],"dataCeTag":"th"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":" "}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"th","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset","stk-table-cell"],"dataCeTag":"th"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"In-house DOM Parser"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"th","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset","stk-table-cell"],"dataCeTag":"th"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Third-party DOM Parser"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"tbody","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"tr","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-table-row"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"td","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset","stk-table-cell"],"dataCeTag":"td"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Pros"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"td","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset","stk-table-cell"],"dataCeTag":"td","dataCellHeader":"In-house DOM Parser"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Can be easily customized, and quickly patched when new exploits are found."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"td","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset","stk-table-cell"],"dataCeTag":"td","dataCellHeader":"Third-party DOM Parser"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Maintenance overhead is passed to third-party developers."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"tr","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-table-row"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"td","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset","stk-table-cell"],"dataCeTag":"td"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Cons"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"td","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset","stk-table-cell"],"dataCeTag":"td","dataCellHeader":"In-house DOM Parser"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Maintenance costs grow as the age and complexity of the code increases."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"td","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-reset","stk-table-cell"],"dataCeTag":"td","dataCellHeader":"Third-party DOM Parser"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Reliance on a third-party to be responsive and maintain a high quality."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Switching to a third-party security solution was a difficult decision. As was finding the right tool and implementing the switch. However, it was necessary."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"TinyMCE’s DOM parser was a big, complex piece of code that only a few developers understood, and working on it was fraught with complications and delays. Plus, the volume of maintenance and tech debt wasn’t sustainable, on top of every other moving part in the rich text editor and 50+ plugins."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"However, not fixing security issues wasn’t an option. The risks associated with accumulating security tech debt are much too high."}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"In the end, switching to an industry-standard, third-party security solution that’s maintained by experts, was a win-win for everyone: Tiny spends more time on rich text editing – our area of expertise – and our users receive the high security standards they expect, and need."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["valign-middle","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid","dataAnimM":"false","dataStkCss":"stkD4Y_X","dataAnimZoom":"100","dataAnimShift":"40","dataAnimRotation":"0","dataAnimOpacity":"100","dataAnimDirection":"right","dataAnimDuration":"0.8","dataAnimDelay":"0","dataAnimScrollStart":"10","dataAnimScrollFinish":"90","dataAnimTrigger":"scroll","dataAnimStickyDirection":"top","dataAnimStickyOffset":"20","dataAnimName":"aDQKFS","dataAnim":"true"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid","stk-theme_44178__mb_05"],"dataStkCss":"stkoxIzS","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataStkCss":"stkGtSQ5","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"FURTHER INSIGHTS"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937"],"dataStkCss":"stk-5MBp","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://www.tiny.cloud/buy-vs-build-whitepaper/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Download and read Build vs Buy White Paper →"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h4","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_header","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"img","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3670816","stk-icon"],"src":"https://ceditor.setka.io/clients/D3SuW9_Vtk6NhYeFXfduUy55A4Dromkt/css/assets/44178/img/arrow-2021102714091113.svg","alt":""},"children":[]},{"type":"text","value":" Protecting user privacy"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The flip side of rich text editor security is privacy. While rich text editors mostly only deal with user input within the user’s browser, any data that’s collected from the editor or transferred elsewhere must follow privacy best practices. Otherwise, you’re liable for data breaches – whether that’s during data transfer or while it’s stored in your servers."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Similar to security, privacy is another aspect of rich text editor development, where taking on tech debt can be very risky."}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Data management must be implemented right the first time – and it needs to be regularly maintained. Especially when new laws or standards are introduced, such as "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://gdpr-info.eu/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Europe’s GDPR"}]},{"type":"text","value":"."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"For TinyMCE, one of our biggest privacy challenges came with the implementation of our Real-time Collaboration (RTC) premium plugin. By nature, RTC functionality requires user data to be transmitted over the internet, so that users can "},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"see"}]},{"type":"text","value":" what others are doing. Doing that securely, without overly impacting the plugin’s functionality was complex work, and required us to implement new features such as "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://www.tiny.cloud/docs/tinymce/6/how-the-rtc-plugin-encrypts-content/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"content encryption during transmission"}]},{"type":"text","value":"."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"This was a case where technical debt needed to be carefully managed, to ensure its negative consequences didn’t exceed its advantages."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"In the case of RTC, if we hadn’t put the work in to protect our users' privacy and data, and had instead relegated such measures to technical debt work to be scheduled, it would have resulted in unacceptable risks to users’ security and privacy."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Our goal has never been to reach zero tech debt. Because sometimes, some debt has been a good thing for our growth. Why’s that?"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Ideally, a ‘Goldilocks level of tech debt’ is what you want to carry – not too much, not too little. Your tech debt management plan needs to balance growth aspirations and housekeeping duties, to ensure you’re continuing to deliver value at high speed, without sacrificing quality, security or privacy."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"But there is another way to minimize your tech debt."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["valign-middle","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkgAJjW","dataCeTag":"grid","dataAnimM":"false","dataAnim":"true","dataAnimName":"preset-slideInRight","dataAnimTrigger":"scroll","dataAnimDuration":"1","dataAnimDelay":"0","dataAnimScrollStart":"10","dataAnimScrollFinish":"90"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkVg3as","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"3","dataStkCss":"stkhGEMT","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"strong","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Reading resources"}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__mb_05"],"dataStkCss":"stkf5Dfv","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://developer.atlassian.com/platform/marketplace/data-privacy-guidelines/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Atlassian’s data privacy guidelines"}]},{"type":"text","value":" are a great rundown of privacy best practices."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataStkCss":"stk9LMRn","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://web.dev/learn/forms/security-privacy/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"web.dev’s lesson on forms and privacy"}]},{"type":"text","value":" has several useful examples."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-theme_44178__mb_05","stk-reset"],"dataStkCss":"stkWXTqY","dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Firewall Times maintains "},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"href":"https://firewalltimes.com/recent-data-breaches/","target":"_blank","rel":["noopener"]},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"a terrifying timeline of recent data breaches"}]},{"type":"text","value":"."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__mb_2","stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h2","properties":{"id":"stk-6","className":["stk-theme_44178__style_large_header","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Easiest way to avoid technical debt, is buying RTE components"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Cost drives much of today’s technology."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"The typical cost of managing the technical debt generated by a rich text editor – and its advanced features – isn’t small. As you can see, even discussing the possibility of adding functionality or fixing a bug and then deciding not to do it, takes time."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"And the more rework you have to do, the higher the price tag and opportunities lost."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"By curating a repository of vetted, pre-approved components and release versions (open source, purchased and subscribed), you’re minimizing security exposures, ongoing maintenance and technical debt accumulation. The components can be safely used and reused within your tech stack, across the enterprise."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"That allows your development work to quickly move, more safely, and avoids last-minute blockers during a development cycle."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Assembling pre-approved specialist components lets you safely walk the tightrope between technical debt and innovation. And it maximizes your opportunity cost."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-layout__overhangs_both","stk-theme_44178__mb_0","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkl-1FZ","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__pad_ver_2","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"12","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["align-center","stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Download the white paper"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628585803915","align-center","stk-reset","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Opportunity Cost of Technical Debt: Minimize Your Rich Text Editor Development"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_empty"],"dataColWidth":"2","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["ce-element--empty","stk-element_no-text","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":" "}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last"],"dataColWidth":"8","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"figure","properties":{"className":["stk-reset","stk-embed_rendered"],"dataCeTag":"embed"},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"code","properties":{"className":["stk-code"]},"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"iframe","properties":{"style":"border: 0px;","src":"https://www2.ephox.com/l/2202/2022-09-29/d9d458","width":"100%","height":500,"frameBorder":"0","dataMceFragment":"1"},"children":[]}]}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-layout__overhangs_both","stk-grid"],"dataStkCss":"stkEIBtG","dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last","stk-theme_44178__pad_ver_3"],"dataColWidth":"12","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["stk-grid"],"dataCeTag":"grid"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"div","properties":{"className":["valign-middle","stk-grid-col","stk-grid-col_last","stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1-m"],"dataColWidth":"6","dataCeTag":"grid-col"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"h4","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_header","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_0","stk-theme_44178__mb_0","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Millie Macdonald"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Product Manager at Halo Connect"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","properties":{"className":["stk-theme_44178__style_small_text","stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_0","stk-reset"],"dataCeTag":"paragraph"},"children":[{"type":"text","value":"Millie is a Product Manager at Halo Connect who dabbles in writing. Previously, she worked at Tiny as a Product Owner, dev, and QA engineer. She loves learning above all else, whether it's about people, tech, or leadership."}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]},{"type":"text","value":"\n"}]}],"data":{"quirksMode":false}}}},"codepens":null,"heroImage":{"image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7767441860465116,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=2560&q=80&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=640&h=360&q=80&fit=scale 640w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=1280&h=720&q=80&fit=scale 1280w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=1528&h=860&q=80&fit=scale 1528w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=2560&q=80&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=640&h=360&q=80&fm=webp&fit=scale 640w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=1280&h=720&q=80&fm=webp&fit=scale 1280w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1z2X2gKj3AqHd0KdZtgxkN/e6c9c76f477affea75b1817a73f02f00/tech-debt-4-2022121313085824.png?w=1528&h=860&q=80&fm=webp&fit=scale 1528w","sizes":"(max-width: 2560px) 100vw, 2560px"}},"alt":"An exclamation mark as a warning, representing the dangers of technical debt","artistName":null,"artistUrl":null},"author":{"slug":"millie-macdonald","name":"Millie Macdonald","image":{"fluid":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1,"src":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=48&q=50&fit=scale","srcSet":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=12&h=12&q=50&fit=scale 12w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=24&h=24&q=50&fit=scale 24w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=48&h=48&q=50&fit=scale 48w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=72&h=72&q=50&fit=scale 72w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=96&h=96&q=50&fit=scale 96w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=144&h=144&q=50&fit=scale 144w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=400&h=400&q=50&fit=scale 400w","srcWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=48&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale","srcSetWebp":"//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=12&h=12&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 12w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=24&h=24&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 24w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=48&h=48&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 48w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=72&h=72&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 72w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=96&h=96&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 96w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=144&h=144&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 144w,\n//images.ctfassets.net/s600jj41gsex/1WjKPKyRtd0IepFyXQBiHt/46d51b0fc7ee0c7700a2d3a835d20735/seYCjfJw_400x400.jpg?w=400&h=400&q=50&fm=webp&fit=scale 400w","sizes":"(max-width: 48px) 100vw, 48px"}},"shortBio":{"shortBio":"Millie is a JS developer and leads the core editor team at Tiny. She specialises in crazy things like copy and paste, image handling, and tables, and occasionally gets to play with ReasonML. She's also an esports community manager and tournament organiser in her spare time."}},"metaTitle":{"metaTitle":"Dangerous examples of technical debt in rich text editors | TinyMCE"},"metaDescription":{"metaDescription":"In this post we talk about the examples of technical debt that our team has the most expertise in: cases of technical debt accrual in rich text editors and share how we approach these issues"},"setkaCss":["https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/setka/common_css_1634572086.css","https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/setka/T-MqHt4_cRRlImdGVfupaQ.css","https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/setka/UnEeJJ5vn9rZGngAji4oNg.css"],"setkaHtml":{"body_html":"<div class=\"stk-post stk-layout_12col_36009 stk-theme_44178\" data-stk=\"{&quot;images&quot;:[{&quot;id&quot;:232077,&quot;alt&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;caption&quot;:&quot;&quot;},{&quot;id&quot;:232078,&quot;alt&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;caption&quot;:&quot;&quot;},{&quot;id&quot;:232076,&quot;alt&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;caption&quot;:&quot;&quot;},{&quot;id&quot;:231512,&quot;alt&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;caption&quot;:&quot;&quot;},{&quot;id&quot;:231511,&quot;alt&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;caption&quot;:&quot;&quot;},{&quot;id&quot;:231508,&quot;alt&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;caption&quot;:&quot;&quot;},{&quot;id&quot;:231436,&quot;alt&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;caption&quot;:&quot;&quot;},{&quot;id&quot;:231435,&quot;alt&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;caption&quot;:&quot;&quot;},{&quot;id&quot;:231434,&quot;alt&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;caption&quot;:&quot;&quot;},{&quot;id&quot;:231432,&quot;alt&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;caption&quot;:&quot;&quot;}]}\" data-ui-id=\"post\" data-ce-tag=\"post\" data-reset-type=\"class\" data-layout-type=\"limited\" data-editor-version=\"3.2.5\"><div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_2\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"12\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"10\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p><p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\" data-gtm-vis-has-fired-10171822_255=\"1\">Developer insights</strong></p><h1 class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1 stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1635835947787\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Dangerous examples of technical debt in rich text editors</h1></div><div data-col-width=\"2\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Published {{setkaPost.lastUpdated}}<br></p></div><div data-col-width=\"9\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><img alt=\"\" class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3740221 stk-icon\" src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/ff75d5fb-c11f-4155-b153-3eb9441ed072/\">&nbsp;{{setkaPost.readTime}} </p></div></div><figure class=\"stk-reset stk-image-figure\" data-ce-tag=\"image-figure\"><div class=\"stk-mask\" data-ce-tag=\"mask\"><img src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/62e2cf36-6845-402f-b9cc-cc0da74222c9/\" data-image-id=\"231512\" data-image-name=\"tech debt 4.png\" class=\"stk-image stk-reset\" width=\"2130\" height=\"860\" loading=\"lazy\"/></div></figure></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_15\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"9\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517294418 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">In an ideal world, the technical debt in your project is intentional and controllable. But rich text editors are complex beasts that exist in an ever-changing environment – which means one of the biggest dangers to rich text editor development is environmental tech debt.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid stk-grid__layout_columns\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><figure class=\"stk-reset stk-image-figure\" data-ce-tag=\"image-figure\"><div class=\"stk-mask\" data-ce-tag=\"mask\"><img src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/f4f978a8-138d-4000-8d66-48ab76705afb/\" data-image-id=\"221201\" data-image-name=\"millie.png\" class=\"stk-image stk-reset\" width=\"942\" height=\"942\" loading=\"lazy\"/></div></figure></div><div data-col-width=\"2\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last valign-middle\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_0 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Millie Macdonald</p><p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Product Manager at Halo Connect</p></div></div></div></div><hr class=\"stk-theme_44178__separator_basic_divider stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-reset\"/><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Many modern software projects rely on numerous external dependencies – libraries, frameworks, and other tools that make development easier. Usually though, you have a degree of control over those dependencies.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editors aren’t so lucky.</p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editors aren’t standalone applications</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">A rich text editor by itself isn’t very useful – it has to be used within the context of another application. That means it has to be compatible with that application – or multiple applications, depending on how it’s used – and be able to adapt to outside changes.</p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The rich text editor environment is complex</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">A rich text editor needs to support numerous browser and operating system (OS) combinations. But there are dozens of combinations, and both browsers and OSes constantly change, which makes for a very complex environment.</p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editors are at the mercy of many standards and specifications</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Security. Privacy. Even just the HTML specification. Rich text editors have to support, work with, implement, and comply with a wide range of standards and specifications – all of which restrict some features and require others.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Staying on top of all these external factors isn’t simple.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">You have to know what to monitor, how to monitor it, and how to assess modification news for its impact on your rich text editor. It requires dedication, domain knowledge, and significant time investment. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Because if you don’t do that, you’re risking the accrual of significant environmental tech debt.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stk_f1eZ\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"OSopQ\" data-anim-trigger=\"sticky\" data-anim-sticky-offset=\"20\" data-anim-sticky-direction=\"top\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1 stk-theme_44178__mb_0\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">TABLE OF&nbsp;CONTENTS</strong></p><hr class=\"stk-theme_44178__separator_basic_divider stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\"/><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-1\">What is environmental tech debt?</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-2\">No new features, yet tech debt still accrues</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-3\">Tech debt example 1: User environment changes</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-4\">Tech debt example 2: Backwards compatibility in the HTML specification</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-5\">Tech debt example 3: Rich text editor security attacks and exposure</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"#stk-6\">Easiest way to avoid technical debt, is buying RTE components</a></p></div></div></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><h2 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\" id=\"stk-1\">What is environmental tech debt?</h2><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Programmer <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ward_Cunningham\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Ward Cunningham </a>originated the technical debt metaphor, in his <a href=\"http://c2.com/doc/oopsla92.html\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">1992 article</a>. A Google search uncovers many types of tech debt that have since been defined – especially seeing there's no rigid lines of delineation between what is and what isn’t considered tech debt. </p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Three key examples of technical debt that affect a rich text editor (RTE) are:</p><ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\"><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Environmental tech debt</strong> is technical debt that accumulates not because of anything <em class=\"stk-reset\">you do</em>, but because of changes in the <em class=\"stk-reset\">surrounding environment</em>. <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.splunk.com/en_us/data-insider/what-is-tech-debt.html\" target=\"_blank\">Splunk goes on to say</a> that “Failure to keep up with these changes will inevitably result in an application that no longer functions properly, and like any other form of tech debt, it is a problem that gets worse over time.”</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Intentional tech debt</strong> is technical debt that you’ve chosen to take on after weighing the pros and cons. <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.construx.com/10x_Software_Development/Technical_Debt/\" target=\"_blank\">Defined in 2007 by Steve McConnell</a>, he suggested that intentional technical debt is debt that’s taken on consciously as a strategic tool. </li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Unintentional tech debt</strong> is tech debt you don’t realize you’re choosing, often due to time constraints or a lack of knowledge. This type of tech debt is usually caused by internal factors and accrues while adding features, or because an aging codebase has started to accumulate cruft. In Steve McConnell’s words, he called it “the non-strategic result of doing a poor job.”</li></ul></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkHGId9\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkeWHiV\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"stk8f6MH\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"stkdwH9Z\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Insights on the complexities of RTEs</p></div></div><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stk9u1uW\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/buy-vs-build-whitepaper/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Buy vs Build: The Great Debate White Paper</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkayc-B\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/technical-debt-whitepaper/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Opportunity Cost of Technical Debt White Paper</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkaReP5\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/cost-of-building-rich-text-editor/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Tiny puts a price tag on building your own core rich text editor</a></p></div></div></div></div><figure class=\"stk-reset stk-image-figure\" data-ce-tag=\"image-figure\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-stk-css=\"stkejlVF\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-fadeIn\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\"><div class=\"stk-mask\" data-ce-tag=\"mask\"><img src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/ed0d959e-11f8-48de-9477-e5c731bd9d75/\" data-image-id=\"231432\" data-image-name=\"types-of-tech-debt.png\" width=\"1440\" height=\"960\" loading=\"lazy\" class=\"stk-image stk-reset\"/></div><figcaption style=\"display:block\" class=\"stk-reset stk-description\" data-ce-tag=\"description\"><a href=\"https://www.splunk.com/en_us/data-insider/what-is-tech-debt.html\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Source</a></figcaption></figure><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Following McConnell’s definition of intentional and unintentional tech debt, Martin Fowler took McConnell’s concept a step further and published what he calls the “<a href=\"https://martinfowler.com/bliki/TechnicalDebtQuadrant.html\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Technical Debt Quadrant.</a>”</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Each quadrant carries different opportunity costs and trade-offs, and seemingly small decisions can have big consequences.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, environmental tech debt differs from both intentional and unintentional debt, because you have no control over the timing, frequency or rationale behind the changes forced on your codebase. All you can control is the speed of response and level of domain expertise you apply to the issues.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"4\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><h2 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\" id=\"stk-2\">No new features, yet tech debt still accrues</h2><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">A rich text editor is inherently a very complicated application that accrues technical debt of its own accord, very easily. However, they also exist in a very complex environment. </p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">There’s a lengthy list of external factors that make rich text editors prone to accumulating environmental tech debt, simply by the very fact of them existing and functioning. For a rich text editor, the source of just a few of the many potentially dangerous examples of tech debt include:</p><ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\"><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Browser and OS changes</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">HTML, CSS, and JavaScript specification and implementation changes</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Changes to accessibility standards (e.g. WCAG and ARIA)</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Changes to accessibility tools (such as screen readers like Jaws)</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">New security exploits, and changes to security standards (e.g. OWASP’s annual Top 10)</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Privacy standard changes (e.g. GDPR and <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/soc2-compliance-meaning/\" target=\"_blank\">SOC2</a>)</li></ul><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Changes to any one (or all) of these factors likely requires your rich text editor to adapt. Often, each of these sources has its own inherent limitations and issues (i.e the cruft in the HTML specification – see Tech Debt Example 2) which you also need to work around. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For each and every environmental change and problem, there’s a decision to make: do you invest the time to deal with it, or do you take it on as environmental tech debt? </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">And, that’s just for the environmental issues you know about – if you miss the news about a change or don’t have the domain knowledge to spot a problem, you can get slammed by environmental tech debt with no warning. And it's well known you never knowingly accrue more technical debt (let alone unknown technical debt) that you have to pay off. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">To more clearly expose the potential dangers lurking in your rich text editor, here’s a few examples of tech debt that have had major consequences.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"4\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_2\" data-stk-css=\"stkznOtI\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-jackInTheBox\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"12\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_ver_2 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"2\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628585803915 align-center stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkV_kBW\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Get more insights in our<br>Technical Debt White Paper</p><a class=\"stk-theme_44178__stk-btn_1628586253530 stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628586133109 align-center stk-reset\" target=\"_blank\" data-stk-button=\"1\" data-ce-tag=\"button\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/technical-debt-whitepaper/\">READ THE WHITE PAPER</a></div><div data-col-width=\"2\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div></div></div><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"12\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Tech debt example 1</strong></p><h2 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\" id=\"stk-3\">User environment changes</h2><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">To behave correctly, a rich text editor has to account for the environment it runs in:</p><ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\"><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">The browser</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">The operating system, and </li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">The device/s its users use.</li></ul><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, browsers update constantly. Operating systems change in significant ways, overnight. And different device types can have very different needs and behaviors.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">It’s difficult to develop a rich text editor that accounts for all these complications, as well as the multiple environments that constantly change… unless you have deep domain knowledge of rich text editors and their idiosyncrasies. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">There’s worse news. Keeping track of all the changes that can </strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\">potentially</strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\"> cause you to accrue </strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\">environmental tech debt,</strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\"> is sometimes even harder than finding it all. </strong></p></div><div data-col-width=\"4\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"10\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><figure class=\"stk-reset stk-image-figure\" data-ce-tag=\"image-figure\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-stk-css=\"stkjAXoc\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-fadeIn\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\"><div class=\"stk-mask\" data-ce-tag=\"mask\"><img src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/1b60d796-8df2-4294-ba98-64083ed6f9d4/\" data-image-id=\"232076\" data-image-name=\"1.png\" class=\"stk-image stk-reset\" width=\"2280\" height=\"1148\" loading=\"lazy\"/></div></figure></div><div data-col-width=\"2\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><h3 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_medium_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editor tech debt example: Chrome User Agent changes</h3><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">One complication that ensues from functioning within so many environments, is that the creation and maintenance of a great user experience (UX), sometimes requires environment-specific code. For example, customizing shortcuts for MacOS and Windows, or switching mouse clicks for touch gestures on phones and tablets. Or even fixing browser-specific bugs with code that only runs on that browser.</p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">One way to differentiate environments is by using the browser’s User Agent string. However, this browser feature is under heavy debate, and has been for quite some years.</p><h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><img alt=\"\" class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3670816 stk-icon\" src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/1c438f98-3b66-4bd6-ad65-64f9781952a1/\">&nbsp;Customisation vs end-user privacy</h4><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Unfortunately, the same features that make the User Agent string great for UX, also make it bad for privacy – because it can be used by bad actors to grab end-user data without their knowledge. This has led to far reaching discussions within the engineering community, about restricting or even replacing the User Agent string.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkBpZPo\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkJEN4L\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"stkFZ0ZI\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"stk4uHTB\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">User agents are a complicated topic</p></div></div><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stk2_oEX\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">This <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Browser_detection_using_the_user_agent\" target=\"_blank\">MDN article about browser detection using the user agent</a> explains what user agents can and can’t be used for, and the privacy risks inherent to user agents.</p></div></div></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"11\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><figure class=\"stk-reset stk-image-figure\" data-ce-tag=\"image-figure\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-stk-css=\"stkbmFVi\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-fadeIn\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\"><div class=\"stk-mask\" data-ce-tag=\"mask\"><img src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/00bc99cb-27b1-45c8-8911-ee32cc11eac9/\" data-image-id=\"232078\" data-image-name=\"2.png\" class=\"stk-image stk-reset\" width=\"3792\" height=\"2150\" loading=\"lazy\"/></div><figcaption style=\"display:block\" class=\"stk-reset stk-description\" data-ce-tag=\"description\">User Agent string example on various browsers</figcaption></figure></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><img alt=\"\" class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3670816 stk-icon\" src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/1c438f98-3b66-4bd6-ad65-64f9781952a1/\">&nbsp;The Chrome User Agent saga</h4><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Some parts of the User Agent string have already been frozen, resulting in <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/web-platform/how-to-detect-win11\" target=\"_blank\">Windows 11</a> and <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23910280\" target=\"_blank\">MacOS Big Sur</a> onwards being reported as previous OS versions. Whereas <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Browser_detection_using_the_user_agent\" target=\"_blank\">MDN already recommends using feature detection and other methods</a> instead of the User Agent string. But one of the most controversial and debated changes has been <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/User-Agent_Client_Hints_API\" target=\"_blank\">Chrome's User Agent Client Hints API</a>.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">In January 2020, <a href=\"https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/g/blink-dev/c/-2JIRNMWJ7s/m/yHe4tQNLCgAJ?pli=1\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Chrome announced a plan to freeze and deprecate the User Agent string</a> and replace it with the User Agent Client Hints (UA-CH) API. Compared to the User Agent string – which makes a lot of data easily accessible – UA-CH would only provide specific information to websites, if they requested it, and only over a secure connection.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">This would be a great step forward for privacy. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, other browsers haven’t adopted UA-CH, and there are many concerns about whether UA-CH is a sufficiently strong enough replacement for the User Agent string. There are also concerns about how much development work is required to adjust to using UA-CH.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">To their credit, Chrome has delayed and changed their plans several times in response to feedback. Unfortunately, this has created uncertainty around what changes will happen, and when.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Across the world, software companies are keeping a close eye on Chrome’s announcements. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">And given the work required to adjust, decisions have had to be made about whether to change code ahead of time, or wait until change is a requirement. <strong class=\"stk-reset\">In other words, engineering teams everywhere are deciding whether to add the User Agent string to their pile of </strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\">intentional technical debt </strong><strong class=\"stk-reset\">that’s accumulating, or whether to pay it down.</strong></p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, browser changes aren't the only problem. The opposite can be just as bad, too.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkjqjKY\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Timeline of Chrome’s User-Agent announcements</strong></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/user-agent-reduction-oct-2022-updates/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Aug 2022: \"Prepare for User-Agent Reduction changes in October\"</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/user-agent-reduction-deprecation-trial/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Feb 2022: \"Prepare for User-Agent Reduction changes in October\"</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/force-major-version-to-100/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Nov 2021: \"Force Chrome major version to 100 in the User-Agent string\"</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/docs/privacy-sandbox/user-agent/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Nov 2021 (updated July 2022): \"User-Agent reduction\"</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://developer.chrome.com/blog/user-agent-reduction-origin-trial/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Sept 2021 (updated Jan 2022): \"User-Agent Reduction origin trial\"</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_0 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/g/blink-dev/c/-2JIRNMWJ7s/m/yHe4tQNLCgAJ?pli=1\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Jan 2020: \"Intent to Deprecate and Freeze: The User-Agent string\"</a></p></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"12\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Tech debt example 2</p><h2 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\" id=\"stk-4\">Backwards compatibility in the HTML specification</h2><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">At first glance, tables might seem like a simple concept. However, in reality, working with HTML tables is very difficult – especially in rich text editors.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The HTML specification for tables has changed a lot since <a href=\"https://www.w3.org/TR/2018/SPSD-html32-20180315/#table\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">tables were first added in HTML 3.2</a>. However, in order to not break old websites that are using old features, browsers tend to support both the new features <em class=\"stk-reset\">and</em> the old ones. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">This makes HTML tables a nightmare of cruft and tech debt – and rich text editors potentially have to implement and support the entire resulting mess.</strong></p></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkQ7hWo\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_0\" data-stk-css=\"stkea3wZ\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"stkKTrXf\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">FURTHER INSIGHTS</strong></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkhR8k6\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"stksCeD1\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><figure class=\"stk-reset stk-image-figure\" data-ce-tag=\"image-figure\"><div class=\"stk-mask\" data-ce-tag=\"mask\"><img src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/0a6e3096-31e2-4472-8631-4dbc1bb5d260/\" data-image-id=\"202975\" data-image-name=\"Tech Debt -2.png\" class=\"stk-image stk-reset\" width=\"640\" height=\"386\" loading=\"lazy\"/></div></figure></div></div><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stklrTMY\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/technical-debt-whitepaper\" target=\"_blank\">Download and read Technical Debt in Rich Text Editors White Paper →</a></p></div></div></div></div><figure class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-reset stk-image-figure\" data-ce-tag=\"image-figure\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-stk-css=\"stkBGQll\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-fadeIn\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\"><div class=\"stk-mask\" data-ce-tag=\"mask\"><img src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/5e72d944-7366-4058-9bd1-722861a6600c/\" data-image-id=\"231434\" data-image-name=\"standards_2x.png\" width=\"1000\" height=\"567\" loading=\"lazy\" class=\"stk-image stk-reset\"/></div><figcaption style=\"display:block\" class=\"stk-reset stk-description\" data-ce-tag=\"description\">The infamous XKCD comic regarding standards proliferation, from <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://xkcd.com/927/\" target=\"_blank\">https://xkcd.com/927/</a></figcaption></figure><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><h3 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_medium_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editor tech debt example: RTE table complexities</h3><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Table support is one of the most complicated pieces of the TinyMCE codebase. It spans several libraries and modules, including:</p><ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\"><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">Advanced Tables premium plugin</strong> repository, which implements advanced features like sorting</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><a href=\"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/tinymce/src/plugins/table\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">Tables plugin</strong></a> module, which implements basic features like styling and adding rows and columns</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><a href=\"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/snooker\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">Snooker</strong> module</a>, which handles manipulating table HTML for the plugin features</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><a href=\"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/darwin\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">Darwin</strong> module</a>, which handles selection in tables</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\"><a href=\"https://github.com/tinymce/tinymce/tree/develop/modules/tinymce/src/models/dom/main/ts/table\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">The <strong class=\"stk-reset\">DOM Table Model</strong></a>, which adds basic table support to the TinyMCE core editor</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Several more libraries and modules which are shared with other parts of TinyMCE core editor</li></ul></div><div data-col-width=\"4\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"10\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><figure class=\"stk-reset stk-image-figure\" data-ce-tag=\"image-figure\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-stk-css=\"stkBVL_D\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-fadeIn\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\"><div class=\"stk-mask\" data-ce-tag=\"mask\"><img src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/819b0b65-7a9a-49b3-b9ba-9c9f4efa847c/\" data-image-id=\"232077\" data-image-name=\"3.png\" class=\"stk-image stk-reset\" width=\"2280\" height=\"1456\" loading=\"lazy\"/></div></figure></div><div data-col-width=\"2\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">A lot of the complexity in TinyMCE’s table code is caused by having to absorb and handle the environmental tech debt inherent in the HTML specification for tables, and the way the various browsers implement it. Why bother to do that? Because otherwise bad things happen.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Put simply, unless you ensure the table HTML can be absorbed, your whole rich text editor breaks when a user copy-pastes content from anywhere, into the table.</strong></p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">However, to handle the HTML specifications, there’s only two alternatives: add explicit support for it, or do the absolute minimum to prevent the editor breaking… and assign any further support to your tech debt pile. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">But remember… for every feature you do support for the HTML specifications, your code complexity grows, again making the code more prone to accruing tech debt. It’s almost a no-win situation for rich text editors.</strong></p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Let’s look at two examples of technical debt in TinyMCE’s table code.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"4\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><img alt=\"\" class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3670816 stk-icon\" src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/1c438f98-3b66-4bd6-ad65-64f9781952a1/\">&nbsp;Small table changes = big table problems</h4><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The modularisation of TinyMCE’s table code usually makes development easier by isolating code for specific functionality into specific places. However, it doesn’t completely remove the risk of changes in one library, causing ripples across the entire dependency tree.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For example, a bug fix in the Snooker module might require changes to every other library. While a new feature in the Advanced Tables premium plugin might require cascading changes all the way down to the DOM Table Model. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">This makes it easy to accrue unintentional tech debt, if you miss seeing the side-effect of a change made. And, if a fix or feature snowballs because of the ripple effect, you may well have to choose between technical debt or meeting your launch deadline. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The only real way to mitigate these issues is tapping into the deep domain knowledge of rich text editor specialists, like TinyMCE, and accessing their inhouse developer expertise.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkyGcm3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkJF7V7\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"stkXuPVn\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"stkncsJ7\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">More insights on the complexities of RTEs</p></div></div><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stkgDC_q\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/reduce-technical-debt/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Reduce technical debt with the right rich text editor</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkInzC1\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/manage-technical-debt/\" target=\"_blank\">Managing technical debt is difficult in rich text editors</a></p></div></div></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><img alt=\"\" class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3670816 stk-icon\" src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/1c438f98-3b66-4bd6-ad65-64f9781952a1/\">&nbsp;Big table codebase = big table mess</h4><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Complex code tends to breed cruft, code rot, and tech debt, and TinyMCE’s table code isn’t immune. Bug fixes are fine, but occasionally, implementing new features can hit roadblocks. And sometimes, all the future-proofing and good design you’ve done can’t save you from needing to just rewrite the code.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For example, Advanced Tables (premium) was originally designed to only enable table sorting. It was well-designed, but a bit rushed and very focused. This caused issues when adding new features, due to how different the new features were, from sorting. In the end, it was more efficient to replace large amounts of the original code than to try to fit the new features into the old code.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid stk-grid__layout_reverse\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"2\" class=\"stk-grid-col align-right stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><figure class=\"stk-reset stk-image-figure stk-mobile-hidden\" data-ce-tag=\"image-figure\"><div class=\"stk-mask\" data-ce-tag=\"mask\"><img src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/c42efec4-bbc2-4be7-8708-9f499a156039/\" data-image-id=\"198625\" data-image-name=\"arrow-2022091908490909.svg\" loading=\"lazy\" class=\"stk-image stk-reset\" width=\"14\" height=\"17\"/></div></figure><p class=\"align-right stk-reset align-left-m stk-theme_44178__style_small_text\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The 3-year Aggregate Decay in an Advanced Tables plugin Individual commits in a repo, by yearly cohorts, across 3 years</p></div><div data-col-width=\"10\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><figure class=\"stk-reset stk-image-figure\" data-ce-tag=\"image-figure\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-stk-css=\"stkJeg0Z\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-fadeIn\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\"><div class=\"stk-mask\" data-ce-tag=\"mask\"><img src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/87483fe5-eccc-4748-b935-9455a730c645/\" data-image-id=\"200721\" data-image-name=\"Group 21.png\" loading=\"lazy\" class=\"stk-image stk-reset\" width=\"1315\" height=\"816\"/></div><figcaption style=\"display:block\" class=\"stk-reset stk-description\" data-ce-tag=\"description\">The half-life of code in the Advanced Tables repository. In the three years since it was created, over 80% of its code has already been replaced.</figcaption></figure></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">If HTML tables weren’t so complicated, or browsers could support only the newest table features without breaking half the internet, this likely wouldn’t have been necessary. But that’s not possible, and it’s not unique to rich text editor’s table features and plugins.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">It applies to many aspects of rich text editors and why their code half-life is so short.</strong> </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">You may be tempted to think that tables are fairly low risk, if you decide to relegate any improvements to your ever growing list of technical debt. But other aspects of rich text editors are much more dangerous. They need attention. Now.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkzFN5f\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkf4tW5\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"stk-qD2s\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"stkOf_hd\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Is your code’s half-life this short?</p></div></div><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stk9dunH\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/blog/rte-code-half-life/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Is your code half-life shorter than your engineering career</a></p></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"12\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Tech debt example 3</p><h2 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\" id=\"stk-5\">Rich text editor security attacks and exposure</h2><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Privacy and security are always a key concern when handling user input. In a plain text form, the ways to mitigate the usual risks are well known and documented. However, rich text editors are much rarer, and much more complicated.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Security attacks can target the editor itself, the application it’s embedded in, the environment in which it’s running, or the server where the editor content is eventually saved. </strong></p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">XSS attacks, DOM clobbering, JavaScript prototype pollution and structural damage to the HTML are all attack types you have to mitigate. Every rich text editor feature you add, has to be checked for privacy violations. And on top of all that, there are security and privacy standards that need to be met, such as SOC2. </p></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkHbTMj\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397 stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">What is SOC2?</strong></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Paraphrasing <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://secureframe.com/hub/soc-2/what-is-soc-2\" target=\"_blank\">Secureframe, a SOC2 audit looks at how</a>&nbsp;<a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://secureframe.com/hub/soc-2/what-is-soc-2\" target=\"_blank\">a company handles user data</a> with regards to its security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy. </p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Many big software companies, such as <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://cloud.google.com/security/compliance/soc-2\" target=\"_blank\">Google</a> and <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.atlassian.com/trust/compliance/resources/soc2\" target=\"_blank\">Atlassian</a>, as well as open source maintainers like <a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://blog.tidelift.com/tidelift-completes-soc-2-type-2-examination\" target=\"_blank\">Tidelift</a>, publicize their SOC2 attainment and results.</p></div></div></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">There’s a lot to manage, with rich text editor security:</p><ul class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"list\"><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Defending against attack vectors</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Protecting your users’ privacy</li><li class=\"stk-reset stk-list-item\" data-ce-tag=\"list-item\">Meeting the relevant standards. </li></ul><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">All that takes time and domain expertise in rich text editors. And it isn’t a one-off problem. New vulnerabilities are constantly being found. New attacks are constantly being reported. Privacy standards are constantly changing. It doesn't ever end.</p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For rich text editors, it’s never-ending work, and relegating tasks to the tech debt ‘fix later’ list can be dangerous, especially when it comes to security issues. Sometimes though, the really hard issues just <em class=\"stk-reset\">have</em> to be fixed.</p><h3 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_medium_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Rich text editor tech debt example: DOM Parsing update in TinyMCE 6.0</h3><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">HTML is a very flexible markup language, and that means it has hundreds if not thousands of security vulnerabilities. Both CSS and JavaScript also have their own plethora of issues. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">A HTML-based rich text editor has to handle all these vulnerabilities.</strong></p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The TinyMCE rich text editor does this by parsing and sanitizing every piece of content added to the editor – whether it comes from code, the clipboard, or a user typing something. Doing this without affecting the performance of the editor (or affecting other editor features) is a considerable <em class=\"stk-reset\">mission</em>. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">That’s why TinyMCE recently switched its in-house DOM parser and sanitizer, for a third-party tool.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkVMzO6\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397 stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">What is the OWASP Foundation?</strong></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://owasp.org/\" target=\"_blank\">The Open Web Application Security Project® (OWASP)</a> is a nonprofit foundation and community that works to improve the security of software. </p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">It conducts community-led open-source software projects, educational and training conferences, and produces freely-available articles, methodologies, documentation, tools, and technologies in the field of web application security.</p></div></div></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><img alt=\"\" class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3670816 stk-icon\" src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/1c438f98-3b66-4bd6-ad65-64f9781952a1/\">&nbsp;Build our own or buy it?</h4><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">TinyMCE is an editor with heritage. For many years, handling the security of its content was something our engineers solely handled, because there were no third-party libraries available to use. Therefore, we reacted quickly when a new exploit was discovered, and easily customized the parsing and sanitizing to our needs. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">However, it also required a lot of work.</strong></p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Recent years have seen an increase in the number and complexity of known vulnerabilities. The domain knowledge required to ensure the security of a rich text editor has grown in relation to that, and the amount of code needed to mitigate all the potential attacks has exploded.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stki8_oo\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkRsmPy\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"stkt9lPU\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">read MORE</strong></p></div></div><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stkrsSKO\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://owasp.org/www-project-top-ten/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">The OWASP Top Ten</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkxEV8a\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://cheatsheetseries.owasp.org/cheatsheets/HTML5_Security_Cheat_Sheet.html\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">HTML5 Security Cheat Sheet</a></p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stk6Ja_V\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://cheatsheetseries.owasp.org/cheatsheets/XSS_Filter_Evasion_Cheat_Sheet.html\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">XSS Filter Cheat Sheet</a></p></div></div></div></div><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_15 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">At the same time, industry standards have appeared, and seemingly stabilized. Whole new industries have grown up around software security and privacy, while security tools have improved by leaps and bounds.</p><table data-responsive-type=\"cards\" class=\"stk-table--bordered_h stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__var_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset stk-table\" data-ce-tag=\"table\"><colgroup><col class=\"stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset\" data-stk-id=\"1118\"/><col class=\"stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset\" data-stk-id=\"1119\"/><col class=\"stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset stk-reset\" data-stk-id=\"1120\"/></colgroup><thead class=\"stk-reset\"><tr class=\"stk-reset stk-table-row\"><th class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"th\"></th><th class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"th\">In-house DOM Parser</th><th class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"th\">Third-party DOM Parser</th></tr></thead><tbody class=\"stk-reset\"><tr class=\"stk-reset stk-table-row\"><td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Pros</strong></td><td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\" data-cell-header=\"In-house DOM Parser\">Can be easily customized, and quickly patched when new exploits are found.</td><td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\" data-cell-header=\"Third-party DOM Parser\">Maintenance overhead is passed to third-party developers.</td></tr><tr class=\"stk-reset stk-table-row\"><td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Cons</strong></td><td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\" data-cell-header=\"In-house DOM Parser\">Maintenance costs grow as the age and complexity of the code increases.</td><td class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset stk-table-cell\" data-ce-tag=\"td\" data-cell-header=\"Third-party DOM Parser\">Reliance on a third-party to be responsive and maintain a high quality.</td></tr></tbody></table><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Switching to a third-party security solution was a difficult decision. As was finding the right tool and implementing the switch. However, it was necessary.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">TinyMCE’s DOM parser was a big, complex piece of code that only a few developers understood, and working on it was fraught with complications and delays. Plus, the volume of maintenance and tech debt wasn’t sustainable, on top of every other moving part in the rich text editor and 50+ plugins. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">However, not fixing security issues wasn’t an option. The risks associated with accumulating security tech debt are much too high.</strong></p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">In the end, switching to an industry-standard, third-party security solution that’s maintained by experts, was a win-win for everyone: Tiny spends more time on rich text editing – our area of expertise – and our users receive the high security standards they expect, and need.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-stk-css=\"stkD4Y_X\" data-anim-zoom=\"100\" data-anim-shift=\"40\" data-anim-rotation=\"0\" data-anim-opacity=\"100\" data-anim-direction=\"right\" data-anim-duration=\"0.8\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-sticky-direction=\"top\" data-anim-sticky-offset=\"20\" data-anim-name=\"aDQKFS\" data-anim=\"true\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stkoxIzS\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"stkGtSQ5\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">FURTHER INSIGHTS</strong></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkJftA2\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last valign-bottom\" data-stk-css=\"stkImVIj\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><figure class=\"stk-reset stk-image-figure stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stkHo0jA\" data-ce-tag=\"image-figure\"><div class=\"stk-mask\" data-ce-tag=\"mask\"><a href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/buy-vs-build-whitepaper-opt-in \" class=\"stk-reset stk-link\" target=\"_blank\"><img src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/fa2c6f05-c295-484d-b3cb-e56dcd64a392/\" data-image-id=\"134877\" data-image-name=\"frame-30-copy-2021110813411567.svg\" class=\"stk-image stk-reset\" loading=\"lazy\" width=\"1138\" height=\"1000\"/></a></div></figure></div></div><p class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937\" data-stk-css=\"stk-5MBp\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a class=\"stk-reset\" href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/buy-vs-build-whitepaper/\" target=\"_blank\">Download and read Build vs Buy White Paper →</a></p></div></div></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><img alt=\"\" class=\"stk-reset stk-theme_44178__symbol_custom_image_3670816 stk-icon\" src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/1c438f98-3b66-4bd6-ad65-64f9781952a1/\">&nbsp;Protecting user privacy</h4><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The flip side of rich text editor security is privacy. While rich text editors mostly only deal with user input within the user’s browser, any data that’s collected from the editor or transferred elsewhere must follow privacy best practices. Otherwise, you’re liable for data breaches – whether that’s during data transfer or while it’s stored in your servers.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Similar to security, privacy is another aspect of rich text editor development, where taking on tech debt can be very risky.</strong> </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Data management must be implemented right the first time – and it needs to be regularly maintained. Especially when new laws or standards are introduced, such as <a href=\"https://gdpr-info.eu/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Europe’s GDPR</a>. </p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">For TinyMCE, one of our biggest privacy challenges came with the implementation of our Real-time Collaboration (RTC) premium plugin. By nature, RTC functionality requires user data to be transmitted over the internet, so that users can <em class=\"stk-reset\">see</em> what others are doing. Doing that securely, without overly impacting the plugin’s functionality was complex work, and required us to implement new features such as <a href=\"https://www.tiny.cloud/docs/tinymce/6/how-the-rtc-plugin-encrypts-content/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">content encryption during transmission</a>. </p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">NOTE:&nbsp;</strong>From January 2023, TinyMCE no longer offers Real-Time Collaboration (RTC) for new customers. For Existing customers, we'll be in contact to discuss options. Please reach out to your Account Manager if you are a customer using RTC, and you have any questions about the plugin.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">This was a case where technical debt needed to be carefully managed, to ensure its negative consequences didn’t exceed its advantages.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">In the case of RTC, if we hadn’t put the work in to protect our users' privacy and data, and had instead relegated such measures to technical debt work to be scheduled, it would have resulted in unacceptable risks to users’ security and privacy.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Our goal has never been to reach zero tech debt. Because sometimes, some debt has been a good thing for our growth. Why’s that?</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Ideally, a ‘Goldilocks level of tech debt’ is what you want to carry – not too much, not too little. Your tech debt management plan needs to balance growth aspirations and housekeeping duties, to ensure you’re continuing to deliver value at high speed, without sacrificing quality, security or privacy.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">But there is another way to minimize your tech debt.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkgAJjW\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\" data-anim-m=\"false\" data-anim=\"true\" data-anim-name=\"preset-slideInRight\" data-anim-trigger=\"scroll\" data-anim-duration=\"1\" data-anim-delay=\"0\" data-anim-scroll-start=\"10\" data-anim-scroll-finish=\"90\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkVg3as\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"3\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-stk-css=\"stkhGEMT\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_4\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><strong class=\"stk-reset\">Reading resources</strong></p></div></div><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__mb_05\" data-stk-css=\"stkf5Dfv\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://developer.atlassian.com/platform/marketplace/data-privacy-guidelines/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">Atlassian’s data privacy guidelines</a> are a great rundown of privacy best practices.</p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stk9LMRn\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"><a href=\"https://web.dev/learn/forms/security-privacy/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">web.dev’s lesson on forms and privacy</a> has several useful examples.</p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-reset\" data-stk-css=\"stkWXTqY\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Firewall Times maintains <a href=\"https://firewalltimes.com/recent-data-breaches/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"stk-reset\">a terrifying timeline of recent data breaches</a>.</p></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class=\"stk-theme_44178__mb_2 stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><h2 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_large_header stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\" id=\"stk-6\">Easiest way to avoid technical debt, is buying RTE components</h2><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Cost drives much of today’s technology.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">The typical cost of managing the technical debt generated by a rich text editor – and its advanced features – isn’t small. As you can see, even discussing the possibility of adding functionality or fixing a bug and then deciding not to do it, takes time.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">And the more rework you have to do, the higher the price tag and opportunities lost.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">By curating a repository of vetted, pre-approved components and release versions (open source, purchased and subscribed), you’re minimizing security exposures, ongoing maintenance and technical debt accumulation. The components can be safely used and reused within your tech stack, across the enterprise.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">That allows your development work to quickly move, more safely, and avoids last-minute blockers during a development cycle.</p><p class=\"stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Assembling pre-approved specialist components lets you safely walk the tightrope between technical debt and innovation. And it maximizes your opportunity cost.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"4\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-layout__overhangs_both stk-theme_44178__mb_0 stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkl-1FZ\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"12\" class=\"stk-theme_44178__pad_ver_2 stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"2\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"align-center stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1652351628236 stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Download the white paper</p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628585803915 align-center stk-reset stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_1\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Opportunity Cost of Technical Debt: Minimize Your Rich Text Editor Development</p></div><div data-col-width=\"2\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"2\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"8\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><figure class=\"stk-reset stk-embed_rendered\" data-ce-tag=\"embed\"><code class=\"stk-code\"><iframe src=\"https://www2.ephox.com/l/2202/2022-09-29/d9d458\" width=\"100%\" height=\"500\" type=\"text/html\" frameborder=\"0\" allowtransparency=\"true\" style=\"border: 0\"></iframe></code><figcaption class=\"stk-reset stk-description\" data-ce-tag=\"description\"></figcaption></figure></div><div data-col-width=\"2\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div></div></div><div class=\"stk-layout__overhangs_both stk-grid\" data-stk-css=\"stkEIBtG\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"12\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last stk-theme_44178__pad_ver_3\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><div class=\"stk-grid\" data-ce-tag=\"grid\"><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div><div data-col-width=\"4\" class=\"stk-grid-col\" data-stk-css=\"\" data-stk-css-m=\"\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><figure class=\"stk-blueprint--avatar stk-reset stk-image-figure\" data-stk-css=\"stk-NM-i\" data-ce-tag=\"image-figure\"><div class=\"stk-mask\" data-ce-tag=\"mask\"><img src=\"https://ucarecdn.com/1a5df2bb-82ec-41ae-ba94-e2c4cdaff4bd/\" data-image-id=\"221200\" data-image-name=\"1548508487603.jpeg\" class=\"stk-image stk-reset\" width=\"471\" height=\"471\" loading=\"lazy\"/></div></figure></div><div data-col-width=\"6\" class=\"valign-middle stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_last stk-theme_44178__pad_round_1-m\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517328397 stk-theme_44178__mb_05 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_3 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">author</p><h4 class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_header stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_0 stk-theme_44178__mb_0 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Millie Macdonald</h4><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_font_style-1628517714937 stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_2 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Product Manager at Halo Connect</p><p class=\"stk-theme_44178__style_small_text stk-theme_44178__color_44178_custom_color_0 stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\">Millie is a Product Manager at Halo Connect who dabbles in writing. Previously, she worked at Tiny as a Product Owner, dev, and QA engineer. She loves learning above all else, whether it's about people, tech, or leadership.</p></div><div data-col-width=\"1\" class=\"stk-grid-col stk-grid-col_empty\" data-ce-tag=\"grid-col\"><p class=\"ce-element--empty stk-element_no-text stk-reset\" data-ce-tag=\"paragraph\"></p></div></div></div></div><style data-stk-css=\"stkJeg0Z\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkJeg0Z\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {}\n</style><style data-anim-name=\"preset-fadeIn\" media=\"screen and (min-width: 768px)\" class=\"\">\n      .stk-post [data-anim-name=\"preset-fadeIn\"]:not(#stk):not([data-anim=\"false\"]) {\n        opacity: 0\n      }</style><style data-anim-name=\"preset-fadeIn\" media=\"screen and (max-width: 767px)\" class=\"\">\n      .stk-post [data-anim-name=\"preset-fadeIn\"]:not(#stk):not([data-anim-m]),\n      .stk-post [data-anim-name=\"preset-fadeIn\"]:not(#stk):not([data-anim-m=\"false\"]) {\n        opacity: 0\n      }</style><script data-anim-name=\"preset-fadeIn\" type=\"application/json\" class=\"\">{\"keyframes\":[{\"opacity\":0,\"offset\":0},{\"opacity\":1,\"offset\":1}],\"options\":{\"id\":\"preset-fadeIn\",\"delay\":0,\"duration\":1000}}</script><style data-stk-css=\"stkD4Y_X\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkD4Y_X\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {}\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkoxIzS\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkoxIzS\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    border-bottom: 1px solid #4D66CB\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkGtSQ5\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkGtSQ5\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkJftA2\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkJftA2\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    background-color: #00C0CD\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkImVIj\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkImVIj\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkHo0jA\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkHo0jA\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    width: 180px;\n    align-self: center\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stk-5MBp\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stk-5MBp\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 0px 10px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-anim-name=\"aDQKFS\" media=\"screen and (min-width: 768px)\" class=\"\">\n  .stk-post [data-anim-name=\"aDQKFS\"]:not(#stk):not([data-anim=\"false\"]) {\n    transform: translateX(-40px)\n  }\n</style><style data-anim-name=\"aDQKFS\" media=\"screen and (max-width: 767px)\" class=\"\">\n  .stk-post [data-anim-name=\"aDQKFS\"]:not(#stk):not([data-anim-m]),\n  .stk-post [data-anim-name=\"aDQKFS\"]:not(#stk):not([data-anim-m=\"false\"]) {\n    transform: translateX(-40px)\n  }\n</style><script type=\"application/json\" data-anim-name=\"aDQKFS\" class=\"\">\n  {\n    \"keyframes\": [{\n      \"transform\": \"translateX(-40px)\"\n    }, {\n      \"transform\": \"none\"\n    }],\n    \"options\": {\n      \"id\": \"aDQKFS\",\n      \"delay\": 0,\n      \"duration\": 800\n    }\n  }\n</script><style data-stk-css=\"stkEIBtG\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkEIBtG\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    background-color: rgba(16, 24, 55, 1)\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stk-NM-i\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stk-NM-i\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    --avatar-size: 180px;\n    align-self: center\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkl-1FZ\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkl-1FZ\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){background-color: rgba(249, 250, 251, 1)}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkgAJjW\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkgAJjW\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){border: 1px solid #4D66CB; border-radius: 4px; box-shadow: 10px 10px 0 -1px #fff, 10px 10px #4D66CB}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkVg3as\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkVg3as\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    border-bottom: 1px solid #4D66CB\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkhGEMT\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkhGEMT\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkf5Dfv\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkf5Dfv\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 0px 10px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stk9LMRn\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stk9LMRn\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){padding: 0px 10px 10px}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkWXTqY\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkWXTqY\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){padding: 0px 10px 10px}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stki8_oo\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stki8_oo\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){border: 1px solid #4D66CB; border-radius: 4px; box-shadow: 10px 10px 0 -1px #fff, 10px 10px #4D66CB}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkRsmPy\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkRsmPy\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    border-bottom: 1px solid #4D66CB\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkt9lPU\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkt9lPU\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkrsSKO\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkrsSKO\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 0px 10px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkVMzO6\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkVMzO6\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    background-color: #F9FAFB;\n    border-radius: 4px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkHbTMj\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkHbTMj\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    background-color: #F9FAFB;\n    border-radius: 4px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkzFN5f\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkzFN5f\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){border: 1px solid #4D66CB; border-radius: 4px; box-shadow: 10px 10px 0 -1px #fff, 10px 10px #4D66CB}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkf4tW5\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkf4tW5\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    border-bottom: 1px solid #4D66CB\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stk-qD2s\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stk-qD2s\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkOf_hd\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkOf_hd\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stk9dunH\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stk9dunH\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 0px 10px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkyGcm3\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkyGcm3\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){border: 1px solid #4D66CB; border-radius: 4px; box-shadow: 10px 10px 0 -1px #fff, 10px 10px #4D66CB}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkJF7V7\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkJF7V7\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    border-bottom: 1px solid #4D66CB\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkXuPVn\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkXuPVn\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkncsJ7\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkncsJ7\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkgDC_q\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkgDC_q\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 0px 10px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkInzC1\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkInzC1\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){padding: 0px 10px 10px}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkQ7hWo\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkQ7hWo\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){border: 1px solid #4D66CB; border-radius: 4px; box-shadow: 10px 10px 0 -1px #fff, 10px 10px #4D66CB}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkea3wZ\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkea3wZ\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    border-bottom: 1px solid #4D66CB\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkKTrXf\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkKTrXf\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkhR8k6\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkhR8k6\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){background: #D3E1E6}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stksCeD1\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stksCeD1\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stklrTMY\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stklrTMY\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 0px 10px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkjqjKY\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkjqjKY\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    background-color: #F9FAFB;\n    border-radius: 4px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkBpZPo\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkBpZPo\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){border: 1px solid #4D66CB; border-radius: 4px; box-shadow: 10px 10px 0 -1px #fff, 10px 10px #4D66CB}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkJEN4L\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkJEN4L\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    border-bottom: 1px solid #4D66CB\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkFZ0ZI\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkFZ0ZI\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stk4uHTB\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stk4uHTB\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stk2_oEX\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stk2_oEX\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 0px 10px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkznOtI\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkznOtI\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){background: #CFE3E6}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkV_kBW\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkV_kBW\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){color: #000}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkHGId9\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkHGId9\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){border: 1px solid #4D66CB; border-radius: 4px; box-shadow: 10px 10px 0 -1px #fff, 10px 10px #4D66CB}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkeWHiV\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkeWHiV\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    border-bottom: 1px solid #4D66CB\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stk8f6MH\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stk8f6MH\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkdwH9Z\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stkdwH9Z\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 5px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stk9u1uW\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">\n  [data-stk-css=\"stk9u1uW\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style) {\n    padding: 0px 10px 10px\n  }\n</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkayc-B\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkayc-B\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){padding: 0px 10px 10px}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkaReP5\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkaReP5\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){padding: 0px 10px 10px}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stk_f1eZ\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stk_f1eZ\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){border: 1px solid #4D66CB; border-radius: 4px; box-shadow: 10px 10px 0 -1px #fff, 10px 10px #4D66CB; --stk-sticky-offset: 20px}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkxEV8a\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkxEV8a\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){padding: 0px 10px 10px}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stk6Ja_V\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stk6Ja_V\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){padding: 0px 10px 10px}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkejlVF\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkejlVF\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkjAXoc\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkjAXoc\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkbmFVi\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkbmFVi\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkBGQll\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkBGQll\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){}</style><style data-stk-css=\"stkBVL_D\" class=\"\" media=\"all\">[data-stk-css=\"stkBVL_D\"]:not(#stk):not(#stk):not(style){}</style></div>","id":"455ca630-b932-5180-adbf-c7e25fb2e4eb"},"resourceFiles":null,"canonicalUrl":null}},"pageContext":{"slug":"technical-debt-examples","setkaPostId":26694}},"staticQueryHashes":["2492987505","740350947"]}